Trans Transmisi
Trans Transmisi
Trans Transmisi
1 Training content
Characteristic parameters of lines
Line operation under no-load
Line operation during matching
Line operation during symmetric short circuit
Line operation under different load types (resistive, inductive)
Transmission losses, efficiency
Reactive power compensation (parallel and series mode)
1.2 Equipment
Basic equipment
Article Quantit
Designation
number y
CO3301-3A Transmission line model 150 km / 300 km 1
CO3301-5P Power-switch module 1
CO3301-3F Resistive load (3-phase, 1 kW) 1
CO3301-3D Inductive load (3-phase, 1 kW) 1
CO3301-3E Capacitive load (3-phase, 1 kW) 1
Documentation
Article Quantit
Designation
number y
SH5001-6K EUL manual: Power transmission 1
Power supply
Article Quantit
Designation
number y
ST8008-4S Adjustable three-phase supply (0 - 400 V / 2 A, 72PU) 1
Table-top housing for 72PU inserts for CEE three-phase
ST8008-7F 1
connection
ST8010-4J 5-way socket strip with illuminated mains switch 2
Measuring instruments
Article Quantit
Designation
number y
CO5127-1Y Three-phase meter 2
Analog/digital multimeter, power meter/power-factor meter,
CO5127-1Z 1
software
Theoretical fundamentals
To keep transmission losses within limits, efforts are made in practice to minimize
the conductor resistance R and maximize the conductance G. Accordingly, R << ωL
and G >> ωCB.
Lines with these properties are described as low-loss. If R and G can be neglected
entirely, one speaks of a lossless line. Though lossless lines cannot be realized in
practice, the simplifications above become more accurate as the considered voltage
level rises. This applies especially when investigating the steady-state response. For
rough calculations confined to essential aspects, the equivalent circuit diagram
shown below can be used to represent operation at zero power loss.
Figure 1.3: Single-phase equivalent circuit diagram of a lossless line.
I10, I20: Currents through the transverse branches respectively at the line's start and
end
In the no-load state, the terminating resistance R at the line's end is infinitely large,
so that the current I2 = 0. The processes taking place in circuits operating at
sinusoidal voltages are visualized by means of phasor diagrams. These diagrams
enable a simultaneous representation of the magnitude and phase angle of the AC
quantities under examination. Phasors can be added or subtracted graphically,
thereby allowing a clear display, for instance, of voltage drops in networks. All
phasors rotate at an angular speed denoted by ω, their diagrams serving to provide
"snapshots" of the system under consideration. These displays are purely of a
qualitative nature and not true-to-scale, and therefore only intended for illustration.
The related, numerical values can be determined individually with the help of
complex calculations. In the combined current/voltage phasor diagrams below, the
voltage vector at the end of the line is defined arbitrarily as the reference phasor, and
drawn in the same direction as the real axis. Furthermore, as is common practice in
energy technology, the display's coordinate system is rotated by +90° so that the real
axis points in the y-direction. The current/voltage phasor diagram below describes
the no-load state.
Figure 1.5: Current/voltage phasor diagram of a lossless line in the no-load state
The phasor diagram shows that in this operating state, the voltage at the line's end is
higher than the voltage at the line's start. This is due to the working capacitance and
known as the Ferranti effect. The voltage at the line's end has risen
disproportionately with respect to the line's length; efforts are therefore made to
avoid this operating state in practice. The current flowing in the no-load state is
termed the charging current, and the associated reactive power the charging power.
As already mentioned, underground cables have a higher working capacity than
overhead lines. The effects described earlier are much more pronounced here. In the
event of matching, the load resistance R is exactly equal to the characteristic
impedance. The power consumed by the active resistance is termed natural power.
The resultant current is just high enough so that the reactive power consumption
attributable to the line inductance is exactly equal to reactive power generated by the
working capacitance. Assuming that the line is lossless, it consumes or generates no
reactive power whatsoever, and the active power it draws from the upstream
connected network only amounts to the natural power. Furthermore, the voltage at
the start of the line in this case has the same magnitude as the voltage at the end of
the line. The next phasor diagram describes this situation.
