#Design Multi Crop Tresher Mach
#Design Multi Crop Tresher Mach
#Design Multi Crop Tresher Mach
Acknowledgement
First and for most we would like to thank the almighty GOD for giving us a blessed
time to do this project. Next it is our great pleasure to thank those individuals who helped
us in preparing this project work. We heartily thank our advisor Ins. Zina G. who guides
us while we were working this project and made necessary correction.
We would also like to express our deepest gratitude to Ins. Moges S. for allowing us
to visit the farm technology laboratory and giving supportive ideas related to this design
project.
Finally, we would like to thank our friends, and everyone who helped us for everything
that they have done for us, from start up to completion of this project.
Mekelle university i
Design of multi crop thresher machine
Abstract
Agriculture mechanization played a significant economic role by increasing
agricultural production and reducing cost of cultivation. Agricultural mechanization has
improved productivity to great extent; still post-harvest value addition to the raw product
in ETHIOPIA is very less as compared to other countries, which may be mainly due to
the lack of such technologies. There is a need to develop more processing machinery for
value addition of agricultural production with a reduction in time and labor. Teff, wheat,
and sorghum are very important crops in ETHIOPIA, but manual removal of grains from
husks is a laborious and time consuming activity.
The purpose of this design project is to make this laborious and time consuming
activity easier by designing a multi crop thresher that can thresh these crops (Teff, wheat,
and sorghum). This thresher machine, since it is designed to be manufactured from
locally available materials, its cost will be cheaper than threshers that are imported from
foreign country.
The design of this multi crop thresher has been presented with each detail component
analysis and both part and assembly drawings are made using CATIA.
Mekelle university ii
Design of multi crop thresher machine
Abbreviations
µ Coefficient of friction
Aw1 factor accountable to the resistance of bearings
B width
Bw3 factor accountable to air resistance
C center to center distance
d diameter
F force
g gravitational acceleration
H corrected horse power
h height
IDC inner dead center
K belt correction factor
ks factor of safety
L length
M bending moment
n rpm
ODC outer dead center
P power
q Feed rate
R radius
t tension
T torque
u air stream velocity
V speed
v volume
W load
w width
Z section modulus
ρ density
τ shear stress
ω angular speed of the drum
Mekelle university iv
Design of multi crop thresher machine
Contents
Acknowledgement ........................................................................................... i
Abstract ........................................................................................................... ii
Abbreviations ................................................................................................. iii
List of figures ............................................................................................... viii
CHAPTER ONE ............................................................................................. 1
1. Introduction ................................................................................................. 1
1.1 Problem Statement ................................................................................ 2
1.2 Objective of the Project ........................................................................ 2
1.3 Significance of the study ...................................................................... 2
1.4 Definition of terms ................................................................................ 2
1.5 Project methodology ............................................................................. 4
CHAPTER TWO ............................................................................................ 5
2. LETRATURE REVIEW............................................................................. 5
2.1 Threshing operation .............................................................................. 5
2.2. Past time threshers ............................................................................... 5
2.3. Modern threshers ................................................................................. 6
CHAPTER THREE ...................................................................................... 10
3. CONCEPTUAL DESIGN ........................................................................ 10
3.1 Model A .............................................................................................. 10
3.2Model B ............................................................................................... 11
3.3Model C ............................................................................................... 11
3.4 Comparison of conceptual designs ..................................................... 12
3.5 Design matrix ...................................................................................... 13
3.6 Description of values .......................................................................... 13
3.7 Decision and Conclusion .................................................................... 14
3.8 Working principles ............................................................................. 14
Mekelle university v
Design of multi crop thresher machine
CHAPTER FOUR......................................................................................... 16
4. DESIGN ANALYSIS ........................................................................... 16
4.1 Geometric Analysis............................................................................. 16
4.2 Design of Belt ..................................................................................... 18
4.3 Pulley analysis .................................................................................... 26
4.4 Shaft design......................................................................................... 32
4.5 Design of keys .................................................................................... 35
4.6 Design of beater .................................................................................. 38
4.7 Design of blower ................................................................................. 41
4.8 Bearing life determination .................................................................. 42
4.9 Design of support frame (stand) ......................................................... 45
4.10 Design of wheel ................................................................................ 47
4.11Design of Cover cylinder ................................................................... 48
4.12 Design of Sieve material ................................................................... 48
4.13 Design of connecting rod .................................................................. 51
4.14 Design of bolt.................................................................................... 54
4.15 Design of weld for the supports ........................................................ 54
