The Five-Year Resume: A Career Planning Exercise: Dennis R. Laker Ruth Laker
The Five-Year Resume: A Career Planning Exercise: Dennis R. Laker Ruth Laker
The Five-Year Resume: A Career Planning Exercise: Dennis R. Laker Ruth Laker
PLANNING EXERCISE
Dennis R. Laker
Widener University
Ruth Laker
Laker Associates
For most college students, lack of career planning wastes time and resources and
may result in years of “career drift.” Lack of planning can also lead to deception
once students begin seeking career-related employment. Faced with a competitive
job market, some students inflate and exaggerate their resumes. The five-year
resume exercise helps students avoid these difficulties by developing a future ori-
entation toward their career goals. Students create the resumes they would like to
have in five years. This exercise encourages both self-management and proactive-
ness. The exercise, sample questions, and a template are provided. Illustrations of
student feedback, benefits, and suggestions for faculty are presented.
Alice: Would you tell me, please which way I ought to walk from here?
Cheshire Cat: That depends a good deal on where you want to go to.
Alice: I don’t much care where.
Cheshire Cat: Then it doesn’t matter which way you walk.
—Louis Carroll (n.d., p. 89)
Author’s Note: Parts of this article were presented at the Mid-Atlantic Regional
Organizational Behavior Teaching Conference, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, March 24, 2001,
and the the International College Teaching & Learning Conference in Las Vegas, Nevada,
October 4-8, 2004. We would like to thank two Journal of Management Education anony-
mous reviewers and Margaret Robinson at the Widener University Writing Center for their
helpful comments and suggestions on earlier drafts of this article. Correspondence should be
addresssed to Dennis R. Laker, Widener University, 129 Quick Center, School of Business
Administration, One University Place, Chester, PA 19013; phone: (610) 499-4512; e-mail:
drlaker@mail.widener.edu; Ruth Laker, www.sevenstarspress.com.
128
Laker, Laker / THE FIVE-YEAR RESUME 129
The day I entered graduate school, a professor told me that I was there
because of what I had done five years ago and that where I would be in five
years would be determined by what I did today. I was surprised by this
statement. The link between the present and the future is obvious for most
but noticed by few. This lack of awareness is true of most students’ efforts
at career planning.
A frequent lament of many parents, faculty, and even of students them-
selves is that students do not plan their careers beyond picking their college
or university and choosing their major. Although students will eventually
decide on and pursue career goals, their efforts are often quite haphazard.
Rarely do they realize that what they do today has implications for their
professional development and future career opportunities. This lack of real-
ization leads to a failure to plan and limits their ability to be proactive in
their career pursuits. Indeed, a future orientation in one’s vocational devel-
opment is a sign of maturity, yet little has been done in career planning to
address this concept or promote a future orientation in career counseling
(Savickas, 1991; Whan, 1995). When students are encouraged to take a
future orientation, they develop a better sense of the continuity between
their past, present, and future (Marko & Savickas, 1998).
Research has shown that many college students are uncertain about how
to establish a professional career (Collins, 1998). Many of those entering
the workforce are poorly informed and subsequently ill prepared. For
instance, research has shown that newcomers to the workforce are not
knowledgable about potential careers, opportunities for career advance-
ment, or what their specific skills and interests are (Brousseau & Driver,
1994; Lyon & Kirby, 2000).
The first author has used this exercise for more than 20 years with more
than 1,000 students and has found it helped them better understand the impor-
tance of career planning and showed them how to be more proactive in devel-
oping and managing their professional development. The exercise asks
students to design their future in synchrony with their desired objectives con-
cerning life, family, and environment. Students create the resume they envision
having in five years, including the jobs, positions, experience, education, and
references the student would want to have by then. This process helps students
visualize their future on paper. The differences between the current resume and
the five-year resume identify the goals to accomplish within the next five
years, and these goals create a series of targets in developing an action plan.
Such planning leads to greater career success and overall life satisfaction.
