Grammar Inf and Gerunds
Grammar Inf and Gerunds
Grammar Inf and Gerunds
Wenyuan Gu
The English verb has two major forms, finite and non-finite. How to use them correctly is very
important to English language learners (ELL), whose native language is not English when they
study English. Having taught English as a second language for many years, the writer tried to
summarize and illustrate the various use of the infinitive, one of the three non-finite forms - the
infinitive, the participles (which have two forms, the present participle and the past participle),
and the gerund, on the basis of his extensive reading and review of different English grammar
books, reference books, magazines, newspapers, books, and English dictionaries, etc., in order
for English language learners to further understand how to use the infinitive properly in the
English language. The infinite is the verb form that simply names the action of the verb, without
any other specification, etc., (in English used with or without to). The infinitive also has two
kinds of infinitive – infinitive with to (to-infinitive) and infinitive without to (bare infinitive).
“She always comes to help me,” in which to help is an infinitive with to. “I saw her leave the
house,” in which leave the house is an infinitive without to or bare infinitive. We do not say “I
saw her to leave the house”, because the verb see is followed by a bare infinitive when the
infinitive is used.
The symbol * means that the phrase or sentence is incorrect. AmE means American English and
BrE, British English. SVO means subject + verb + object, SVC, subject + verb +complement,
SVOiOd, subject + (indirect) object + (direct) object, SVOC, subject + verb + object +
complement, SVOA, subject + verb + object + adverbial, and SVOCA, subject + verb + object +
complement + adverbial.
1
The finite verb versus the non-finite verb
A finite verb phrase is one that can be the main verb of a sentence. A non-finite verb phrase is an
infinitive, participles (present and past), or a gerund. In the sentence “Many people stay up late
1
at night”, we have “stay up late at night” as its predicate, in which the verb “stay up” is a
finite verb. In the sentence “He went to see his father yesterday”, went is a finite verb and to
see is a non-finite verb to express purpose. A finite verb is one which predicates something of the
subject of the sentence in which it is. A verb is not necessarily, however, always used as a finite
verb. It can be used as a non-finite verb as well. In fact, the whole predicate including the verb
may be transplanted into other sentences, where it is to have the function not of a predicate but
of a subject, an object, a predicative, a complement, an attributive, an adverbial, or an
independent element, as the case may be. In that case, it will be non-finite, i.e., a gerund (if it is
tantamount to a noun) or an infinitive (if it is tantamount to a noun, an adjective or an adverb) or
a participle (if it is tantamount to an adjective or an adverb). To continue with one of the above
examples, which contains the predicate “stay up last at night”, we can for illustration apply the
same phrase in non-finite forms as follows:
There are three non-finites in English – the infinitive, the participles (which have two forms, the
present participle and the past participle), and the gerund, as described from the above
examples. Some people use both the present participle and the gerund as the –ing form because
they look the same in form – both having the –ing forms, but in this article the writer will discuss
the use of the infinitive only.
2
2
The infinitive
Infinitive forms
Active Passive
Indefinite to write to be written
Perfect to have written to have been written
Continuous or progressive to be writing to be being written
Perfect continuous or to have been writing to have been being
progressive written
From the above table, we do not usually have to have been being written, which sounds very
awkward although it exists.
For example:
3
The voice/tense of the non-finite for infinitives
A The tense of the infinitive expresses time relatively to that of the main (or principal) verb. If
the action expressed by the infinitive is of the same time as, or of later time than, that
expressed by the main verb, the indefinite or continuous/progressive forms should be used,
e.g.
3
a. He seems to know the fact.
(= It seems that he knows the fact. Simple form shows simultaneous action, but for
the progressive form to be knowing would be impossible, because know is a state
verb, which is not used in a progressive form.)
b. He seemed to know the fact. (= It seemed that he knew the fact.)
c. He seems to be working hard at math.
(= It seems that he is working hard at math. Progressive form shows simultaneous
action with that of seems.)
d. I’m pleased to meet you. (The pleasure and the meeting are both in the present.)
e. He was lucky to win $1,000 in a slot machine. (The luck and winnings are both in the
past.)
f. That farm was reported to be producing more fish than the previous year.
(= It was reported that the farm was producing more fish than the previous year.)
g. The country is known to be rich in natural resources.
(= It is known (to all) that the country is rich in natural resources.)
h. He seems to have done a great deal of work.
(A perfect form shows prior action to that of seems. Also see the examples in B)
below.)
i. He happens/appears/seems to have been knocked down by a car.
Cf. He happens/appears/seems that he has been/was knocked down by a car.
j. He happens/appears/seems to be sleeping.
Cf. He happens/appears/seems that he is sleeping.
B Besides some examples in A, if the action expressed by the infinitive is of earlier time than
that expressed by the main/principal verb, the perfect infinitive is usually used. That is, we
use a perfect infinitive for something prior to the time in the main verb, e.g.
a. He is said to have gone to Las Vegas. (= It is said that he has gone to Las Vegas.)
b. The enemy was reported to have been surrounded three days before.
(= It was reported that the enemy had been surrendered three days before.)
c. Sandy is known to have been teaching in the school for the past ten years.
(= It is known (to all) that Sandy has been teaching in the school for the past ten
years.)
d. I am sorry to have kept you waiting. (= I am sorry that I’ve kept you waiting.)
e. I prefer to have finished the work before she comes.
f. John seems to have seen Mary.
g. I’m glad to have met you. (The feeling is in the present, but meeting you is in the
past.)
h. It’s a pity that I missed the movie; I‘d like to have seen it.
(“To have seen it” has the meaning of subjunctive mood.)
i. The lady appeared to have been drinking.
4
Generally speaking, the perfect form and perfect progressive form refer to prior action or state,
and the progressive form to simultaneous action or state in comparison with the predicative verb
or predicate verb. The simple form of the infinitive has also time reference. It usually expresses
simultaneous action or state in place of the progressive form, if the verb itself cannot normally
have the progressive tense (see a in 3).
D Like the finite verb, the non-finite verb can be put into a passive voice, if the meaning so
required, as in
a. I don’t like to be fooled by flattery.
Cf. I don’t like people to fool me by flattery.
b. Here are three patients to be operated on immediately.
c. It is necessary for the patient to be operated on immediately.
Cf. It is necessary (for us) to operate on the patient immediately.
d. Most men die to be forgotten by posterity.
If the subject or the understood subject of the sentence is also the logical object of the non-finite
verb, then passive infinitive is used as seen above (e.g. I don’t like to be fooled by flattery). More
details are also described of the tenses and voice for the non-finite in each following section.
5
4
The infinitive used as subject
When the infinitive or the infinitive phrase is used as subject, its function is like that of a noun,
as in
Note that in modern English, we move the real subject and use the anticipatory it (some people
call it empty subject or introductory it) to represent the real subject. Thus, we can say “It is a
pity/fatal to hesitate.”
More examples:
As examples shown from g to j in A above, we use the construction for + logical subject + to do
when the logical subject of the infinitive is not the subject of the sentence (also see 21), as in
6
a. For us to be invited to attend the conference is a great honor.
b. =It is a great honor for us to be invited to attend the conference next week.
Cf. It is a great honor for them to invite us to attend the conference.
In such a case, if the construction, for + logical subject + to do, is long, we usually place it after
the empty subject it as we can see Sentence b above. For us to be invited to attend the
conference next week is longer than it is a great honor.
2. When the action in the infinitive happens before that of predicative or predicate, a
perfect infinitive (active or passive) is used, depending on its implication, as in
a. To have completed (=That we had completed) all work on time was a triumph to us.
b. To have been killed (=That she was killed) in a car accident is a great loss to her
family.