Figure 1.6: Current/voltage phasor diagram of a lossless line during matching
(termination with the characteristic impedance)
Due to the conductive material of which it is made, every real transmission line also
has an active resistance, which is responsible for the transmission losses. These are
equal to the difference between the supplied and consumed powers. A transmission
system's efficiency is defined as the ratio between the active powers at the system's
output and input. Because no reactive power needs to be transmitted in the event of
matching, the efficiency is maximized in this case. Since the value of a line's load is
determined by the behaviour of the consumers connected to the line, matching
occurs very rarely and randomly. However, reactive power compensation is also
available as an option for minimizing transmission losses. Related experiments are
described in the chapter after the next one. In the case of a (three-pole) short circuit,
the load resistance R has the value 0. The current then flowing is limited only by the
line impedance (assuming that the line inductance results in lossless transmission)
and therefore much higher than the values occurring during normal operation. This
must be detected and isolated as soon as possible by the network protection
devices. The phasor diagram below describes this situation.
Figure 1.7: Current/voltage phasor diagram of a lossless line in the event of a short
circuit at the line's end
Finally, we will look at the phasor diagram in the case of the resistive/inductive loads
such as those occurring most frequently during real-life operation. For a more
precise representation, a low-loss line is assumed here.
Figure 1.8: Current/voltage phasor diagram of a low-loss line in the case of a mixed
(resistive/inductive) load
The resultant current I2 through the load comprises a resistive and an inductive
component in accordance with the ratio of the load's active and reactive powers. In
practice, the influence of the capacitances at the line's end is (qualitatively) lower
than that indicated in the phasor diagram here, i.e. I2 and I12 are approximately equal.
As the reactive power rises, so does the longitudinal current through the line and,
consequently, the losses produced by the line resistance R. To minimize these
losses, electricity supply companies define certain limiting values for the reactive
power and power factor cos φ. Accordingly, it is common to demand a surcharge on
electricity rates (reactive power clause) from cos φ values below 0.8. One alternative
for the customer is to compensate the (usually) inductive reactive power by means of
capacitors connected in parallel. The power triangle shown below illustrates the
relationships involved here.
Figure 1.9: Power ratios with an uncompensated and partly compensated load
P is the active power, Q the reactive power, and S the apparent power. To reduce
the apparent power and, consequently, the apparent current, the reactive power can
be lowered, for instance, from its original value Q to a residual value Q R. This is
equivalent to improving the power factor from cos φ2 to cos φ'2. As indicated in the
diagram, the compensatory reactive power QC needed for this is therefore:
The equation indicates that the compensatory capacitance is load dependent. Its
three individual capacitors C connected in star configuration are determined by:
C = QC / (ω * UN²)
The last equation assumes that the nominal voltage is present across the load.
Moreover, half the working capacitance present at the line's end also contributes
very slightly toward compensation. However, both influences are usually ignored
during the design of compensatory mechanisms. For full compensation, φ' 2 must be
zero, so that: QC = P * tan φ2.
C = 1 / (ω² * L) = 1 / (ω * XL)
Experiments
For both line lengths, set the voltage to the nominal value (380 V) at the beginning of
the line. The outer conductors are designated L1 , L2 and L3 , the neutral conductor
N. Measure the variables indicated in the table (the powers always comprise three-
phase values, i.e. total power levels):
Compare the measurement results with the calculated values (all calculations are
carried out for single-phases on the basis of the associated phasor diagram).
To determine the voltage rise at the line's open end, it is best to use the voltage
measured there to calculate the voltage at the line's start. The calculations shown
next apply according to Figure 1.5.
UL = X * I20 = 2.53 V
U1 = U2 – UL = 220.5 V
UL = X * I20 = 10.48 V
U1 = U2 – UL = 220.5 V
The charging power can be ascertained with sufficient precision assuming that the
voltages at the start and end of the line are identical.