4.16 summary of result ............................................................................. 56
CHAPTER FIVE .......................................................................................... 58
5 Cost Estimation .......................................................................................... 58
CHAPTER SIX ............................................................................................. 59
6. Manufacturing process .............................................................................. 59
CHAPTER SEVEN ...................................................................................... 60
7. Assembling procedure .............................................................................. 60
CHAPTER EIGHT ....................................................................................... 61
8. Conclusion and Recommendation ............................................................ 61
8.1 Conclusion .......................................................................................... 61
8.2 Recommendation ................................................................................ 62
References ..................................................................................................... 63
Appendix ....................................................................................................... 64
Mekelle university vi
Design of multi crop thresher machine
List of tables
Table 1 design matrix
Table 2 coefficient of friction between belt and pulley
Table 3 belt type designation
Table 4 belt dimensions
Table 5 belt correction factors
Table 6 belt correction factors
Table 7 belt correction factors
Table 8 groove dimensions of v-belt
Table 9 shaft correction factors
Table 10 ball bearing principal dimensions
Table 11 ball bearing principal dimensions
Table 12 ball bearing principal dimensions
Table 13 relation between equivalent length (L) and actual length (l)
List of figures
Fig.1 belt tension
Fig 2 belt section
Fig.3 forces on belt
Fig.4 pulley dimensions
Fig.5 shaft
Fig.6 reaction force diagram
Fig7. Bending moment diagram
Fig.8. keys
Fig.9. key dimensions
Fig.10. beater dimensions
Fig. 11 tong dimension
Fig.12. welding structure of beater
Fig. 13 blower
Fig. 14 supporting structure
Fig. 15 supporting structure
Fig.16 wheel
Fig.17 sieve
Fig.18 sieve position with dimension
Fig.19 reaction force diagram
Fig. 20 connecting rod
Fig.21 cross section of connecting rod
Fig.22 connecting rod dimensions
CHAPTER ONE
1. Introduction
Indigenous threshing of crops (wheat, barley, teff, sorghum… etc,) is one of the
most time consuming labours and maximum loss of grain. After harvesting the crop
transported to the threshing site where they are left stacked till the threshing season,
which is usually December and January. The threshing floor usually made smearing the
ground with caw dung and left to dry for some time or levelling the ground and trampling
according the type of crop which is going to be threshed
During threshing the loose crop is laid on the floor and several oxen tread on it.
The oxen go round on the threshing floor over the crop for some time and are taken out to
turn the un threshed crop from the bottom up and spread it laying the heads up for
efficient threshing.
Threshing with animals need skill and energy to keep the animals moving around
the threshing floor. Usually the best-trained animals are used as the pivots on the canter
of the ring while other animal‟s circle around. The threshing season normally lasts 2-3
months, but with the increased in production, which is possible with the high yielding
varieties, nevertheless, threshing may not be completed with this time. The delay on
completion of the threshing operation within safe time will expose the crop to
unfavourable weather and will result in quality deterioration, insect and rodent attack.
Oxen, which are not in good conduction, are exposed to danger during the threshing
season. Therefore this method of threshing brings low quality of grain and high
percentage of loss.
Mekelle university 1
Design of multi crop thresher machine
The traditional threshing methods of threshing crops like teff, barley and sorghum
especially for commercial purposes is tedious and time consuming activity. Locally in
Ethiopia, the region that is the highest producer of these crops, the threshing activity is
done by animals and beating by hands using sticks. Since, threshing crops using animals
and beating by hands is not effective way of crop threshing; there will be large amount of
grain loss or wastage due to breakage and removal of grains together with straw.
b) Specific objective
1. To propose detail engineering design for each components, control and
automation of the system.
2. To propose its cost analysis.
3. To deliver a detail proposal for its operation.
4. To prepare simple manual for assembly.
Mekelle university 2
Design of multi crop thresher machine
B, Threshing drum
It is the main part of a thresher which rotates and hits the crop to separate the grain
from the chaff
C, Bearing
It is a mechanical component used to support the rotating shaft of the thresher
D, concave
It is the upper part of the thresher body that used for covering the internal parts of the
thresher and sometimes it is used as a guide for the chaff to pass through the discharge.
Mekelle university 3
Design of multi crop thresher machine
Mainly consists of two or more oscillating sieves, a fan and air sucking duct known as
aspirator
Usually two ducts, primary and secondary duct Function of primary duct is to remove
major portion of straw, dust and other foreign matter Secondary duct is used for final
cleaning of the grain
Grain discharge:-
It has sheet plate metals that takes the grain from the secondary sieve and discharge the
grain to given temporary storage place.
Primary Data: - Direct observation, formal and informal interview with different workers
(lab assistants), and from written data.
c) Data Analysis
1. Using different analytical approaches and theories.
2. Using different static and fatigue machine element analysis to design machine
parts like pulley, belt, and rotary shaft (or drum) etc…
3. By using solid works software to draw the part and assembly drawings.
Mekelle university 4
Design of multi crop thresher machine
CHAPTER TWO
2. LETRATURE REVIEW
2.1 Threshing operation
Threshing or shelling consists of separating the grains, or the shells in the case of
groundnuts, from the portion of the plant that holds them.Threshing or shelling operations
follow the harvest and whatever pre-drying of the crop is undertaken. These operations
may be carried out in the field or on the farm, by hand or with the help of animals or
machines. Depending on the influence of agronomic, economic and social factors,
threshing or shelling is done in different ways:
The threshing operation involves the detachment of paddy kernels or grain from the
panicle. Depending on the influence of agronomic, economic, and social factors,
threshing is done in different ways. It can be achieved by rubbing action, impact and
stripping. The rubbing action occurs when buddy is threshed by trampling by the humans,
animals or tractor. The impact method is the most popular method of threshing paddy.