3. A passive voice is used when the logical subject of the infinitive is also the object of the
infinitive, as in
a. It is a good idea for John to be allowed to use a calculator for the math test.
(= It is a good idea for the teacher to allow John to use a calculator for the math
test.)
In the above sentence, John is the logical subject of the infinitive, to be allowed, but it is also the
logical object of the infinitive, to allow John.
More examples:
7
b. It might be a bad idea for the beautiful picture to be deleted.
(= It might be a bad idea for us to delete the beautiful picture.)
5
Linking verbs + adjective + infinitive used as predicative
In construction of A, the subject, John, of the linking verb, is, is also the logical subject of the
non-finite to wait. In such a case, the empty subject, it, can be used with this construction, of the
logical subject to do, as in
The adjectives of this kind are: brave, careless, clever, foolish, generous, good (= kind),
helpful, honest, intelligent, kind, mean, nice, polite, rude, sensible, silly, stupid, wrong, etc.
Also see B in 21.
B He is hard to convince.
In the construction of B, the subject, he, of the linking verb, is, is the object of the infinitive to
convince. The adjective is here mainly predicating the information from the infinitive. In this
construction, we can use the infinitive as a subject of the sentence or use empty subject it,
as in
8
a. He is hard to convince.
Cf. To convince him is hard. It is hard to convince him.
b. He is difficult to astonish.
Cf. To astonish him is difficult. It is difficult to astonish him.
c. She is easy to deceive.
Cf. To deceive her is easy. It is easy to deceive her.
d. He is convenient to send.
Cf. To send him is convenient. It is convenient to send him.)
e. The house was difficult to find.
Cf. To find the house was difficult. It was difficult to find the house.
If the adjective has an adverb form with the suffix -ly (i.e. easy – easily), a passive construction
is possible since the subject of the main clause is also the logical object of the infinitive, as in
Moreover, since the subject is the logical object of the infinitive, we cannot add another object to
the infinitive; therefore, we do not say *He is easy to convenience Lucy. Adjectives of this kind
are: amusing, awful, cheap, convenient, dangerous, difficult, easy, expensive, extraordinary,
funny, hard, horrible, important, impossible, improper, marvelous, inconvenient, interesting,
nasty, nice, pleasant, safe, splendid, strange, unimportant, useful, etc.
If the infinitive is intransitive verb, a preposition should be in its normal place (also see 3. in 12
below), as in
i. Sandy is pleasant to talk to. (Sandy is the logical object of the proposition, to.)
j. This river is dangerous to bathe in.
k. Good conversation is interesting to listen to.
l. This is a very good pen to write with.
m. She is easy to get along with.
Cf. It’s easy to get along with her. How easy it is to get along with her!
Adjectives that have antonyms (e.g. easy/difficult) occur in this construction, but this is not
always the case. That man is impossible to work with is acceptable, but *That man is possible
9
to work with is not acceptable (Hornby 1975). However, we can say, it’s possible to work with
that man. Let’s consider the following sentences:
When our team is used as the logical object of the infinitive to win or to lose, we don’t use them
as the subject in such a case. We do not say *Our team is possible to defeat. *To win/lose our
team is (im)possible. *It is (im)possible to win/lose our team (R.A. Close 1976). However, we
can say: Our team cannot win/lose/be defeated.
In this construction, we can also use the infinitive to postmodify an adjective phrase, as in
We can use feel, seem, etc., as a linking verb besides the linking verb be, as in
10
Willing/unwilling: afraid, anxious, determined, eager, keen, impatient, prepared, ready,
reluctant, unwilling, welcome, willing, etc. Personal qualities: mean, clever, sensible, right,
silly, lucky, fortune, etc.
Participles of this kind are: ashamed, amazed, amused, annoyed, astonished, cheered,
confused, delighted, determined, disappointed, dissatisfied, disinclined, disposed,
disturbed, excited, flattered, gratified, grieved, honored, horrified, hurt, inclined, induced,
infuriated, insulted, interested, moved, offended, pleased, prepared, provoked, relieved,
satisfied, shocked, surprised, thrilled, vexed, worried, wounded, etc.
They can be also premodified by adverbs such as very, rather, quite, etc.
More examples of this construction:
In this construction when the subject of the infinitive is different from the subject of the main
verb (the finite verb), we use for + logical subject + to do construction, as in
D There are a small number of adjectives expressing speaker’s opinion to make statement or ask
questions - an indication of the speaker’s attitude towards the future, not the indication from
the subject of the sentence. These adjectives are certain, likely, sure, etc., as in
11
(It is the speaker’s attitude rather than Mr. Marlowe, who is sure.)
q. Our team is (un)likely to win.
r. We are sure to need help.
s. Sandy is certain to come.
(Im)probable is not followed by to-infinitive, but it is used with empty subject it or that-clause,
as in
E He is slow to react.
In the construction of E, the subject of the linking verb, is, is also the subject of the infinitive;
its function is the same as A. We can convert the adjective adverbially, as in
Adjectives of this kid are hesitant, quick, reluctant, prompt, slow, willing, etc.
In the construction of F, it has attitudinal expression. The infinitive expresses reason to the rest
of the sentence (also see C in 14), as in
12
(= To hear about it bored me/infuriated me. It bored me /infuriated me to hear about
it.)
b. I was indignant to hear about it.
(= It made me bored/furious/indignant to hear about it.)
If an adjective like indignant above has no corresponding verb, we can use make as paraphrase
(Quirk 1972). Adjectives of this kind are: angry, content, furious, glad, happy, impatient,
indignant, jubilant, etc., and participles of this kind are: annoyed, astonished, bored,
concerned, delighted, depressed, disappointed, disgusted, (dis)satisfied, embarrassed, excited,
fascinated, overwhelmed, perturbed, puzzled, surprised, worried, etc.
In this construction the anticipatory it or empty subject it represents the real subject – the
infinitive phrase – in the sentence. Adjectives used in this construction are: advisable,
amusing, awful, bad, better, best, careless, cheap, clever, common, confusing, convenient,
dangerous, depressing, dreadful, difficult, easy, embarrassing, essential, exciting, expensive,
foolish, generous, good, great, hard, helpful, horrible, important, impossible, incredible,
intelligent, interesting, kind, lovely, marvelous, mean, natural, necessary, nice, normal, odd,
perfect, pleasant, polite, possible, right, rude, safe, sensible, silly, stupid, terrible, vital, rare,
strange, terrific, understandable, usual, wonderful, wrong, etc. Also see K below.
13
1. Too … to do … construction
a. He was too weak to climb the wall. (after the adjective, weak)
b. The river is too cold to swim in. (after the adjective, cold)
c. The problem is too difficult/impossible to solve.(after the adjectives
difficult/impossible)
d. The bridge was too narrow to cross. (after the adjective, narrow)
e. I came too late to prevent him from going there. (after the adverb, late)
f. It moves too quickly for most people to see (it). (after the adverb, quickly. Quirk, et al
1972)
g. She is too nice a girl to refuse.
h. The weather in Las Vegas is too hot for anyone to eat outside.
