Location via proxy:   [ UP ]  
[Report a bug]   [Manage cookies]                

Why Choose Intrinsic Safety

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 4

INSTRUMENTATION TOOLS

Adsby Google

ElectricalWiring

HazardousArea

Equipment

FireAlarmSystem

Why choose intrinsic safety ?


SafetySystems October25,2015

TopERPSoftware
AwardWinningERPSoftware.DownloadOurFreeERPInfoPack!

Intrinsic safety (IS) is a lowenergy signalling technique that prevents explosions from
occurringbyensuringthattheenergytransferredtoahazardousareaiswellbelowtheenergy
requiredtoinitiateanexplosion.

Theenergylevelsmadeavailableforsignallingaresmallbutuseableandmorethan
adequateforthemajorityofinstrumentationsystems.
Thetwomechanismsbeingconsideredthatcouldinitiateanexplosionare:
Aspark
Ahotsurface

Theadvantagesofintrinsicsafety
The major advantage of intrinsic safety is that it provides a solution to all the problems of
hazardousareas(forequipmentrequiringlimitedpower)andistheonlytechniquewhichmeets
thiscriterion.Thesignificantfactorsareasfollows:
a) The IS technique is accepted throughout the There is an increasing acceptance of
international certificates issued under the IEC Ex scheme but this has some way to go.
IntrinsicsafetyisanacceptabletechniqueinalllocallegislationsuchastheATEXDirectives
andOSHA.Therelevantstandardsandcodeofpracticegivedetailedguidanceonthedesign
and use of intrinsically safe equipment to a level which is not achieved by any of the other

methodsofprotection.
b)ThesameISequipmentusuallysatisfiestherequirementsforbothdustandgas
c)AppropriateintrinsicallysafeapparatuscanbeusedinallInparticular,itistheonlysolution
that has a satisfactory history of safety for Zone 0 instrumentation. The use of levels of
protection (ia, ib and ic) ensures that equipment suitable for each level of risk is available
(normallyiaisusedinZone0,ibinZone1andicinZone2
d)IntrinsicallysafeapparatusandsystemsareusuallyallocatedagroupIICgasclassification
whichensuresthattheequipmentiscompatiblewithallgas/airOccasionally,IIBsystems
are used, as this permits a higher power level to be used. (However, IIB systems are not
compatiblewithacetylene,hydrogenandcarbondisulfide.)
e) A temperature classification of T4 (135C) is normally achieved, which satisfies the
requirementforallindustrialgasesexceptcarbondisulfide(CS)which,fortunately,israrely
f) Frequently, apparatus, and the system in which it is used, can be made ia IIC T4 at an
acceptable This removes concerns about area classification, gas grouping and temperature
classificationinalmostallcircumstancesandbecomestheuniversalsafesolution.
g)Thesimpleapparatusconceptallowsmanysimplepiecesofapparatus,suchasswitches,
thermocouples,RTDsandjunctionboxestobeusedinintrinsicallysafesystemswithoutthe
needforcertificaThisgivesasignificantamountofflexibilityinthechoiceoftheseancillaries.
h)Theintrinsicsafetytechniqueistheonlytechniquethatpermitslivemaintenancewithinthe
hazardousareawithouttheneedtoobtaingasclearancecertificaThisisparticularlyimportant
forinstrumentation,sincefaultfindingondeenergisedequipmentisdifficult.
i) The installation and maintenance requirements for intrinsically safe apparatus are well
documented, and consistent regardless of level of This reduces the amount of training
requiredanddecreasesthepossibilityofdangerousmistakes.
j)Intrinsicsafetypermitstheuseofconventionalinstrumentationcables,thusreducingCable
capacitanceandinductanceisoftenperceivedasaproblembut,infact,itisonlyaproblemon
cables longer than 400 metres, in systems installed in Zones 0 and 1, where IIC gases
(hydrogen) are the source of risk. This is comparatively rare and, in most circumstances,
cableparametersarenotaproblem.
Availablepower
Intrinsic safety is fundamentally a low energy technique and consequently the voltage,
currentandpoweravailableisrestricted.Figure1.0isasimplifiedillustrationoftheavailable
powerinintrinsicallysafecircuitsandattemptstodemonstratethetypeofelectricalinstallation
inwhichtheintrinsicallysafetechniqueisapplicable.
The blue and green curves are the accepted design curves used to avoid spark ignition by
resistivelimitedcircuitsinGroupIICandIIBgases.Theiccurvesarelesssensitivebecause
theydonotrequiretheapplicationofasafetyfactorinthesamewayasfor
iaandibequipment.Ingeneralthemaximumvoltageavailableissetbycablecapacitance
(400metrescorrespondsto80nFwhichhasapermissiblevoltageof29VinIICiacircuits)