The difficulty of the process depends on the varieties of grown, and on the moisture
content and degree of maturity of the grain.
Mekelle university 5
Design of multi crop thresher machine
countries, there was a place for a small hand-operated grain thresher which
could be adapted to engine power later. However, he did add that most treadle-
operated and hand-operated threshers were very tiring to operate.
According to Hopfen (1960), treadle-driven drum threshers were satisfactory
only when the grain was easily detachable from the stalks, as with rice, but not
with wheat or barley.
Sutton (1969), suing a drum thresher driven by a 1.7 kilowatt petrol engine,
quoted outputs of 230 - 690 kg per hour for rice. The machine was of rasp-bar
type, drum size 300mm diameter x 300 mm width, drum speed 1500 rev/minute
for rice and 860 rev/minute for beans, sorghum and other crops.
Arnold (1964), from instrumented experiments, gave the specific threshing
energy requirement for wheat to be in the range of 0.77 kilowatt-hours per ton.
VITA (1977) listed 15 manufacturers who produce small-scale threshers for rice
and other crops, but without detailing which threshers were engine-driven and
which were man-powered.
The Alvan Blanch company (UK) (1976) listed specifications of their 3 tractor-
powered and engine-driven threshers.
The John Derbyshire Company (UK) (1972) exhibited a one-man pedal-driven
rasp-bar thresher with belt drive, mounted on skids for field transport.[2]
The thresher handles wheat, barely, teff, maize, sorghum, rice and soybean, it is
of all steel construction, comprising a frame, a peg tooth cylinder with straw-throwing
paddles on one end and enclosed by a cover with spiral louvers and a round rod lower
concave. It is provided with two solid rubber wheels for easy transport. Material is
Mekelle university 6
Design of multi crop thresher machine
loaded on the table and fed into the opening between the cylinder and the lower
concave. The pegs of the threshing cylinder hit the material, separating the grains from
the straw and accelerating them around the cylinder. The majority of the grains are
threshed during the initial impact but further threshing is performed while the material
moves axially towards the opposite, discharge, end. [3]
Northland Superior Supply Company Ltd. is proud to present its line-up of versatile and
robust Wheat and barley head threshers; models ET-16 and ET-20. An integral part of the
industry leading “in –line wheat cleaning system”, the ET series thresher simply and
effectively processes and recovers wheat from un threshed wheat heads. [4]
Mekelle university 7
Design of multi crop thresher machine
When used in conjunction with northland superior‟s wheat head destroyer, atypical
operation will recover in excess of 70% of wheat by weight from the wheat heads.
Unique feature of Northland Superior's Thresher ET-16 design is its ability to perform the
dual function of a debearder. By changing the drive and slowing down the Rpm‟s of the
inner drum, customers are able to debeared barley, clip and polish oats and de-awn
durum. This saves in both floor space and additional equipment costs. The ET series
threshers essentially consist of a dynamically balanced inner drum rotating within a
heavy gauge abrasion-resistant outer casing. The inner drum and inside casing of the
housing are lined with hard surface beater bars. Wheat heads enter into the thresher at the
inlet hopper and are conveyed and forced through the constricted space between the
beater bars. The threshed wheat and chaff are discharged from the machine for of the
product through the thresher. Further separation on existing, cleaning ET series thresher
equipment is needed. Processing efficiency can be controlled by adjustments on the
weighted discharge gate, thereby altering the flow rate. [5]
Mekelle university 8
Design of multi crop thresher machine
Mekelle university 9
Design of multi crop thresher machine
CHAPTER THREE
3. CONCEPTUAL DESIGN
Conceptual design is designing ideally a layout of a given machine model, components or
parts in different and more suitable way by considering different angles.
During a design of multi crop thresher, things to be considered are; Determination of
Power Required to thresh off grains from stalk, threshing velocity, pulley analysis, belt
analysis, shaft analysis, and determination of torque required combing off grains from
stalk, pulley arm considerations and blowers. The - rasp-bar-and wire concave
mechanism can be used for almost all crops, provided that clearance stators-to-beaters is
correct and that beater speed is correct for the crop being threshed.
We prepared three conceptual models to design multi crop thresher;
3.1 Model A
Thresher with gear box and single sieve
This multi crop thresher has one sieve and gear box, the gear box reduces the speed
of the engine during thresh the highly dried crops grin because highly dried crops have
the tendency of break. The sieve of the thresher is cleans ones, because of this some of
straw will pass together with grain.
Fig 6, multi crop thresher with gear box and single sieve
Mekelle university 10
Design of multi crop thresher machine
3.2Model B
Thresher with gear box and two sieves
This thresher, which has two sieves will clean two times in order to separate some
small straws those passed together with grain during thresh. The gear box helps to change
the speed of the engine.
Fig.7. multi crop thresher with gear box, and two sieves.
3.3Model C
Thresher with two sieves, and different pulley diameters instead of gear box for speed
reduction.
This thresher has pulleys with different pulley diameters instead of gear box. It
reduces the speed of the engine as we need to thresh the crop.