Note that the subjects of some sentences above are also the logical objects of the infinitive: to
swim in the river (in b.), to solve the problem (in c.), to cross the bridge (in d.), etc. When the
logical subject is not the subject of the sentence, for + logical subject is used after too …to do
construction, as in
i. The bridge was too narrow for the truck to cross. (after the adjective, narrow)
When too + adjective is used, the following noun is usually a singular countable noun. It cannot
be a noun in a plural form or an uncountable noun. Thus, we do not say:
j. *They are too nice girls to refuse. (Girls is a noun in a plural form.)
k. *It is too good food to throw away. (Food is an uncountable noun. Quirk, et al 1972)
But we can say It’s food (which is) too good to throw away.
a. The bridge was not wide enough for the truck to cross. (after the adjective, wide)
b. They were driving fast enough to attract attention. (Fast is an adverb.)
c. He was not strong enough to lift the weight. (after the adjective, strong)
d. We have enough money to last.
e. I am fool enough to believe her. (Fool is a noun.)
(*I am a fool enough to believe her. Fool is a noun.)
f. Are you man enough to do this dangerous job?
(*Are you a man enough to do this …?)
g. He was gentleman enough to help her.
(*He was a gentleman enough to help her.)
h. She was scholar enough to read the inscription.
(*She was a scholar enough to read ….)
14
When enough is used to postmodify a countable noun in this construction, the indefinite article,
a or an is not used as seen from the last four sentences (from e to h) above, but when the
infinitive is not used, the indefinite article can be used, therefore, the following sentences are
normal, as in
J Voice
After an adjective phrase in this construction above, the active voice in the infinitive is usually
used rather than a passive, as in
K It used with verbs such as appear, feel, happen, prove, seem, sound, turn out,
etc.
The verbs above are linking verbs. Their subjects are usually introduced by anticipatory it (also
see G above), as in
a. It seems a pity to waste so much money.
b. It sounds reasonable to do it this way.
c. It appears unlikely for us to win the game
Besides these verbs above, we also have some intransitive verbs such as suffice, do, and remain,
etc., the subjects of which are also it, as in
d. It will suffice to get a few more people.
e. It won’t do for a student to cheat in his test.
f. It remains to choose a partner and to fix the date.
g. It does no good to say anything.
h. It didn’t occur to me to do that sort of thing.
The infinitive of these verbs above is not used as an object, because these verbs are intransitive
verbs. They can be followed by a that-clause, e.g.
15
i. It happened that we met at the bar. (Cf. We happened to meet at the bar.)
j. It seems that her iPhone has been stolen/lost. (Cf. Her iPhone seems to have been
stolen/lost.)
And the verbs relating to the expression of mood or feeling are also used this way. They are:
amuse, annoy, delight, cost, irk, irritate, make, need, require, take, etc., as in
k. It delighted me to have met you.
l. It irritated her to be forced to do it all over again.
m. It made Mr. Marlowe excited. (= It excited Mr. Marlowe) to have his greenhouse
rebuilt.)
n. It took us a few hours to complete the experiment in Sandy’s lab.
L Wh-words followed by infinitive used as predicative
Sometimes, some of the wh-words followed by infinitive can be used as predicative or subject
complement (also see A in 6), as in
a. My question is where to start the project.
b. The problem is which to do next.
c. Who to turn to is what Mr. Marlowe wants to know.
Cf. What Mr. Marlowe wants to know is who to turn to.
The infinitive is used in predicative introduced by how and what in it + be construction, but
the it + be is usually omitted (Hornby 1976), as in
6
Infinitive used in predicative
In addition to what is described in 5, we continue to discuss the use of the infinitive in SVC
construction. The subject of the sentence can usually be a noun, a noun phrase, a noun clause, or
an infinitive.
16
A Nouns used as subject and an infinitive used as predicative
a. The first step is to remove the lid to let the water out. (The first step is a noun
phrase. To remove the lid … is used as predicative.)
b. My task today is to help you. (My task today is a noun phrase.)
c. My aim was to help you. (My aim is a noun phrase.)
d. His greatest pleasure is to sit in the casino, playing games. (His greatest pleasure is a
noun phrase.)
e. The most important thing is not to waste money.
(The most important thing is a noun phrase.)
f. Her plan is to make better use of these medicinal herbs. (Her plan is a noun phrase.)
g. My goal is to complete the work on time.
h. Your mistake was to write her that nasty letter.
i. The point is what to do it.
j. The issue is which one to give the reward to.
k. The question is when to call the principal.
In such a case, the subject usually contains such nouns as aim, ambition, duty, hope, idea,
intention, mistake, plan, purpose, suggestions, etc. The wh-words followed by the infinitive
are also used as predicative as described from h to k above.
B A noun clause or wh-words (who, what, which, where, when, how, etc.)
used as subject and an infinitive used in predicative
Usually an infective used as predicative after the subject introduced by a noun clause consisting
of superlative words such as the best, the worst, or all (that), the only, wh-words, etc., as in
a. What I want is to get to the airport as early as possible. (What I want is a noun
clause. To get to the airport … is used as predicative or subject complement.)
b. What I really wanted to do was drive all night. (bare infinitive used in predicative)
c. All I did was empty the bottle. (bare infinitive)
d. The worse you can do is become very drowsy. (bare infinitive used in predicative)
e. The best way to do was wait until the result came out. (bare infinitive used in
predicative)
f. The only thing I can do now is go on by myself. (bare infinitive used in predicative)
g. What worries us most is where to find the man.
17
C Infinitive
a. To see is to believe. (To believe is used as predicative – SVC.)
b. To decide is to act. (To act is used as predicative – SVC.)
c. To be kind to the enemy is to be cruel to the people. (To be cruel to the people is used
a predicative – SVC.)
Besides the linking verb be, we use the verbs such as appear, seem, happen, as in
d. He seemed not to pay much attention to what I was saying. (SVC)
e. He seemed (to be) unable to get out of the habit. (SVC)
f. I can’t seem to solve this math problem.
(Cf. I seem (to be) unable to solve the math problem.)
g. He couldn’t seem to get out of the habit.
(Cf. He seemed (to be) unable to get out of the habit.
Note: When can’t or couldn’t is used with seem above, it negates the infinitive.
h. This appears (to be) an important matter.
i. He appears to have many friends.
j. She happened to be out when I called her.
k. She happened to be killed by shark.
7
Tense and voice in predicative
Generally speaking, the tense is usually a simple tense – subject + is/was + to do, and active
voice is used, too, as in
1. Passive
Sometimes we use passive in predicative when the subject of the sentence is also the logical
object of the infinitive, as in
18
When we use for + logical subject + to do construction, a passive is used as described above
because the logical subject is actually the logical object of the infinitive.
More examples:
d. Their suggestion was for the plan to be discussed by all the students.
Cf. Their suggestion was that the plan should be discussed by all the students.
e. One of the decisions taken at the meeting was for Spanish to be taught in all schools.
Note that the sentences below from f to i are used in active voice, but they have passive meaning,
as in
2. Progressive
3. Perfect
a. John was to have come back yesterday, but he was sick.
(To have come back yesterday has the meaning of subjunctive mood in the
construction of was/were to have done.)
b. His achievement is to have produced a new method of calculation.
Cf. His achievement is that he has produced a new method of calculation.
c. The socialists seem to have been elected.
Cf. It seems that the socialists have been elected.
Sometimes the perfect infinitive is also used to postmodify a noun or noun phrase, which
corresponds somewhat to a relative clause, as in
d. Mr. Marlowe was the last to have entered the greenhouse before it caught fire.
19
(= Mr. Marlowe was the last who had entered/entered the greenhouse before it
caught fire.)