The resume format is used because students are quite familiar with the
resume, and it plays such a critical role in their future employment. Practical
exercises in resume writing are routinely provided in colleges and are rated
most highly by college students when compared with other pedagogical
130 JOURNAL OF MANAGEMENT EDUCATION / February 2007
activities (Schroth, Pankake, & Gates, 1999). The current resume represents
a professional snapshot of who the student is. The five-year resume, in con-
trast, is a picture of who the student wants to become professionally. The
starting point in creating the five-year resume is in identifying where one is
now, where one wants to be, and how one is going to get there. In this way,
the five-year resume helps to make career planning a conscious and system-
atic process. It serves as a map to guide students in making employment and
career-related decisions and in creating action plans to help them achieve
their career objectives. The use of five years is somewhat arbitrary. In reality,
any number of years could be used, but we have found five to be both a man-
ageable time period and the minimum needed to be of practical usefulness.
This exercise may be of interest to individuals who are trying to actively
plan and manage their own careers and to professionals who work with
students and have an interest in helping them to develop professionally. The
first author has generally used this exercise as part of a management or
human resource class taught to sophomores, juniors, seniors, nontraditional
students, and graduate or professional students. The five-year resume could
also be used as a stand-alone exercise for career exploration.
This exercise also addresses two other career-related issues some
students face: career drift and misrepresentation. Career drift usually occurs
in the absence of personal proactiveness and self-initiative. By not planning
their careers, most students’ efforts at professional development become
unstructured and fragmented. Their careers appear to be rudderless, falling
to the mercy of various forces, all seemingly out of their control. From
our perspective, it is important that an individual creates his or her future
rather than merely accepting it. Jack Welch, ex-CEO of General Electric,
expressed this point this way: “Manage your destiny, or somebody else
will.” Proactiveness decreases the likelihood of sitting back and letting
something or someone else manage your destiny.
Paradoxically, despite their lack of planning, research suggests that
students want both more career planning time with advisers (Alexitch,
1997) and approaches that use an interactive method in order to help them
explore career goals via academic planning (Broadbridge, 1996). Lyon
and Kirby (2000) advocated the perspective that professors have an oblig-
ation to help students develop the skills necessary to be successful and
satisfied in their future careers. This includes the intellectual and content-
related expertise acquired from their classes, as well as the skills related
to career exploration, job search, and professional development. We, too,
believe it is the responsibility of professors, advisers, and counselors to
help students actively with such planning and to provide them with the
tools they need to focus on their future and help provide the direction they
greatly require.
Laker, Laker / THE FIVE-YEAR RESUME 131
The first step is to create a current resume that identifies where students
are professionally and educationally. The current resume serves as the start-
ing point for career planning and represents where students are now and
what they have achieved to date. Instructions for the current resume are in
Appendix A.
The second step is to create a resume that represents what students want
their resumes to look like in five years. The new resume should include any
132 JOURNAL OF MANAGEMENT EDUCATION / February 2007
For students who are unclear about their career goals, we recommend
career counseling and an exercise in career exploration. One career
exploratory exercise is the Career Wheel (Laker, 2002). Through this exer-
cise, students validate or invalidate their beliefs and assumptions about the
careers they are contemplating or actively pursuing. The goal of the Career
Wheel is to help students make a more informed career/job choice.
Although it can help students identify potential careers, its primary purpose
is to provide students with a systematic plan for exploring the careers in
which they are interested. The Career Wheel exercise relies on both self-
reflection and on making contact with professionals in the field. It uses
informational interviews in the true sense of the word, rather than as ploys
to seek employment (Laker, 2002). A second approach for exploring career
opportunities is to view potential careers through online mentoring
(Whiting & de Janasz, 2004). This approach also allows the student to
explore a variety of careers and career paths.
The third step is for students to determine their short-term and long-term
goals. Students identify long-term goals by conceptually subtracting what
is on their current resume from what is on their five-year resume. (See
Appendix B for illustrations.) The difference identifies what they need to
achieve in order to reach their five-year goals. These goals then serve as a
basis for developing a series of short-term, specific milestones that need to
be accomplished in order to achieve the long-term goals.
