K-Machine Vibration Diagnostic Summary
K-Machine Vibration Diagnostic Summary
K-Machine Vibration Diagnostic Summary
http://www.vibanalysis.co.uk/vibanalysis/index.htm
0
Chapter Outline
1
1- When do you have a vibration problem?
Machine parts are all over the floor or machine wants to walk
out of the building
None can stand the machine running for more than 15 min.
When there is a noise problem
When the boss complains
Machine wear parts are being changed frequently (bearings or
couplings every 6 months)
Cracks or bad parts
Machinery does not live up to its expected life
SYMPTOMS …. SOURCES (locate and fix)
2
Good (Normal) and Bad (Serious) Vibrations
3
Forced vs Natural
4
Vibration Instrument for Diagnosis
FFT Analyzer
(fancy AC voltmeters with a frequency display axis)
separates the frequencies (identifying specific causes)
and quantifies the amplitude (judging how bad).
5
2- Unbalance
Most common cause and the easiest to diagnose.
Condition where center of mass is not coincident with center
of rotation
Typical causes: casting porosity, nonuniform density, loss of
material during operation, manufacturing tolerances,
machining, couplings, bearings, anything that affects the
rotational mass distribution
Shows up as a vibration frequency exactly equal to the
rotational speed (amplitude proportional to the amount of
unbalance). Must do frequency analysis to diagnose.
Speed dependent due to centrifugal force; vibration increases
as the square of the speed
Low axial readings, In phase
Unbalanced and balanced motor spectrum
6
Source: Wonk,
Machinery Vibration
7
3- Misalignment
Coupling misalignment- shafts of the driver and the driven machine are
not on the same centerline (parallel or angular)
Vertical or Horizontal- can be frustrating
Why misalignment? Equipment from different suppliers are mated
together. Example: motors and pumps (centrifugal pump)
Flexible couplings are used to take up misalignment (but could strain
the couplings, bearings and seals)
Shows up as a series of harmonics of the running speed- as shafts are
cyclically strained towards each other (audible growl of misalignment)
Misalignment is temperature dependent (vibration changes on warm up)
High axial readings
~180 degrees out of phase (machine casing rocks out of phase with the
machine)
Less sensitive to speed changes. Forces due to misalignment remain
constant with speed
Align first; and if a high 1X rpm vibration remains, then balance.
8
Source: Wonk,
Machinery Vibration
9
4- Resonance
Driving force applied to a structure is close to its natural frequency
and amplification occurs
Driving force can be residual imbalance in a rotating machine or
broadband turbulence due to fluid motion
Beams, plates have resonant frequencies, not just one (for single
dof)
Resonance is highly speed sensitive, damping decreases the
maximum amplitude and broadens the response curve
Rotors have resonances (critical speeds)- remember rotors runs
smoother above the critical speed than below it; example: squeaking
in an automobile at highway speeds goes away with a change in
speed
An impulse will excite the system to natural frequencies
Directional vibrations suggest resonance
Key indicators: an audible pure tone, a clean sine wave in the time
domain and a single tall peak in the frequency domain
10
Identifying Resonance
Stop the machine, do the bump test, measure natural frequencies. If these
frequencies appear in the spectrum when the machine is running, then you
have confirmed resonance.
The second way is to watch the spectrum as the machine changes speed
(coast-down). The resonances don’t change frequency as the machine
speed changes.
11
5- Others
High frequencies
Gears (shock pulses arise with defective teeth contact) gear-mesh
frequencies: rpmX no of teeth
Cavitation: 3-5 kHz broadband; pressurizing inlet helps
Medium frequencies
Bearings (failure causes: contamination, overstress, lack of lubrication,
defects created after manufacturing)
Motor (electrical) 120 Hz + harmonics
Mechanical Looseness ½, 1 ½, 2 ½ etc. Decreases with load
At 1x rpm
Bent shaft (correct with massive balance weights near the center
Reciprocating
At Less than 1x rpm
Belts (p rpm pitch dia) Strobe light helps see the defect
Oil whirl (approx. 45% of 1Xrpm) in journal bearings
Looseness
12
Source: Wonk,
Machinery Vibration
13
6- Vibration Limits
14
15
References
Machinery Vibration by Victor Wonk, McGraw Hill
http://www.vibanalysis.co.uk/vibanalysis/index.htm
16
Any Questions ?
Thank You
17