8
The infinitive used as object
He began to work early in the morning every day. (SVO)
This is SVO construction – subject (He)+ verb (began) + object (to work …). In such a
construction, the subject of the sentence is also the logical subject of the infinitive. The following
verbs usually take an infinitive used as object: afford, agree, aim, apply, ask, can’t wait, choose,
claim, dare, decide, demand, desire, determine, endeavor, expect, come on (begin), guarantee,
hope, learn, long, manage, mean (intend), offer, pretend, promise, refuse, seek, swear,
threaten, train, undertake, want, wish, etc., e.g.
a. I agreed to use a school computer to do my assignment. (SVO)
(The logical subject of the infinitive to use is I.)
b. I expected to meet Ms. Roden. (SVO)
c. She means to do better. (SVO)
d. He wants to pay a visit to his friend in Las Vegas. (SVO)
e. She likes to get up early. (SVO)
f. What did Mr. R say she wanted to do? (SVO)
g. She pretended not to see me while she was walking by. (SVO)
We can also use the following verbs in SVOC construction: advise, allow, ask, beg, beseech,
bribe, cause, challenge, command, compel, dare (=challenge), direct, drive (= compel),
empower, enable, encourage, entice, entitle, entreat, expect, forbid, force, help, impel, implore,
incite, induce, instruct, intend, invite, know, lead, mean (= intend), oblige, order, permit,
persuade, predispose, press ( = urge), recommend, remind, request, require, teach, tell, tempt,
urge, warn, etc., in SVOC construction, as in
h. I expected Mr. Roser to meet you. (SVOC)
i. She told me not to go there alone. (SVOC)
Sometimes the infinitive is used as object and its function is tantamount to an object clause,
as in
j. I hope to be able to attend the meeting.
Cf. I hope that I will be able/I am able to attend the meeting.
k. I expect to have finished writing this chapter by next Friday.
Cf. I expect that I will have finished writing this chapter by next Friday.
l. He considers her to be very trustworthy.
Cf. He considers that she is very trustworthy.
20
m. I think it strange for her to meet him.
Cf. I think it strange that she’d/will meet him.
Also see The infinitive used as part of complex object or SVOC in 16 about “I think it a good
idea to go there”, where it represents the real object to go there (see SVOC in18).
9
Tense and voice in the infinitive used as object
In SVO construction, when the infinitive is used as object, the finite verb is usually not converted
into passive. Therefore, the following is incorrect:
It is not easy for us to convert an object from SVO or SVOC into a passive voice. However, we
can have a few verbs to convert them into passive when we use the empty subject it as subject of
the passive sentence. These verbs are decided, desired, hope, intend, plan, propose, suggest,
etc., as in
c. It was proposed to hold another meeting for that student.
d. It has been decided to enroll more students for our school next year.
A When the subject of the sentence is not the logical subject of the infinitive,
but the logical object of the infinitive, a passive voice is used
1. A perfect infinitive (of some verbs) is used to predict that the action in the infinitive will be
completed by a certain time in the (near) future, as in
2. A perfect infinitive (of some verbs) is used to indicate something that is unfulfilled, not
realized, or not carried out. These verbs are usually in reference to wish or intention. They
are: expect, hope, intend, mean, suppose, want, wish, and should like, was/were to have
done, etc., as in
a. I should like to have called you the other day, but I forgot.
b. She intended to have told me about what had happened to her last week.
c. Mr. Marlowe expected to have reached the top of the mountain by noon, but the bad
weather stopped him.
d. I meant to have told you what was going on last night, but I decided not to.
e. I thought it wrong to have helped her. (the hypothetical)
f. I wanted to have seen you ever so much, but I did not like to bother you.
g. I expected the door to have opened, but it did not. It remained shut.
h. We were to have been married in Las Vegas last year, but we didn’t get married.
i. He was to have repaired the computer yesterday, but he didn’t.
Generally speaking, the above examples have the meaning of subjunctive mood. Moreover, we
can use a perfect tense in the main clause rather than the perfect infinitive, with no practical
difference in meaning, as in
j. She had intended to tell me about what had happened to her last week.
Cf. She intended to have told me about what had happened to her last week.
22
k. Mr. Marlowe had expected to reach the top of the mountain by noon, but the bad
weather stopped him.
Cf. Mr. Marlowe expected to have reached the top of the mountain by noon, but ….
Note that “Mr. Marlowe had expected to have reached the top of the mountain by noon, but the
bad weather stopped him” is also acceptable, but we have a definitely redundant sentence.
When the verb hope is used in the past perfect tense, it indicates the past hope was not realized,
as in
We had hoped that she would soon be well again. (Hornby 1975)
A progressive is used (in SVO and SVOC) to express or emphasize a certain action that was
happening then, is happening now, or will happen in the (near) future (also see 2. In 7), as in
a. He is believed to be coming.
Cf. It is believed that he is coming.
We believe that he is coming.
b. He seems to be enjoying himself.
Cf. It seems (that) he is enjoying himself.
c. I am glad to be meeting you.
Cf. I am glad that I am meeting you now.
d. I would like to be having lunch at home now.
e. You don’t need to be working in a great hurry now; we have plenty of time.
f. They didn’t expect the boys to be sitting quietly in the classroom.
(The boys were sitting quietly in the classroom.)
g. I believe you to be sending your email to your boss.
Cf. You are sending your email to your boss now.
h. I don’t want you to be working so hard like this. (You are working so hard now.)
i. I felt myself to be missing something.
j. They are said to be working diligently. They are working diligently.
Cf. It’s said that they are working diligently.
k. He is supposed to be looking for something he wants to use.
Cf. He is looking for something he wants to use.
23
D Passive
The infinitive postmodifier can be passive when the postmodified noun or noun phrase is also the
logical object of the infinitive. In such a case, the passive used can express tense and mood -
something that will/can/must/should happen or happens, as in
If a verb, especially an intransitive verb, is used as a non-finite attributive, its infinitive may
sometimes correspond to its present participle. Thus:
Attention should be paid to the fact that when the indirect object (a person) is also the logical
subject of the infinitive and the direct object (a thing) is also the logical object of the infinitive,
an active voice is usually used, as in
Because the action of to read is me, and me is the logical subject of the infinitive, to read,
although a book is the logical object of to read, therefore, an active voice is usually used in the
infinitive clause, especially for these verbs: buy, get, lend, etc. More examples:
k. She bought her daughter a Laptop to use during the conference. (NOT to be used)
24
l. Please get me a cup of water to drink. (NOT to be drunk)
10
Wh-words + to do and there + be constructions
The infinitive preceded by wh-words can be used as an object. These wh-words are: who, whom,
which, what, where, when, how, whether (but not if or why) to form a noun phrase. The
following verbs can be used with wh-words. They are: advise, ask, choose, consider, decide,
discover, discuss, explain, find out, forget, guess, hear, imagine, inquire, know, learn, observe,
perceive, remember, see, settle, show, teach, tell, think (= consider), understand, wonder (= to
be curious to know), etc. The phrase is virtually a construction of an indirect question. The
logical subject of the infinitive is also the subject of the sentences, as in
When subject + verb + indirect object + direct object (SVOi Od) is used, the logical subject of
the infinitive is also the object of the main verb. Here the direct object is formed by wh-words to
do construction, as in
i. Please advise me which to buy. (SVOiOd, me is the indirect object, which is also the
logical subject of to buy, and which to buy the direct object.))
Cf. Please advise me which one I’ll buy.
j. Tell her what to do next. (SVOiOd)
Cf. Tell her what she will do next.
k. Show me how to solve the math problem.
Cf. Show me how I’ll/can solve the math problem.
l. Please show me how to do it
25
Cf. Show me how I will/should do it.
m. Can you tell me which way to go?
Cf. Can you tell me where I should go?