Mekelle university 11
Design of multi crop thresher machine
2 Physical functionality
Average size of component 3 4 4
Less number of components 3 5 5
Complexity 2 4 4
Weight 2 4 3
Mekelle university 13
Design of multi crop thresher machine
Operationabilty 3 4 4
3 Mechanical functionality
Reliability 5 3 4
Durability 4 3 4
Stability 4 3 3
Total sum 54 66 68
Table1design matrix
3.7 Decision and Conclusion
Comparing the above four main concepts of obtaining mechanism for threshing multi
crops in many especially based on mechanical properties and cost effectiveness; the
selection of the feature in model concept ’c’ , is beneficial and viable decision
Mekelle university 14
Design of multi crop thresher machine
Inlet
Threshing unit
Cleaning unit
Grain discharge
Mekelle university 15
Design of multi crop thresher machine
CHAPTER FOUR
4. DESIGN ANALYSIS
Design specification
Grain output= 8.3Kg/min = 500Kg/h
Motor speed= 1500rpm
Feed rate= 12.5kg/min
Drum speed= 900rpm
Drum type: Peg tooth with an open threshing drum
Drum shape: cylindrical
Cleaning mechanism: using blower
Source of power: electric motor
Type of drive: belt drive
Mekelle university 16
Design of multi crop thresher machine
Mekelle university 17
Design of multi crop thresher machine
Mekelle university 18
Design of multi crop thresher machine
Mekelle university 19
Design of multi crop thresher machine
Design power
Design power (Pd) of belt drives is given by:
Pd =power transmitted * safety factor.
For uniform driven machinery, safety factor (ks) = 1-1.2
Say ks =1.15
Now the Pd= 8.3kw*1.15
Pd = 9.545kw …………….ans.
B 50-150 125-200
Table 3
Center to center distance
Center to center distance is calculated by:
C= (0.07-0.1)* v belt. [7]
Take 0.08 to be the multiplication factor.
C= 0.078 * 26.2
C= 0.94m.……………………………………………………..ans.
Angle of contact on pulleys
1. the angle of contact on smaller pulley is given by:
Ө1= 180-2sin-1(d2-d1)/ (2*c) degrees
Ө1= 180- 2sin-1(250-200)/ (2*.94*1000)
Calculating the above equation and we get,
Ө1=174.780……………………………………………………………ans.
2. the angle of contact on the larger pulley is also given as :
Ө2=180+2sin-1(250-200)/ (2*0.94*1000)
Substituting the above values and we get,
Ө2= 185.220
Length of the v-belt
Mekelle university 20
Design of multi crop thresher machine
V-belt section
2β=400
Fig.2. belt section
From table for v belt sections B type
B= width of the belt
t= thickness of the belt
And their values are:
B=17mm and
t= 11mm
Assume the belt is made of rubber with a density,
ρ=1000kg/m3
Now, the power transmitted by the belt is given by:
P= (t1-t2)*v
Where t1= tension on the tight side, N
t2= tension on the slack side. N
V= velocity of the belt in m/s.
Again t1 can be found from
T1-Tc
Where Tc is the centrifugal tension of the belt, and it is calculated by:
Tc= m*v2 where, m= mass of the belt per length
And the mass m is given by:
M=area*length*density
Now m= 1000*1.8056*A
Where A= bt
At b=17mm and t=11mm
A= 0.017*0.011
A=1.87*10-4kg/m
Now, m= 1000*1.8056*1.87*10-4
Mekelle university 21
Design of multi crop thresher machine
M= 0.3376kg/m……………………………………………………………..ans.
Now, Tc=mv2
= 0.3376*(11.782)
= 46.85N………………………………………………………ans.
We know that the relation between t1 and t2 is given by:
= 2.3log (t1/t2) =µ Ө cosecβ
Take µ of rubber = 0.3
At Ө=174.780=3.05 radians and 2β=400
Now 2.3log (t1/t2)=0.3*3.05* cosecβ
Log (t1/t2)=0.3978*2.924
Substituting the above values and we get:
Log (t1/t2) =1.16324
T1/t2=3.2 and …………………………. (.1)
The maximum tension in the belt is given by:
T=σ*b*t
Where σ=allowable bending stress
B= width of the belt
t= thickness of the belt
For rubber B belt type
σ=2.1Mpa
b=17mm
t=11mm
T=2.1*106*0.017*0.011
T = 392.7N…………………………………………………………………………ans.
Therefore tension in the tight side of the belt can be obtained from
T1= T-Tc
T1= 392.7-20.83
T1 = 371.87N…………………………………………………………..ans.
Now from (1) we get:
T1/T2=3.2
T2=116.21N……………………………………………………………..ans.
Now, the power transmitted by the belt tensions is given by:
Pt= (t1-t2)*v
= (371.87-116.21)*11.78
= 3011.67w
Pt= 3.11kw……………………………………………………………….ans.
torques on the driving and driven pulleys are
T1= (t1-t2)*r1
= (371.87-116.21)*d1/2
Substituting the corresponding values and we get:
Mekelle university 22
Design of multi crop thresher machine
T1=25.566N.m…………………………………………………………ans.