In this case: Qc = 3 * (UN / v3) ² * ? * CB = UN ² * ? * CB
1.4.2 Matching
To study the response during matching, the resistive load is decreased from its
maximum value until attainment of the power levels specified in the table below. In
the case of both line lengths, the nominal voltage (380 V) is to be set at the start of
the line and maintained at this value through readjustment wherever necessary. The
variables indicated next are to be measured.
Situated between these ranges is the operating state known matching. The supplied
reactive power is now at its minimum value (theoretically zero). This operating point
is to be found by slowly changing the load resistance, starting from its maximum
value.
Measurement values during matching (line length of 150 km and supply voltage of
380 V):
Measurement values during matching (line length of 300 km and feed voltage of 380
V):
For the purpose of monitoring, this resistance can naturally also be measured by
means of an ohmmeter with the load disconnected.
Here too, a comparison is performed with the theoretically expected value for a
lossless line for both line lengths (the characteristic impedance is independent of the
line length).
Finally, the measured values are used to determine the efficiency during matching
for both line lengths:
To study the response in the event of a three-pole (symmetric) short circuit, the
resistive load is disconnected, and the three outer conductors connected to each
other as well as the return conductor. These connections must be established before
the power switch is turned on.
In this experiment, the line can be considered as a model of a 110-kV line
possessing the same line constants for R, X and CB as a 380-kV line. Even with
these values, the line model remains realistic.
Because of the high current in the short-circuited state, the experiment should be
carried out swiftly at a reduced supply voltage. The current should remain on only
until the desired measurement values have been obtained. Increase the line-to-line
voltage at the start of the line to 110 kV and measure the variables indicated below.
Note:
In this experiment, the currents were measured only in the steady state. The initial
values occurring on a short circuit of relatively short lines in meshed networks with
multiple feeds can be much higher. Unbalanced and earth faults, of equal
importance to the design of protective equipment, are treated in a separate
experiment.
Connect the capacitor in star configuration, and set the voltage at the start of the line
to a constant value of 340 V; perform any readjustment necessary to avoid excess
voltages at the end of the line. Enter the values of the specified parameters in the
table below. The power levels again comprise total values.
C= 2 µF 4 µF 6 µF 8 µF 10 µF 12 µF
Voltage L1 - L2 (line end)
Current L1 (at line end)
Reactive power (at line end)
Strom L1 (am Leitungsanfang)in
A
Active power (at line start)
Reactive power (at line start)
How does the voltage at the line's end depend on the connected capacitance?
Evidently, the voltage at the end of the line rises
disproportionately with increasing inductive load. This
can be explained by the Ferranti effect, as already
described in the case of no-load.
Evidently, the voltage at the end of the line rises
disproportionately with increasing capacitive load. This
can be explained by the Ferranti effect, as already
described in the case of no-load.
Evidently, the voltage at the end of the line rises
disproportionately with increasing resistive load. This
can be explained by the Ferranti effect, as already
described in the case of no-load.
For measurements with purely inductive loads, assemble the circuit as shown next.
Figure 1.13: Experiment circuit for measurements with purely inductive loads
Connect the inductor in star configuration, and set the voltage at the start of the line
to 380 V; perform any necessary readjustments. Enter the values of the specified
parameters in the table below. The power levels again comprise total values.
How does the voltage at the end of the line depend on the connected inductance?
In the case of inductive loads, the voltage at the start of
the line drops as the load increases (i.e. as the
inductance increases). The line behaves similarly to a
purely resistive load.
In the case of inductive loads, the voltage at the end of
the line drops as the load decreases (i.e. as the
inductance decreases). The line behaves similarly to a
purely resistive load.
In the case of inductive loads, the voltage at the end of
the line drops as the load increases (i.e. as the
inductance decreases). The line behaves similarly to a
purely resistive load.