In the last two sentences above, me is the object of the main verb, show and tell, respectively, but
the logical subject of the following infinitives is also me. After what, which, whose, how many,
and how much, a noun or noun phrase can be followed, as in
1. The wh-words + the infinitive construction can also be used as object after a preposition,
as in
a. The rule permits there to be no more than hundred people in the conference room.
b. We understood there to be money available.
c. You wouldn’t want there to be another war.
d. I don’t want there to be any trouble.
e. He meant there to be no indiscipline.
f. Would you like there to be another meeting to reevaluate that project?
g. I expect there to be no argument about the matter.
h. I should prefer there to be another meeting for this issue.
i. We’d prefer there to be at least three adults in charge on the field trip.
11
The infinitive used as object of a preposition
26
Suffice it to say that only the gerund or a noun should be used as the object of a preposition, that
is, a gerund can be used as an object of a preposition, but a few prepositions can be followed by
an infinitive or a bare infinitive. These prepositions are: except, but, than, rather than, about,
save, besides, etc., as in
12
The infinitive used as attributive (postmodifier or premodifier)
A Postmodifier
A postmodifier is a modifier that follows the noun or the noun phrase. The infinitive used as
postmodifier is also (in most of the cases) comparable with a relative clause in function, but the
infinitive does not show time reference except, perhaps, in the case of the passive infinitive,
which nearly always has a future reference.
27
Cf. The next ship which arrived was the Elizabeth.
b. Mr. Roser was always the first to come but the last to leave.
Cf. Mr. Roser was always the first who came but the last who left.
c. An expert will be the best man to consult.
Cf. An expert will be the best man you should consult.
d. He is not a man to bow before difficulties.
Cf. He is not a man who bows before difficulties.
e. We need someone to help us repair the machine.
Cf. We need someone who can help us repair the machine.
3. When a noun or a noun phrase is the logical object of the preposition, the preposition
comes in its normal place, e.g.
a. There’s nothing to get excited about. (Nothing is the logical object of about.)
b. I have nothing really to complain about. (Nothing is the logical object of about.)
c. She has five children to look after. (Five children is the logical object of after.)
d. Ms. R is looking for a room to live in. (A room is the logical object of in.)
Cf. Ms. R is looking for a room where she can live.
e. He gave me a quarter to call you with.
Cf. He gave me a quarter with which I can call you.
f. I’m looking for something to clean the carpet with.
Cf. I’m looking for something with which I can clean the carpet.
g. I use a pen to write with.
h. I’ve bought this chair to sit in.
Cf. I’ve bought this chair where/in which I can sit.
i. He is not a man to trifle with.
j. She has given me much to think about.
But in formal English, we usually use an infinitive clause with a preposition in front, as in
28
Cf. I need a can in which to put some paint.
l. Ms. R is looking for a room to live in
Cf. Ms. R is looking for a room in which to live or where she can live.
m. He gave me a quarter to call you with.
Cf. He gave me a quarter with which to call you.
n. Ms. Roden had no time left in which to pack her things.
o. It was a bad season in which to have outings.
p. After the harvest, the farmers select their best produce with which to pay their tax
to the state.
When the noun is in reference to time, place, way, etc., the preposition can be omitted, as in
q. He is looking for a place to live. (in being omitted after live, especially in AmE)
Cf. He is looking for a place where he can live.
He is looking for a place to live in.
r. Some people say the best way to travel is on foot.
Cf. Some people say the best way they can travel is on foot.)
For the above construction, we usually have the following words such as: ability, agreement,
anxiety, aptitude, attempt, ambition, campaign, chance, claim, courage, curiosity, decision,
desire, determination, eagerness, efforts, evidence, failure, fight, hope, impatience, intention,
means, measures, movement, need, patience, plan, power, promise, opportunity, position,
29
refusal, reluctance, reason, resolution, right, skill, strength, struggle, tendency, threat,
willingness, wish, etc.
B Premodifier
Instead of a negative word used with passive voice used in it, sometimes we use other words, a
noun, an adverb, an adjective, or a bare infinitive, etc. Such combination, a hyphen usually used,
is regarded as an adjective or noun phrase. Some of them already become idiomatic expressions,
as in
30
The mom-to-be was screaming in the passenger seat when Jean-
Louis stopped his car. --- https://www.yahoo.com/news/florida-deputy-pulled-over-
driver-131659207.html
13
The infinitive used as appositive
The infinitive with to (some people called it the infinitive clause) is used as apposition to the
noun or noun phrase and gives the further explanation of the meaning of the noun or noun
phrase. In such a case, a hyphen, or sometimes comma, is used for the non-restrictive infinitive
clause, as in
This is not always the same case, sometimes we have restrictive apposition and the appositive
would correspond to the finite clause introduced by a that-clause, as in
Besides, the infinitive clause is used after a word (usually a pronoun or numeral), as in
g. We also had quite a number of visitors, some to see us off, some to fetch things, and
some to do both. (Each infinitive clause is preceded with some.)
h. She has written two articles for the journal, one to be published in this issue, the
other to come out in the next.
14
The Infinitive used as adverbial
An adverbial of purpose and result is usually indistinguishable, so they are treated together.
An adverbial of purpose can, however, usually be expanded into in order to or so as to phrase.
31
A Purpose
The infinitive can be used to express purpose or result. In order to avoid ambiguity, in order to
or so as to is used when the infinitive expresses purpose. For example, he came into the room in
order to disturb me. Without using “in order to”, the meaning of the sentence is confusing.
When we say, “He came into the room to disturb me”, the sentence can express either purpose
or result.
It is noted that when the infinitive is used to express purpose, the whole infinitive clause can be
transposed or moved to the initial position (like b. and f. above) for the purpose of emphasis,
although sometimes rather unnaturally:
In informal English, we use and rather than to in the cases of come/go to do construction, the
and functions as purpose, too. Also see E in 29.
w. Go and get some water for me. (= Go (to) get some ….)
x. “Come and see me when you come back,” he said.
y. Come dance with us! (and is omitted, especially in AmE.)
When the go or come is in past tense, the verb after and does not express purpose, but expresses
result, e.g. We went and met him at the airport.
B Result
When the infinitive is used to express result, the infinitive clause is usually placed after the main
clause. Besides the infinitive itself, we usually have so (…) as to…, such (…) as to …, enough
to …, too …to…, and (only) to constructions used to express result, as in
a. I ran all the way to find that he had gone. (F.R. Palmer 1978)
b. Ms. R went abroad never to return. (The infinitive expresses result.)
c. He must be deaf not to hear that. (result)
d. That night there was a storm and I woke to hear the rain lashing the window panes.
e. He lived to be ninety. (result)
f. The miserable old days have gone never to return. (result)
g. She grew up to be a pretty young lady. (result)
i. The peasants worked hard (so as) to live. (result)
j. I shall go on working late today so as to be free tomorrow. (purpose and result)
k. Would you be so kind as to lend me your pen? (result)
l. Her unknown illness is such as to cause great anxiety.
m. I was such a fool as to believe what she told me.
n. He is old enough to know how to handle the issue. (Also see I in 5.)
o. The wood is strong enough to carry the weight.
33
p. He is too young to know anything.
q. It was too late for us to attend the meeting. (Also see I in 5.)
When we express “an unhappy thing” after the main verb, (only) to do is used. Again see the
following examples:
Therefore, “iPhone stolen” is bad news, and so is only to find her mother dying in a hospital,
etc. It is noted that in too…to… construction, it has negative meaning for the infinitive, e.g. The
rock is too heavy for me to lift, which means the rock is very heavy and I am unable to lift it.