And T2= (t1-t2)*r2
= (371.87-116.21)*d2/2 T2= 31.9575N.m………………..ans.
Initial tension of the belt (ti)
t1+t2=2*ti
√ (Ti) =1/4*(√ ti+√t2)
√ Ti=1/4*(√ 371.87+ √ 116.21)
Now, Ti=56.49N………………………………………………………………..ans.
Table.4
The maximum power transmitted by the belt is given by:
Pmaxb= Tmax*V
= 392.7N*7.854m/s
= 3084.26w.
And the belt correction factor K2 is selected as:
Table 5
From fig.17-7 of page (676) the correction factor K1=0.99 (from graph)
Interpolating the above values and we get,
The rated horse power as indicated from table 17-9, page (676) of Joseph Edward shigley
Hr= 2.801hp and the corrected horse power (H) is given by:
H= 3.084*.99*.95=2.634
Now, the number of belts required is given by:
n = design power /power transmitted by the belt (corrected power)
n = 9.545/2.634
n = 3.62376 since n should be even number now the number of belts required
n = 4…………………………………………………………………………………ans.
Belt life
Durability (life) correlations are complicated by the fact that the bending induces
flexural stresses in the belt. The corresponding belt tension that induces the same
Mekelle university 23
Design of multi crop thresher machine
maximum tensile stress is, fb1 at the driving sheave and fb2 at the driven pulley. These
equivalent tensions are added to f1 as:
T1= f1+ (fb1) =f1+Kb/d1
T2= f2+ (fb2) =f1+Kb/d2 where Kb is given as:
From table 17.16, pa#1073, [7]
Belt section Kb Kc
B 576 0.965
Table 6
The tension passes trade –off question as used by the gates Rubber Company is:
Tbnp=kb
Where b is from table 17.17 [7]
Table 7
From the minor rule used to sum damage incurred by the two tension peaks.
1/np= (K/T1)-b+ (K/T2)-b or
np= [(K/T1)-b+ (K/T2)-b]-1passes.
The life in hours is given by:
t= np*Lp/ (720*v)
Note: if np>109 report that np>109 and t> np*LP/ (720*v) without placing confidence in
numerical values beyond the validity interval.
Mekelle university 24
Design of multi crop thresher machine
Mekelle university 25
Design of multi crop thresher machine
Mekelle university 26
Design of multi crop thresher machine
Arm considerations
Tangential load per arm,
Wt=T/(r*n/2) =2T/r*n
Where t= torque transmitted
R= radius of pulley
n= number of arms.
From standard for pulleys diameters ranging from 200-600mm
n=4
We know that the torque transmitted is given by:
T= 60*Pdes/ (2* π*n2)
Substituting the corresponding values and we get
T= 140.22N.m
Wt=2*T/R*n
= 2*140.22/ (0.25*4/2)
= 560.9N ……………………………………………………………….ans.
Cross section of arms is given by:
M/Z=σb where M= maximum bending moment on the arm at hub end.
Z = section modulus of arm
σb = bending stress for arm material.
Where Z is given by:
Z= π*d3/32 and
M= 2*T*R/ (R*n) = 2*T/n
Where d is diameter of arms, now using T=140.22N
M= 2*T/n= 2*140.22/4
= 70.11*103N-mm………………………………………………………ans.
The allowable bending stress for cast iron pulleys is given as:
σb(all) = 15Mpa. Then from the relation
M/Z= fb we get
Z= M/fb= 70.11*103/15
Z= 4676mm3……………………………………………………………….ans.
Again Z is given by: Z= π*d3/32 from this equation we can get
3
d =32*Z/ π putting the above values and we get
d= 36.24mm
Say d= 38mm………………………………………………………………ans.
Determination of hub diameter
d1=2*d
Where d= diameter of shaft
d1=diameter of hub
To find the diameter of hub let‟s find first the diameter of shaft.
We know that the torque transmitted by the shaft is given by:
Mekelle university 27
Design of multi crop thresher machine
Mekelle university 28
Design of multi crop thresher machine
Vb= A*w
= π (.32-.292)/4*(0.02)
= 37.45*10-6m3…………………………………………………………….ans.
Fan:
h= 100mm
w= 125mm
t= 4mm
vf= h*w*t
= 50 *10-6m3……………………………………………………………ans.
Mekelle university 29
Design of multi crop thresher machine
Mekelle university 30
Design of multi crop thresher machine
Mekelle university 31
Design of multi crop thresher machine
Fig 5. shaft
Mekelle university 32
Design of multi crop thresher machine
1. Stationary shafts
(a) Gradually applied 1.0 1.0
load
(b) Suddenly applied 1.5 – 2.0 1.5 – 2.0
load
2. Rotating shafts
(a) Gradually applied 1.5 1.0
or
steady load
(b) Suddenly applied 1.5 – 2.0 1.5 – 2.0
load
with minor shocks
only
(c) Suddenly applied 2.0 – 3.0 1.5 – 3.0
load
with heavy shocks
Mekelle university 33
Design of multi crop thresher machine
Mekelle university 34
Design of multi crop thresher machine
Fig.8. keys
Mekelle university 35
Design of multi crop thresher machine
\
Fig.9. key dimensions
Let‟s now check the induced shear and crushing stresses in the key.