and the maximum current


by cable inductance (400
metres corresponds to
400H which has a
permissiblecurrentof300
mA in IIC ia circuits). A
frequently used limitation
on power is the 1.3W,
whicheasilypermitsaT4
(135C) temperature
classification.Theselimits
areallshowninFigure1.0
Asimpleapproachistosay
thatiftheapparatuscanbe
operated from a source of
power
whose
output
parameters are within the
(blue) hatched area then it
can readily be made
intrinsically safe to IIC ia
T4 standards. If the
Fig1.0AvailablePowerCurves
parameters exceed these
limits to a limited degree
thenitcanprobablybemadeintrinsicallysafetoIIBoricrequirements.

The first choice, however, is always to choose IIC ia T4 equipment, if it provides adequate
powerandisaneconomicchoice,asthisequipmentcanbeusedinallcircumstances(except
ifcarbondisulfide(CS)isthehazardousgas,inwhichcasethereareotherproblems).
Inpracticealmostalllowvoltageinstrumentationcanbemade
IIBicT4asthelimitsaresetbytheleastsensitiveoftheignitioncurvesinFigure1.0
(typically24V500mA).TheIIBicspecificationdoesrestrictapplicationtoZone2andwhere
the hazardous gas is not hydrogen, acetylene or carbon disulfide but is still applicable to a
largerangeofinstallations.
Conclusion
Intrinsic safety is the natural choice for all low voltage instrumentation problems.
Adequate solutions exist which are compatible with all gases and area classifications. The
techniquepreventsexplosionsratherthanretainsthemwhichmustbepreferable,andthe
livemaintenancefacilityenablesconventionalinstrumentpracticetobeused.
Whyuseintrinsicsafety?
The principal reason for using intrinsic safety is because it is essentially a low power
technique. Consequently, the risk of ignition is minimised, and adequate safety can be
achievedwithalevelofconfidencethatisnotalwaysachievedbyothertechniques.
Itisdifficulttoassessthetemperaturerise,whichcanoccurifequipmentisimmersedinadust

because of the many (frequently unpredictable) factors, which determine the temperature
risewithinthedustlayer.Thesafesttechniqueisthereforetorestricttheavailablepowertothe
lowestpracticallevel.Amajorfactorinfavourofintrinsicsafetyisthatthepowerlevelunder
faultconditionsiscontrolledbythesystemdesignanddoesnotrelyonthelesswellspecified
limitationoffaultpower.
Intrinsic safety also has the advantage that the possibility of ignition from immersed or
damaged wiring is minimised. It is desirable to be able to do live maintenance on an
instrument system, and the use of the intrinsically safe technique permits this without the
necessityofspecialdustfreecertificates.Thereisaneedtoclearlayersofdustcarefullyand
toavoidcontaminationoftheinteriorofapparatusduringmaintenancebutthisisapparentto
anytrainedtechnician.(Thereisnosignificantpossibilityofaperson,inadustcloudthatcan
be ignited, surviving without breathing apparatus). To summarise, intrinsic safety is the
preferredtechniqueforinstrumentationwheredustisthehazardbecause:
the inherent safety of intrinsic safety gives the greatest assurance of safety and removes concern
overoverheatingofequipmentandcables
theinstallationrulesareclearlyspecifiedandthesystemdesignensuresthatallsafetyaspectsare
covered
livemaintenanceispermitted
equipmentisavailabletosolvethemajorityofproblems

AlsoRead:DifferencebetweenDCS&PLCSystems

Ex&ATEXCertification
ATEX,IEC,CE&NECCertificationExTest&Verificationatyoursite

POSTED BY S BHARADWAJ REDDY

You might also like