This is not always the case. The too … to … construction can be also used without negating the
infinitive, as in
C Reason/cause
When the infinitive is used to express reason or cause, it looks the same as the expression of
purpose. It depends on their implication or meaning from context. For example, She wept to hear
the news (to hear the news expressing reason) and She wept to obtain sympathy (to obtain
sympathy expressing purpose), as in
34
Besides, with/without + noun + infinitive phrase can be used to express reason, as in,
g. With only five minutes to go, they were in a great hurry to complete the work.
h. With nobody to help the boy, he finished the work late.
i. Without anyone to call her, she might be late for the performance.
D The infinitive to used after some conjunctions (i.e. as if, as though, etc.)
The infinitive is used adverbially after as if, as though, etc., to express something true or untrue
and may have the meaning of subjunctive mood, as in
F Condition
Sometimes the infinitive can be used to express condition. In such a case, the infinitive is placed
before the main clause, as in
To hear him speak, you would think he owned the whole world.
(= If you should hear him speak, you would think he owned the whole world.)
15
The logical subject of the infinitive
The logical subject of the infinitive is usually the subject of the sentence. For example, I caught
the train to go to New York, in which the logical subject of to go New York is I, but sometimes
the logical subject of the following infinitive is not the subject of the main clause, instead, for +
logical subject + to do is used to express purpose to avoid confusion, as in
a. For plants to grow properly, Mr. Marlowe always waters them regularly.
b. Here’s the book for you to read.
c. It was a bad day for you to call her.
In order for us to avoid confusion with the uses of the infinitive, so as or in order is used before
the infinitive. Note the differences between the following sentences:
35
f. He left us, so as (= in order) to pay the bill. (He paid it) (SVA)
g. He left us to pay the bill. (We had to pay it) (SVOC)
Sometimes it is really hard to distinguish the difference between the purpose and the resul, both
introduced by an infinitive clause. Again, to avoid ambiguity, we can use in order to do or so as
to do for the expression of purpose.
16
The infinitive used as part of complex object or SVOC
The noun or noun phrase postmodified by the infinitive (or the adjective infinitive) is usually a
logical object of the infinitive or the receiver of the action. In such a case, the infinitive clause is
tantamount to a relative clause.
For example:
In the last three sentences above, to be, can be omitted when they are used in a passive voice. In
such a case, the past participles are still used as complement after the omission of to be.
In SVOC construction, we use it as anticipatory it (or empty it) to represent the infinitive which
is used as the object of the verb, as in
1. We think it our duty to study and work hard for our country.
36
(The infinitive phrase, to study and work hard for our country, is the real object of
the verb, think, and our duty is a noun phrase used as the complement. It is SVOC.)
2. I count it one of the sweetest privileges of my life to have known and conversed with
many men of genius.
(The perfect infinitive phrase, to have known and conversed with many men of
genius, is a real object of the verb, count, and the noun phrase, one of the sweetest
privileges of my life, is used as the complement. (It is SVOC.)
3. Do you think it proper to treat her so badly?
4. I think it prudent to wait and see.
5. We count it an honor to serve you. (An honor is a noun used as complement. It is
SVOC.)
6. I should consider it unwise to swop horses in mid-stream.
7. Do you consider it proper to treat him so badly?
8. She deemed it her duty to help her younger brother.
9. I find it difficult to explain the matter to her.
10. I’ll make it my business to help her.
11. I count it a great honor to serve the people wholeheartedly.
12. We don’t think fit to adopt his suggestion.
13. You know the situation best. Do whatever you see fit.
14. I consider it a favor for you to call on me on that account.
15. It is considered unwise to cheat in a test. (Also see passive in D below)
Note that Think fit and see fit (to do something) are fixed phrases, in which the anticipatory it is
always omitted before fit as seen in Sentences 12 and 13 above.
We can use the anticipatory it to represent the infinitive used as object in some phrasal verbs
made of preposition or prepositional phrase. They are: take …in turn, have …in mind, leave …
to, owe … to, take … upon oneself, etc., as in
37
We treat some phrasal verbs as if they are transitive verbs. We can use an infinitive after them as
object. These phrasal verbs are: arrange for, ask for, beckon to, call on, call upon, care for,
count on, depend on, depend upon, long for, motion to, prepare for, provide for, prevail on,
rely on, vote for, wait for, wave to, and wish for, etc., as in
We can convert the sentence into passive with the anticipatory it, as in
17
Have and there + be constructions
We often use have or there + be followed by an infinitive, as in
a. She has three children to look after. (Three children is the logical object of the
infinitive to look after.)
b. He has cakes to eat. (Cake is also the logical object of the infinitive to eat.)
c. I have a whole family to support.
d. I will have the house to paint as I have got a letter from HOA (home of association).
e. He has no money to spend.
f. There are three children to take care of.
g. There is no money to spend.
h. I want a book to read.
i. I have a lot of things to do.
38
Obviously, I have cakes to eat is idiomatic, but I have cakes to be eaten is unidiomatic
substitution for I have cakes to eat. However, I have cakes to be eaten usually means I have some
cakes to be eaten by others, i.e. for others to eat. We sometimes use an active infinitive to talk
about jobs we have to do as the examples seen above, so we do not use a passive voice. When
the subject of the main verb is also the logical object of the infinitive, normally a passive voice is
used, but in there +be construction, either active or passive is used, as in
j. These windows have to be painted. (These windows are the logical object of paint.)
k. There is a lot of work to do/to be done this weekend.
Cf. There is a lot of work for us to do this weekend.
l. There are a lot of windows to paint/be painted.
m. There is a lot to be said (or to say) about this book.
Again, we do not usually use a passive voice in there + be construction when it is referred to as
leisure activities, as in
In addition, when the active voice is used in there + be construction, it implies duty, necessity,
and the like while the passive implies possibility (Schibsbye 1970), as in
18
Used as object complement
In SVOC construction, the object (O) is the agent of the action and the infinitive is used as
complement (C). That is, the object (O) is also the logical subject of the infinitive, as in
39
I told her to come. (I is the subject; told is the finite verb; her is the object and to come is
` the infinitive used as object complement. It is SVOC.)
Verbs used like tell above in SVOC construction (some people also called complex object in
SVOC construction) are: believe, consider, declare, discover, feel (= think), find (=consider),
help, imagine, judge, know, prove, suppose, think, understand, etc.
More examples:
In the last seven sentences, the to be can be omitted after the verbs of consider, declare, find,
prove, think, etc. In such a case, after the omission of to be, the adjective is still the complement
of the object (SVOC). But when the infinitive is perfect, it is usually not permissible for such
omission, as in
40
19
A noun or noun phrase postmodified by infinitive
When an infinitive is used to postmodify a noun or a noun phrase, sometimes the infinitive can
replace a relative clause (also see A in 12), as in
When a noun or noun phrase postmodified by the infinitive is also the logical object of the
infinitive, the passive voice is usually used, as in
41
20
The infinitive used as independent element
The infinitive can be used as independent elements (disjunctive adverbials) of the sentence. They
are also called dangling or dangling infinitive phrases (Randall 1988). Such a dangling
infinitive is used to modify the whole sentence (the main statement). The phrase is more or less
stereotyped, though with a very few of them. They are enumerated in sentences as follows:
a. To speak bluntly, the newly born baby is covered with fur all over his body.
b. To cut a long story short, I think you are wrong.
c. To use a shipping term, the ship is down by the head.
d. The baby is rather like an animal, so to speak.
e. He has a lot of children, nine, to be exact.
f. To be (quite) honest with you, you should end the bad relationship with her.
g. To tell (you) the truth, they didn’t quite like the idea.
h. To be sure, he showed laziness in his work.
i. To begin with, you started the quarrel.
j. To tell you the truth, I don’t want to marry you.
k. To be fair, she is a difficult lady to deal with.
l. To speak frankly, you have hurt her feelings.
m. Strange to say, we met in Las Vegas.
n. To put it frankly, you have hurt her feelings.
o. To be frank, you don’t make a good progress.
p. I’m a bit tired of visiting Las Vegas, to tell you the truth.
