Bernard Williams
12,258 Followers
Recent papers in Bernard Williams
In her influential and challenging paper “Skepticism about Practical Reason” Christine Korsgaard sets out to refute an important strand of Humean scepticism as it concerns a Kantian understanding of practical reason.1 Korsgaard... more
Agent-regret seems to give rise to a philosophical puzzle. If we grant that we are not morally responsible for consequences outside of our control (the 'Standard View'), then agent-regret—which involves self-reproach and a desire to make... more
In "Freedom and Resentment" P.F. Strawson, famously, advances a strong form of naturalism that aims to discredit kcepticism about moral responsibility by way of approaching these issues through an account of our reactive attitudes.... more
In this paper I deal with the concept of "practical identity " and its role in our moral lives. Starting from the notion of integrity, as introduced by Bernard Williams, I add discussion of materials from Gary Watson and Harry Frankfurt... more
This paper makes an initial attempt to redescribe the failure of racial equality in America by making use of the idea of tragedy. I offer a reading of Antigone to stabilize the appropriateness of three ideas in support of reading the... more
The article examines whether realist theory should adopt a philosophical anarchist position concerning political obligation. The conclusions are mixed. Drawing on a distinction between strong and weak theories of political obligation (in... more
Artykuł stanowi uzupełnienie debaty na temat wartościowania nieśmiertelności poprzez wskazanie na możliwość zastosowania w dyskusji na jej temat wczesnej filozofii Martina Heideggera. Interpretacji poddane zostało opowiadanie Jorge Louisa... more
Much of the literature on the desirability of immortality (inspired by B. Williams) has considered whether the goods of mortal life would be exhausted in an immortal life (whether, i.e., immortality would necessarily end in tedium).... more
What is it to have a reason to do something? is one sort of question; what is it we have reason to do? is another. These questions are often explored separately. But our answers to them may not be independent: what reasons are may have... more
Table of Contents
(Columbia: Columbia University Press, 2018)
(Columbia: Columbia University Press, 2018)
In writings about the Holocaust, both Primo Levi and Hannah Arendt appeal to a concept of shame that extends the reach of the concept in a dramatic way. In its more familiar uses, we experience shame because of a failing of our own (I... more
This essay attempts an ‘internalist’ explication of political legitimacy. That is, a philosophically articulated and normatively compelling account, which nonetheless appeals only to resources that are (at least in principle) available to... more
In this paper I want to show how Bernard Williams contributed, especially with his 'turn' in Ethics and the Limits of Philosophy, to overcoming the dichotomy between analytic and continental philosophy, creating a style of reflection in... more
Bernard Williams
Both the genetic endowment we have been equipped with, and the environment we had to be born and raised in, were not-and never are-for us to choose; both are pure luck, a random ticket in this enormously inventive cosmic lottery of... more
Gettier problems have become a kind of benchmark challenge that any proposed analysis of knowledge must overcome. Over the last fifty years philosophers have developed other, similar examples which, when applied to various accounts of... more
Appeals to a ‘tradition’ stretching back to Thucydides have been central to the recent emergence of realism in political theory. This article asks what work these appeals to tradition are doing and whether they are consistent with... more
Bernard Williams influentially attacked ethical theory. This paper assesses arguments for the ‘anti-theory’ position in ethics, including mainly arguments put forward by Williams but also arguments put forward by others. The paper begins... more
Some moral theories — particularly versions of impartial maximizing act-consequentialism such as act-utilitarianism — have been accused of making overly severe demands on agents. This paper aims to clarify what exactly this line of... more
I argue that the idea of virtue has become central after the Fifties in both Anglo-Saxon and German moral philosophy and that this revival has come together with recognition of the legitimacy of discussion of issues in normative ethics,... more
In this paper I consider Bernard Williams' characterization of thin and thick concepts, and compare it with Ryle's discussion of the notion of a thick description. (This appears in my edited volume 'Thick Concepts' (OUP, 2013), pp.... more
Examines various arguments about whether and under what circumstances political violence can be justified and how they can be employed in thinking ethically about violence. It begins by looking at arguments about the justifiability of... more
John Rawls’ gamification of justice leads him – along with many other monist political philosophers, not least Ronald Dworkin – to fail to take politics seriously enough. I begin with why we consider games frivolous and then show how... more
Bernard Williams' critic to utilitarianism allows us to analyze the most controversial aspects of this ethical theory. After a brief sketch of the main ideas of utilitarianism, we are going to show some of the main problems of that... more
Foot argues that there are certain things that all human beings - perhaps all rational agents - need. This gives a sense in which certain values and disvalues can be called 'objective'. I suggest that, with certain relatively minor... more
Williams’s famous argument against immortality rests on the idea that immortality cannot be desirable, at least for human beings, and his contention has spawned a cottage industry of responses. As I will intend to show, the arguments over... more
The Humean theory of motivation maintains that cognitive states like beliefs lack motivating force. If an agent were to be motivated to perform an action, s/he would necessarily have a preceding desire Φ and a means-end belief that by... more
This paper puts forward an account of blame combining two ideas that are usually set up against each other: that blame performs an important function, and that blame is justified by the moral reasons making people blameworthy rather than... more
Is the idea of the voluntary important? Those who think so tend to regard it as an idea that can be metaphysically deepened through a theory about voluntary action, while those who think it a superficial idea that cannot coherently be... more
Conceptual engineering is thought to face an ‘implementation challenge’: the challenge of securing uptake of engineered concepts. But is the fact that implementation is challenging really a defect to be overcome? What kind of picture of... more
If ethical reflection on which concepts to use has an avatar, it must be Nietzsche, who took more seriously than most the question of what concepts one should live by, and regarded many of our inherited concepts as deeply problematic.... more
In this paper, I identify a central problem for conceptual engineering: the problem of showing concept-users why they should recognise the authority of the concepts advocated by engineers. I argue that this authority problem cannot... more
Bernard Williams thought that philosophy should address real human concerns felt beyond academic philosophy. But what wider concerns are addressed by Ethics and the Limits of Philosophy, a book he introduces as being ‘principally about... more
Forthcoming in David Macarthur and Mario de Caro's Handbook of Liberal Naturalism.
This version probably isn't final (just wait till Adrian Moore sees it, for a start).
This version probably isn't final (just wait till Adrian Moore sees it, for a start).
Spontanément, le monde me paraît centré sur moi et sur le moment présent. Spontanément, ma vie et ce qui arrive présentement me paraissent aussi jouir d’une forme de privilège : je leur accorde naturellement une certaine importance et... more
In his paper "Wittgenstein and Idealism" Professor Williams proposed a 'model' for reading Wittgenstein's later philosophy which he claimed exposed its transcendental idealist character. By this he roughly meant that Wittgenstein's later... more
In this article, I explore recent work on realist political theory and international politics. I discuss how scholarship on the topic emanates from two different fields — International Relations and political philosophy — and argue that... more