Shearing:
τs= F/As where F= force applied ds= 25mm
As= shear area T= 121.59Nm
F= T/r= 9727.2N r=ds/2 = 25/2= 12.5mm
-6
As= l*w= 600*10
τs= 16.212Mpa.
Since this is less than (16.212Mpa<50Mpa). Therefore it is safe.
Crushing:
σ= F/Ac where Ac= crushing area
= l*t/2= 40*10-6
F=9272.2N
Now, σ= 38.63Mpa
Since this is less than (38.63<80). Therefore design of the key for crushing is safe.
Mekelle university 36
Design of multi crop thresher machine
Let‟s now check the induced shear and crushing stresses in the key.
Shearing:
τs= F/As where F= force applied shaft diameter, ds= 30mm
As= shear area T= 140.22Nm
F= T/r= 9348N r=ds/2 = 30/2= 15mm
-6
As= l*w= 600*10
τs= 15.58Mpa…………………………………………………………………ans.
Since this is less than (15.58Mpa< 50Mpa). Therefore it is safe.
Crushing:
σ= F/Ac where Ac= crushing area
= l*t/2= 240*10-6
F= 9348N
σ= 38.95Mpa
Since this is less than (38.95<80). Therefore design of the key for crushing is safe.
Mekelle university 37
Design of multi crop thresher machine
15
Mekelle university 38
Design of multi crop thresher machine
I. bending stress
σb= M/z= M/ (π*t*d2)/4=4M/ π*t*d2
Where σb= bending stress
M= bending moment, Z= section modulus
The maximum bending moment M is given by:
M= qL2/2 Where q= distributed force. L = length of tong
q, On each tong is equal to the force and is given by:
q=F= 2.29N
Now, M= qL2/2, where L= 60mm
= 2.29*0.06/2=0.0687N.m…..………………………………………………ans.
And assume thickness of weld to be t=3mm, and the diameter of the tong is d=15mm
Now, σb= 4*M/ (π*t*d2) = 4*0.0687/ (π*0.0152*0.003)
= 0.129Mpa…………………………………………………………………..ans.
II. shearing stress
The shear stress τs is given by:
τs= F/a Where F= applied force
A = throat area and is given by:
A= π *d*t= 0.7071*π*d*x
Where d= diameter of tong
X= size of weld
The section modulus Z= π*t*d2/4=0.07071* π*d2*x/4 substituting the corresponding
values and we get
t= 0.7071*x where t= 3mm
x= 3/0.7071=4.24 mm
Say x= 5mm…………………………………………………………………………ans.
Now, A= π*d*t=π*0.015*0.003
Mekelle university 39
Design of multi crop thresher machine
= 141.372*10-6…………………………………………………………………ans.
And F=2.2.29N
Now, τs=F/A
Substituting the values and we get, τs= 0.0162Mpa……………………………………ans.
Mekelle university 40
Design of multi crop thresher machine
Fig. 13 blower
1. The feed rate of the contaminants, which are to be entrained by the air stream, is
obtained as
q1 =bq/100
Where q1= feed rate of the grain stock = 290Kg/min
b = the amount of contaminants (%) in the feed material.
q1=0.35x150/100 =0525 kg/s
2. An air stream velocity u is selected such that it is greater than the terminal velocity of
the light contaminants and smaller than that of the principal grain material.
For wheat terminal velocity ut = 8.9------11.5m/s
3. The quantity of air required to entrain the material is determined from the expression.
0 =q1/q2
Where 0 <1 is the concentration coefficient of the contaminant- air mix,
q2 is the air delivery per unit time, kg/s.
Mekelle university 41
Design of multi crop thresher machine
Table.10 [7]
M in and lb mm and kw
Radial ball 1.78(1000) 5.11(1000)
Mekelle university 42
Design of multi crop thresher machine
Now at LD=6000hrs
nd= 650rev/min
FD1=741.7N and FD2=-42.2N reaction forces on bearings respectively.
The expression Lr*nr*60=106
The design basic dynamic radial load C10 will be:
C10=741.7*(6000*650*60/106)1/a
Design basic dynamic radial load C10= 4.562KN*Ks taking Ks= 1.2
C10= 5.4744KN………………………………….…ans.
The basic life of bearing is (the number of revolutions or hours at constant speed). That
90% of a group of bearings will achieve or exceed before the failure criterion develops
and given by:
L10= 60*Lr*n*R*(C10/Fe) a/ (60*nd)
Where Fe= is the equivalent radial load and is given
Fe=Fr= 42.2N…………………smaller
Now, bearing life L10 =106*(5474.4/42.2)3/ (60*650)
= 550.23*106hrs………………………………………………ans.