Laker, Laker / THE FIVE-YEAR RESUME 133
The sixth step is to have students summarize what they have learned
from this exercise. Students prepare a final paper that outlines how they
have performed each of the six steps of the project and the conclusions they
have drawn. Most students use this summary to reflect on their experience
and either validate or invalidate their career choices. At this time, we also
ask each student to evaluate the exercise by answering the following four
questions:
However, one has to remember that these are their careers, and our role is
to provide guidance, not judgment.
A traditional evaluation of this exercise is difficult. We found it extremely
difficult to evaluate the content of the five-year resume in the traditional
sense of looking for a correct or desired response. Instead, we focus on
whether and to what extent the student completed each of the various steps
of the exercise. All six steps should be part of the evaluation process.
Students are also required to seek input from our Career Planning and
Services program on campus. They review and advise students in the cre-
ation of their current resume. We have also required students to take their
five-year resume to a separate professional in the field for that individual’s
review and input. Judging the efficacy or benefits of this exercise should not
be restricted to only whether there is a demonstrable impact on their stated
career-related goals. The success of this exercise is not that they achieve the
objectives that they listed on their five-year resume per se but that they
understand and appreciate the value of career planning and that they can be
proactive in terms of their career management. Many students, upon com-
pletion of this exercise, come to the conclusion that they are pursuing the
wrong career and switch majors, a decision that is better made sooner than
later and a testament to the effectiveness of the exercise.
This exercise really helped me to examine my future. Have I taken the right
steps to be in that position? What additional steps do I need to take? I enjoyed
the assignment, and it helped me organize my career goals.
I found that this was a very challenging and eye-opening experience. What
I liked is that by writing down my goals, I have a very good chance of achiev-
ing them. With my day-to-day activities I would not have taken the time to
do this very important exercise. This exercise “reenergized me.”
I am not sure if this is where I will be in five years, but it gives me some sort
of basis to try and gear my future. It really made me think about my future
and where I wanted to be in five years. This exercise forced me to look at my
life and set goals for the next five years. It made me realize that I am the only
one that can take care of my career plans.
I feel the key part of this assignment was the personal assessment of my cur-
rent skills and how they needed to match or possibly be enhanced to the skills
required for those positions I aspire to in the future.
It’s amazing—I actually decided to use vacation time to get some useful
experience at a client’s business.
Summary
Appendix A
Student Instructions and the Steps in the Five-Year Resume
Exercise
The first step is to create a current resume that identifies where you are profes-
sionally and educationally. The second step is to create a resume that repre-
sents what you want your resume to look like in five years. Appendix B
provides a template of the five-year resume that can serve as a guide to help
in completing this part of the exercise.
You can identify the entries for your five-year resume in a variety of ways. You
should not create your five-year resume in a vacuum. It is important to talk
to a number of professionals in your desired field in creating this resume. You
may also acquire the resumes of individuals who presently have or have had
the position(s) that you aspire to possess. You may use old want ads to iden-
tify jobs you would like to have in the future. You may also want to talk to
seniors who have been recognized in their field by the faculty or who have
been highly sought after by employers. If you are unclear as to what career
you wish to pursue, there are a variety of ways that you might explore possi-
ble careers. One career exploratory exercise is the Career Wheel (Laker,
2002). The reference for this exercise appears below.
The third step is to identify your short-term and long-term goals. You identify
these long-term goals by conceptually subtracting what’s on your current
resume from what you have on your five-year resume. The difference is what
you plan to achieve in order to reach your five-year goals. These goals then
serve as a basis for developing a series of more short-term, specific goals that
would need to be accomplished in order to achieve your long-term goals.
Research on goal setting has found that to be most effective, goals should be
specific and measurable. It is extremely beneficial that you create some way
of measuring your progress in accomplishing these goals.
The fourth step is to create a series of action plans and identify the resources
needed to complete them. You need to address the following questions: What
is going to be done? When will it be done? What resources will be needed
(time, money, emotional and physical support, experiences, and opportuni-
ties)? If an internship or practical experience is necessary, you need to ask:
When will it occur? Who will it be with? Who can help with acquiring such
an experience? Your five-year goals can then be broken down by year, by
what will be accomplished in each of the 12 months of that year, and then
into each of the 4 weeks of each month, and so on. All decisions concerning
education, career, internships, job choice, and other actions should support
and be in alignment with your overall goals.