Besides dangling participle, the dangling can occur with the infinitive and the gerund as well.
Roughly speaking, the agent of the infinitive should be expressed if it is different for the subject
of the sentence but omitted if it is the same. To omit it where it is necessary is inadvertence; to
insert it where it is unnecessary will be redundancy (Huang 1979). The following examples show
indiscriminate omission leading to dangling construction:
In order to bring her back to normal, she underwent a full course of insulin treatment.
(Say they let her undergo or they subjected her to instead of she underwent, so as to
supply the infinitive with the proper agent.)
To cut costs, lamb chops will no longer be trimmed in most butcher shops.
(Say to cut costs, most butcher shops will no longer trim lamb chops or Because most
butcher shops must cut costs, they will no longer trim lamb chops.)
Like the dangling participle, some kind of dangling constructions in the case of the infinitive has
been accepted by usage, too. This will be the case where the subject of a sentence is inanimate
42
and the main verb passive, and no ambiguity, therefore, can be involved by the omission of the
personal but indefinite agent of an active infinitive. The dangling is legitimate again, e.g.
21
For + noun (or pronoun in objective case) + infinitive
A The preposition for is used to introduce a construction in which a noun (or pronoun in
objective case) has an infinitive attached to it. The noun or pronoun is the logical subject of
the infinitive, e.g.
Verbs with for and an infinitive include apply, arrange, ask, call, long, plan, pray, prepare,
provide, ring, send, telephone, vote, wait, etc.
B Care must be taken to distinguish the following from the above-mentioned construction for +
logical subject + to do :
We cannot place the prepositional phrase at the beginning of the sentence used as a subject,
therefore we do not say, *Of you to help me is very kind. Here the prepositional phrase of you
goes rather with kind than with the infinitive that follows, though in meaning you is still that
43
logical subject of the infinitive. In such a construction, adjective of + logical subject, these
adjectives include: absurd, artful, awful, brave, careless, clever, clumsy, considerate, crazy,
cruel, cunning, dishonest, extravagant, foolish, generous, good (= kind), greedy, helpful,
honest, horrible, idiotic, impudent, inconsiderate, intelligent, kind, lazy, mean, modest, nasty,
nice, polite, reasonable, rude, selfish, sensible, silly, stupid, thoughtful, unselfish, wicked,
wise, wrong, etc.
More examples:
When in the exclamatory sentence, it is or it was can be omitted, e.g. How foolish of Mr. Smith
to meet her again! (= How foolish of Mr. Smith (it is) to meet her again!) We can omit of
+logical subject in It was silly to make such a mistake. (cf. It was silly of you to make such a
mistake.) In this construction, the adjectives are used to express personal qualities as shown
above, but when we say It was nice for Sandy to take the dog for a walk, it was a pleasant
experience for Sandy. Sometimes that is used besides it in such a construction as seen from g
and h above.
22
After all auxiliary and modal verbs except ought
44
23
After the object of the verbs expressing physical
perception/sensation (see, hear, feel, observe, notice, watch, listen to,
look at, etc.)
For example:
When the object of the sentence above becomes passive, the infinitive sign to is usually used,
e.g. He was seen to get in the house.
24
After the object of the causative verbs (let, make, have, etc.)
The non-finite form of the object complement to the verb have is rather complicated. They are
demonstrated below:
A When shall / will have means want, wish or like, or they are in negation, a bare infinitive is
usually used, as in :
B When have means get or make, which is usually American usage, we take a bare
infinitive:
C Have meaning wish, arrange, experience or cause takes either a bare infinitive or a present
participle according to implication:
D Let, make
25
Bid, dare, know, etc.
a. The knight bade the traveler enter. (Bid occurs in old-fashioned narrative English.)
b. He bade me (to) come in.
c. Does anyone dare (to) call me a liar?
d. Would anyone dare predict when this dictatorship will end?
e. You’ll never find him (to) neglect his work. (Schibsbye 1970)
46
(To is optional in negative, but when the verb be is used, to be should kept: I found
her to be dishonest or I found her dishonest.)
As is known to all, dare is both an auxiliary verb and a lexical (or regular) verb. When dare is
used as a lexical verb, the infinitive sign, to, is either used or not used. Generally speaking, the
omission of to happens when dare is used in either a question (frequently used after how) or a
negative sentence or sentence with negative meaning, as in
Note that know is usually followed by a bare infinitive when it is perfect tense or in negation or
in a question, but when the infinitive to be is used, we retain to be after the verb know, or to do is
retained when know is converted it into passive, as in
26
In some idiomatic expressions
47
The bare infinitive is also used in: had better (‘d better or better), had best (‘d best), would (or
had) rather, etc.
Note that had better can be followed by progressive infinitive, but cannot be negated; the
negation of which occurs in the infinitive and had better indicates the speaker or hearer
(showing strong recommendation) regards as desirable, as in
27
Would (or had) rather, would sooner, rather than
It is noted that in terms of discourse and subject orientation, would rather indicates the subject
orientation, as in
48
e. I’d rather be lying on the beach than stuck in a traffic jam.
f. I’d rather not go.
g. I’d rather not sit at the back.
h. I’d rather (= sooner) go now. (It means “I’d prefer to go now.”)
i. Would you rather/sooner stay here? (Rarely used in a question.)
j. I had rather die than betray her.
As seen above, sometimes perfect or progressive forms are used in these constructions. The
omission of the infinitive sign, to, also happens in rather than when it means would rather not,
as in
k. I decided to write rather than telephone.
l. He resigned rather than take part in such a dishonest transaction.
m. Rather than travel by air, I’d prefer a week on a big liner.
n. He suffered death rather than betray the secret. (F.T. Wood 1993)
o. Rather than allow the vegetables to go bad, he sold them at half price.
28
May (just) as well, might (just) as well
May (just) as well (spoken) is used to say that you will do something that you do not really want
to do, because you cannot think of anything better. Might (just) as well (usually spoken) is used
to suggest doing something that you do not really want to do, because you have no better idea.
For example:
His appearance changed so much that you may well not recognize him. (NOT may not)
We might (just) as well not have a car at all.
I may as well go out tonight. There’s nothing on television.
If you’re not going to eat that pizza, I may as well throw it out.
It’s no good waiting for the bus. We might as well walk.
No one will eat this food; it might just as well be thrown away.
Note that may/might as well cannot be used in a question or may or might cannot be negated
(*may/might not as well), but we use not to negate the following verb. However, a question or
49
negation can be used in It might be (just) as well to construction; in such a case, the infinitive
with to is usually used as follows:
29
The omission of the infinitive sign, to
R. Quirk, et al (1972) pointed out “The to of the infinitive is optionally omitted in a clause
which, as complement, expands the meaning of the verb DO.” When we do not use the infinitive
sign, to, we call it bare infinitive or infinitive without to. They mean the same. A bare infinitive
occurs because the subject of each sentence contains the verb DO in the noun clause (Gu 1984).
We are going to describe the detail of the omission of the infinitive sign, to, in various
constructions below:
The all+ subject + do construction is used to introduce a noun clause. In such a case the
infinitive sign, to, is usually omitted in its complement, as in
1. All I did was (to) turn off the gas. (All I did is a noun clause used as subject of the
sentence.)