Fig. 13 bearing
Mekelle university 43
Design of multi crop thresher machine
Table 11 [7]
Table.12
Mekelle university 44
Design of multi crop thresher machine
Table 12 [6]
Assume one end free and the other end fixed
L=2*l
Cases for buckling to occur
1. if Wcr<Wapp or
2. σ>σall.
The weight applied on the support frame; assume it is the weight of the beater, pulley,
cover, shaft, and weight of bearings plus bolts and spikes to be:
W=Wc+Ws+Wb+Wbr+Ws
Wt=19+6 N= 25N
Now the total weight WT= 25N+111.4N+623N=759.4N……………………………ans.
Since we are considering the frame as a column:
The force applied on one of the supports is given by:
WT/4= 189.85N…………...................ans.
Factor of safety for steady loads is given as: F.S= (5-6)
Therefore; the critical load Wcr=F.S*189.85N
= 949.25N………………………………………….ans.
Assume the support is rectangular iron type steel with dimensions of b=t (squared cross
section).
Mekelle university 45
Design of multi crop thresher machine
Mekelle university 46
Design of multi crop thresher machine
Fig.14 wheel
Wheel material:
Cast iron and has an actual dimensions of
D= 300mm, W= 50mm, t= 10mm
Cast iron ultimate strengths Modulus of elasticity E= 100-160Gpa
Ultimate tensile stress, σut=100-200Mpa Density of cast iron, ρ=7200kg/m3 [7]
Ultimate crushing stress, σuc= 400-
1000Mpa Taking factor of safety, KS=2
Ultimate shear stress τu= 120Mpa, σall= 400/2=200Mpa
if we take the minimum compressive stress.
Now, to check for crushing
σcr= Wcr/Ac where Ac= crushing area of the wheel
Wcr = applied load on each of the wheel
The crushing area is given by: Ac= d*t
Ac= 0.46*0.01=4.16*10-3m2
Now, σcr=Wcr/Ac where Wcr=W/2=379.7
= 0.091Mpa……………………………………………………………ans.
Since, σcr<σall design for wheel is safe.
Shaft of the wheel material;
Material selected: steel 40c8
With σu=560-670Mpa
τu =320Mpa
F.S= 2
Since, this shaft is subjected to bending only; the bending moment given to solid shaft is
given by:
Assume: length of the shaft L=780mm
M/I=fb/y
Where M= bending moment of the shaft material
Mekelle university 47
Design of multi crop thresher machine
I= moment of inertia of cross sectional area of the shaft about axis of rotation.
fb= bending stress of the shaft material
y= distance from neutral axis to outer most fiber
The terms stated above are calculated as follows:
I= π*d4/64 M= π*fb*d3/32 y=d/2=
Now, the maximum bending moment on the shaft is given by:
Mmax= W*d/2 where d=680/2+25=0.365m
Mmax= 759.5/2*0.365= 138.59N.m.
fb= σu/F.S= 600/2=fb= 300Mpa
Now from the relation given above
M/I=300/d/2=M/I=600/d
M/π*d4/64
=600/d=64M/π*d3 substituting and we get:
d3 = 16.75mm Say d=30mm……………………………………………………..….ans.
Fig.15. sieve
Mekelle university 48
Design of multi crop thresher machine
Mekelle university 49
Design of multi crop thresher machine
Now, checking for the sieve either it is bending or not when the load is applied on it.
Bending area
Let the thickness of the sieve be t,
Ab= w*t= 0.4*t
And the bending force (force applied), F, on the sieve material is:
Wc= 262.5N
Now, σall= σs/FS= 360/1.5= 240Mpa
σall= Wc/Ab= 262.5/0.4*t
t= 2.7mm, Say t= 3mm…………………………………………………………………ans.
Mekelle university 50
Design of multi crop thresher machine 2007
[7 ]
Fig. 18 connecting rod
Odc= outer dead center
Idc = inner dead center of the crank
Fc= force exerted on the sieve and transmits to the rod
From the fig above the crank radius, r=d/2= 90mm
Since the connecting rod is designed by taking the force in the connecting rod (Fc) equal to the
maximum force on the sieve (weight) due to weight of the sieve + crop dropped, therefore, force
in the connecting rod,
Fc= F=W=105N.
The connecting rod is designed for buckling about (in plane of motion of the connecting rod)
assume both ends hinged, taking factor of safety F.S=6.
The buckling load is given by:
Wcr=Fc*F.S= 105*6=630N.
If the connecting rod has a rectangular cross section;
Mekelle university
51
Design of multi crop thresher machine 2007
Mekelle university
52
Design of multi crop thresher machine 2007
Mekelle university
53
Design of multi crop thresher machine 2007
Mekelle university
54
Design of multi crop thresher machine 2007
= 4.22/s N/mm2
Bending moment, M = P * e = 0.0941*20 = 1.882*103Nmm
Section modules of the weld through the throat,
( )
Z= =
= 94.29 s mm2
Bending moment, σb = M/Z = 1.882*103/94.29 s
= 0.0199/s N/mm2
We know that maximum shear stress (τmax)
124.1 = √( ) = √( ) ( )
z
s = 4.1/124.1 = 0.033mm but
Minimum fillet weld size, for plate thickness up to ¼ inch (6.35 mm) can be taken as 1/8 in =
3.17 ≈ 4 mm……………………………………….ans.