Besides purely resistive loads (lighting, process heat), operations in a real power
network also involve numerous loads of a resistive-inductive nature (transformers,
electric motors). The overall power factor cos f in this case usually ranges between
0.8 and 0.9. These load cases are accordingly given due consideration below. All
experiments here are conducted with a line length of 150 km.
For tests involving mixed resistive-inductive loads, assemble the circuit as shown
next.
Figure 1.14: Experiment circuit for measurements with mixed resistive-inductive
loads
Connect the inductor and load resistor in parallel and star-configuration in each case;
set the voltage at the start of the line to 380 V and perform any necessary
readjustments. Note the values of the exemplified variables in the table. The power
levels again comprise total values.
Measured values for L = 3.2 H and a load adjusted (starting with large values of R)
so as to consume an active power of 300 W:
Voltage L1 – L2 (line end) V
Current L1 (at line end) A
Reactive power (load) var
Power factor cos f (load)
Current L1 (at line start) A
Active power (at line start) W
Reactive power (at line start) var
Measured values for L = 2.0 H and a load adjusted (starting with large values of R)
so as to consume an active power of 400 W:
Voltage L1 – L2 (line end) V
Current L1 (at line end) A
Reactive power (load) var
Power factor cosf (load)
Current L1 (at line start) A
Active power (at line start) W
Reactive power (at line start) var
Measured values for L = 1.2 H and a load adjusted (starting with large values of R)
so as to consume an active power of 500 W:
Voltage L1 – L2 (line end) V
Current L1 (at line end) A
Reactive power (load) var
Power factor cos f (load)
Current L1 (at line start) A
Active power (at line start) W
Reactive power (at line start) var
The following applies to the load's power factor: tan j2 = I2 reactive / I2 active = 0.62 and
cos f2 = 0.85.
The transverse current due to half the working capacitance at the end of the line is:
The longitudinal current along the line is I12 = I2 + I20 = (0.844 – j 0.462) A.
Consequently, U1 = U2 + (R + j X) * I12.
If R = 3.6 W und X = 36.15 W (line values) are used, then U1 = (217.2 + j 28.847) V
and U1? = (376.19 + j 49.964).
The transverse current due to half the working capacitance at the start of the line is:
I10 = U1 * (j ?CB / 2) = (- 0.009 + j 0.068) A
A load state involving a poor power factor will now to be simulated in order to
demonstrate the possibility of reactive power compensation.
Measured values for L = 1.2 H and a load adjusted (starting with large values of R)
so as to consume an active power of 300 W:
Voltage L1 – L2 (line end) V
Current L1 (at line end) A
Reactive power (load) var
Power factor cos f (load)
Current L1 (at line start) A
Active power (at line start) W
Reactive power (at line start) var
Measured values for L = 2.0 H and the load R adjusted so as to consume an active
power of 500 W:
Voltage L1 – L2 (line end) V
Current L1 (at line end) A
Reactive power (load) var
Power factor cos f (load)
Current L1 (at line start) A
Active power (at line start) W
Reactive power (at line start) var
The experiment demonstrates that the load at the end of a long line causes an
impermissibly high voltage drop. A series capacitor can be used to reduce this drop.
Three individual capacitances with the value C = 1 / (? * XL) are required for full
compensation. At a length of 300 km, the line model has a reactance XL = 72.3 O,
so that C = 44 µF. In the experiment, this value can be realized by a parallel
connection of capacitors rated respectively at 30, 8, 4 and 2 µF. The three
capacitances formed in this manner are to be connected between the end of the line
and the multimeter in each case. This permits continued measurement of the sought
variables across the load. The resistive load is to be readjusted until a consumption
of 500 W is achieved again, and the same variables as those in the uncompensated
state are to be measured:
Voltage L1 – L2 (line end) V
Current L1 (at line end) A
Reactive power (load) var
Power factor cos f (load)
Current L1 (at line start) A
Active power (at line start) W
Reactive power (at line start) var