The fifth step is for you to discuss how you will implement your action plans.
Remember: Action planning is a dynamic process and thus is subject to
change; the five-year resume serves only as a starting point.
The sixth step is for you to summarize what you have learned from this exercise.
You need to prepare a final paper that outlines how you have performed each
of the previous five steps of this exercise and the conclusions you have drawn.
140 JOURNAL OF MANAGEMENT EDUCATION / February 2007
Laker, D. (2002). The Career Wheel: An exercise for exploring and validating one’s career
choices. Journal of Employment Counseling, 39, 61-72.
Abridged from Laker, D. (2005). The five-year resume: A career planning exercise and work-
book. Unpublished manuscript. Kimberton, PA. (610) 499-4512, drlaker@mail.widener.edu.
A published version of this workbook will be available in fall 2006 from Seven Stars Press,
www.sevenstarspress.com.
Appendix B
Five-Year Resume Questions
Abridged from Laker, D. (2005). The five-year resume: A career planning exercise and
workbook. Unpublished manuscript.
Laker, Laker / THE FIVE-YEAR RESUME 141
References
Alexitch, L. R. (1997). Students’ educational orientation and preferences for advising from
university professors. Journal of College Student Development, 38(4), 333-334.
Arthur, M. B., & Rousseau, D. M. (1996). Introduction: The boundaryless career as new
employment principle. In M. Arthur & D. Rousseau (Eds.), The boundaryless career:
A new employment principle for a new organizational era (pp. 3-19). New York: Oxford
University Press.
Broadbridge, A. (1996). Academic advising—Traditional or developmental approaches?
Student perspective. British Journal of Guidance and Counseling, 24(1), 97-111.
Brousseau, K. R., & Driver, M. J. (1994). Enhancing informed choice: A career concepts
approach to career advisement. Selections, 10, 24-31.
Carroll, L. (n.d.). Alice’s adventures in wonderland. New York: Avenel Books.
Collins, M. (1998, Spring). Great expectations: What students have to say about the process
and practice of launching a career. Journal of Career Planning and Placement, 41-47.
Hall, D. T. (1996). The career is dead: Long live the career. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
Hall, S. M., Jr. (2000). A sound planning calendar enables seniors to excel. Black Collegian,
31, 28-31.
Kossek, E., Roberts, K., Fisher, S., & DeMarr, B. (1998). Career self-management: A quasi-
experimental assessment of the effects of a training intervention. Personnel Psychology,
51(4), 935-962.
Laker, D. (2002). The Career Wheel: An exercise for exploring and validating one’s career
choices. Journal of Employment Counseling, 39, 61-72.
Laker, D. (2005). The five-year resume: A career planning exercise and workbook. Kimberton,
PA: Seven Stars Press, (610) 917-3021; www.sevenstarspress.com
Locke, E. A., & Latham, G. P. (1990). A theory of goal setting & task performance. Englewood
Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.
Lyon, D. W., & Kirby, E. G. (2000). The career planning essay. Journal of Management
Education, 24(2), 276-287.
Marko, K. W., & Savickas, M. L. (1998). Effectiveness of a career time perspective interven-
tion. Journal of Vocational Behavior, 52(1), 106-119.
Mirvis, P. H., & Hall, D. T. (1994). Psychological success and the boundaryless career. Journal
of Organizational Behavior, 15, 365-380.
Savickas, M. L. (1991). Improving career time perspective. In D. Brown & L. Brooks (Eds.),
Techniques of career counseling (pp. 236-249). Boston: Allyn & Bacon.
Schroth, G., Pankake, A., & Gates, G. (1999). A comparison of pedagogical approaches to
teaching graduate students in educational administration. Journal of Instructional
Psychology, 26(4), 238-249.
Whan, K. A. (1995). Modifying career time perspective. Dissertation Abstracts International−
Section B: The Science and Engineering, 55(10-13), 45-96.
Whiting, V. R., & de Janasz, S. C. (2004). Mentoring in the 21st century: Using the internet to
build skills and networks. Journal of Management Education, 28(3), 275-293.