Mekelle university
55
Design of multi crop thresher machine 2007
Mekelle university
56
Design of multi crop thresher machine 2007
Mekelle university
57
Design of multi crop thresher machine 2007
CHAPTER FIVE
5 Cost Estimation
Mekelle university
58
Design of multi crop thresher machine 2007
CHAPTER SIX
6. Manufacturing process
To manufacture this multi crop thresher machine, since it is a combination of different
components, different types of manufacturing processes are applied. Some of this manufacturing
processes used to manufacture this multi crop thresher are listed below
1) Machining
Machining operation is used to manufacture the thresher components like; shaft, for surface
finishing of pulley and other components which needs operations like; grinding, drilling milling,
and turning operations.
2) Casting
To manufacture the pulley which is made from cast iron, casting operation is used.
3) Welding
Welding operation is used to join different sides of the supporting frame and also to weld the
beaters with that of the drum and also to weld the concave and the cover plate.
Mekelle university
59
Design of multi crop thresher machine 2007
CHAPTER SEVEN
7. Assembling procedure
1. The main support frame together with the concave bars, motor together with the pulley,
speed reducer, disk is first made ready on the required place with specified position.
2. Insert both the sieves under the concave bars and connect the sieves with the rotating disk
using connecting rod.
3. Attach the shaft and the bearing on the upper support frame.
4. Shaft together with beater placed on the upper of supporting frame through the bearing.
5. Fix the shaft and bearing with the supporting frame using bearing bolts.
6. Attach pulley on the upper shaft.
7. Connect the lower and upper pulleys using belt strands.
8. Provide pulley cover belt cover for the upper pulley.
9. Place the beater cover together with out let of the blowing straw.
10. Attach the flat spade (sheet metal) and fix it through the inlet position using bolt with the
support frame.
11.Finally both the assembled components placed on the support frame and tightened by
bolts.
Mekelle university
60
Design of multi crop thresher machine 2007
CHAPTER EIGHT
8. Conclusion and Recommendation
8.1 Conclusion
It is with full confidence to say that this machine will do effectively and lighten the
burden of our farmer‟s duties if it is properly manufactured with the described design
specifications. The machine described in this report will effectively thresh wheat, Teff, sorghum,
and barley using a power of 8KW with 900 rpm of motor speed. This thresher is designed to
provide all the necessary equipment such as, different pulley diameters (speed reducer), sieves
and some necessary dimensions with four number of belt strands. This machine is suitable for all
farmers in Ethiopia who are suffering with traditional way of threshing device.
The machine is suited completely for production by 'village technology' methods, since no
components require high levels of technical equipment and skill. It would appear that the use of a
wheat and barley thresher multiplies labour productivity by a factor of 3 over hand threshing.
Mekelle university
61
Design of multi crop thresher machine 2007
8.2 Recommendation
1.The design is done on certain reasonable assumptions such as disk dimension, small pulley
dimension, number of tongs, beater dimension etc. so that these concepts should be carefully
taken in to consideration as they bring significant change in the overall performance of the wheat
and barley thresher.
2. During installation, production, and threshing of the components great care should be taken to
maintain the results of the design.
3. Since modern threshers in Ethiopia is not that much therefore further investigations should be
taken to improve these threshing mechanism (machines) for further improvement.
4. Since this thresher is not require highly skilled person to install, operate therefore every farmer
should be trouble free on buying, working and using this thresher.
5. The crops must be dry, in order to be threshed well by the machine, but in this case it do not
lose its moisture content.
6. Concave clearance will be 11mm with each diameter of 10mm irons and total of 28 tongs.
7. The sieves should be inclined at 70 during assembling.
Mekelle university
62
Design of multi crop thresher machine 2007
References
1. Threshing machine - Wikipedia, the free encyclopaedia
2. Alex Weir November 1999, introduction of multi crop threshers
3. http:// www.ard-raise.com, multicrop threshers
4. VITA – (1972) - "Portable Thresher" (mimeo) published Volunteers for
International Technical Assistance, vv@vita.org http://www.vita.org/ Maryland USA
5. http://www.fao.org/inpho/ Institute of agricultural research organization holeta agricultural
center (IARC), Barley: Post-Harvest Operations.
6. R.S. KHURMI J.K. GUPTA 2005 EURASIA PUBLISHING HOUSE (PVT.) LTD.
RAM NAGAR, NEW DELHI-110 055
7. Joseph Edward shigley. Charles R mischeke, mechanical Engineering design 6 th
edition. New York, 2001.
8. SG2000 multi crop thresher design manual (Combolcha agricultural center)
Mekelle university
63
Design of multi crop thresher machine 2007
Appendix
Mekelle university
64
Design of multi crop thresher machine 2007
Mekelle university
65
Design of multi crop thresher machine 2007
Mekelle university
66
Design of multi crop thresher machine 2007
Mekelle university
67
Design of multi crop thresher machine 2007
Mekelle university
68
Design of multi crop thresher machine 2007
Mekelle university
69