2. All you do is talk about cars. (To is omitted between is and talk in the sentence.)
3. All she seems to do is gossip with her friend.
(To is omitted between is and gossip in the sentence.)
4. All we have to do is push the button. (To is omitted between is and push in the
sentence.)
5. All I could do was beat the thug black and blue.
(To is omitted between was and beat in the sentence.)
6. For now, all he could do was be patient and wait.
(To is omitted between was and be in the sentence.)
7. All he has to do was bathe and dress, then take the two-hour wagon to the MacGregor
plantation, where the wedding was due to start at once. --- Roots, p.728
In the … thing(s)+ subject + do … construction, we usually have first, only, etc., used to
premodify thing or things as in
50
The first thing we had to do was ask him for help.
(To is omitted between was and ask in the sentence, thing being modified by the
first.)
If you ever went to the United States to study in a college or a university, one of the
first things you would have to do is open a checking account.
---– English for Today, Book 3, p.225
(To is omitted between is and open in the sentence.)
The only thing I can do now is go on by myself.
(To is omitted between is and go in the sentence.)
The only thing she can do now is divorce him.
(To is omitted between is and divorce in the sentence.)
In what + subject + do construction, the what is tantamount to the meaning of that which or the
thing(s) which/that, as in
It is noted that a past participle can be used when the perfect tense is used in the subject or a
gerund can be used when a progressive tense is used in the subject, as in
What he has done is spoilt the whole thing. (Spoilt is used because of has done.)
What he is doing is spoiling the whole thing. (Spoiling, a gerund, is used because of
the progressive tense, is doing.)
The infinitive sign, to, can be also omitted in the best (most, least, etc.,) … to do construction,
where the best means the thing(s) that is (are) best, the most, the greatest amount or the most
possible thing(s), and the least, the least possible thing(s), as in
51
The least I can do is drive everybody else closer to the issue.
The best way to do was wait until Richie was not entangled in a court action.
The best she could do was remain silent.
As long as you have air, the best thing to do is stay on the bottom and find shelter in
` the reef.
The worst you can do is become very drowsy.
In the examples from A to D above, we notice that the subject of each sentence must contain the
verb do form, which can be either finite or non-finite. The linking verb is usually be (is used in
the present time or future time and was used in the past time) in the sentence.
More examples:
What he’ll do is spoil the whole thing. (future time in the noun clause)
What he’s done is spoil the whole thing. (present perfect in the noun clause)
All he did was talk to her patiently. (past time in the noun clause)
All you do is think of him. (present time in the noun clause)
What he’s doing is spoiling the whole thing. (progressive tense in the noun clause, but
spoiling is a gerund.)
All we are trying to do is find the fact. (to do, non-finite form)
The best thing she could do was remain silent. (used with an auxiliary verb)
All I could do when we got on the ground was hug and kiss the man.
---- Reader’s Digest, Oct. 1974, p.20
(When we got on the ground, the adverbial clause of time, is inserted between could do
and was in the above sentence.)
The only thing I can do now is go on by myself. (Now is inserted between do and is.)
In the last two sentences, something is inserted between the verb be and the infinitive. It does not
affect the omission of the infinitive sign, to, in such cases. Moreover, when the subject
complement is placed before the subject of the sentence for the purpose of emphasis, the
infinitive sign, to, is still omitted, as in
Die is the last thing I shall do, doctor. Cf. The last thing I shall do is (to) die, doctor.
Turn off the tap was all I did. Cf. All I did was (to) turn off the tap.) (Quirk, et al 1972)
E Come or go
Usually when come or go used in imperative sentences (but not limited) or indicative sentences
or interrogative questions (also see A in 14), bare infinitives are often used (Gu 1984).
For example:
52
I’ll come ask her about it.
I’ll go tell her.
Come live with me and be my honey. (Imperative)
“Go take a look in the closet,” he told Leuci.
---- Reader’s Digest, August 1979, p.202
Let’s go find us a drink.
Let’s go find something to eat.
I think I’ll go lie down for a while.
I had to call my folks to come get me.
He decided to go borrow it.
She finally had to go ask for a raise.
You’d better go see a doctor about that cut.
I’d like to go hear a concert this afternoon.
Will you come join us?
Do you want to go look at yourself?
Do come to my house this evening!
In the last sentence above, DO is used for the emphasis of the action COME in the imperative
sentence, which has nothing to do with the omission of to between do and come. In the above
sentences except the last one, the infinitive sign to is omitted, but attention should be paid to the
fact that when come or go in past form, the to is usually not omitted, so we usually do not say:*I
went tell her, *He came watch the movie last night, but instead, we say I went to tell her and
He came to watch the movie last night. We can also use and in He came and watched the movie
last night. This sentence is correct. But in this sentence, and watched the movie last night,
expresses result. Also see A Purpose in 14. Sometimes the infinitive to is still omitted even if an
adverb is used after come or go (Gu1984), e.g.
The omission of the infinitive to also happens in the sentences where an adverb is inserted as we
see the last three sentences above (over is inserted between go and talk, on between come and
get, and in between come and watch).
The omission is often seen in advertisements (especially in AmE) for the sake of brevity or in
order to catch people’s attention, as in
Come fly Korea. Come spend a few pleasant hours as our guests.
---- Time, April 14, 1980, p.3
53
There will be pageants, parades, festivals, even royal tours. Come celebrate with us.
---- Newsweek, April 21, 1980, p.13
F Help
Sandy helped me (to) clean the room. (To is optional after the verb, help.)
This book helps me to see the truth.
The rag helps me to clean the table.
It is noted that in the sentences above: “Sandy helped me (to) clean the room”, where to is either
used or omitted after help, but especially in American English, to, is usually not used in such a
case. We keep the infinitive sign to in the last two sentences, because the subject of the sentence
does not directly participate in the following action – the book does not see the truth – and
neither does the rag - do the cleaning, while Sandy does part of her work – cleaning the room, so
to is not used. In a word, when help is used as a main verb and the subject of the sentence does
not do the work or part of the work in the infinitive, to is usually retained. In informal English,
the infinitive sign, to, is often omitted after help. However, when to is not used in such a case, it
does not affect the meaning of the sentence. When it is converted into passive, the to is usually
used, as in
In the United States the verb help may be followed by the simple form (infinitive without to) …
while in Great Britain, the to infinitive is required (Evens, et al 1957).
30
Bare infinitives used after some prepositions
A bare infinitive (also see 11) may occasionally be used after the prepositions except, but, than,
rather than, about, besides, save, etc., as in
54
The child did nothing except weep.
Cf. He seldom comes except to look at my pictures.
(To is used because there is no Do form in it as described in A through D in 29.)
She will do anything for you except lend your money.
Cf. It had no effect except to make him angry.
She did nothing except complain the whole time she was here.
What could I do then except watch them carry you away?
Sandy can do everything except cook.
They could do nothing but wait for the doctor to arrive.
She can do anything but sing.
He did nothing but laugh.
They couldn’t do anything but just sit there and hope.
From the above examples, we see a bare infinitive used after the prepositions except, but, and
than, because in the predicate contains the verb DO. Without the use of DO, we usually keep the
infinitive sign, to, as in “He seldom comes except to look at my pictures.” “It had no effect
except to make him angry.” “He desired nothing but to succeed”, etc. When do nothing else
construction is used, we do not use but or except; instead, we use than instead (Gu 1984), as in
Besides what has been described above, the omission of the infinitive sign to also happens after
the prepositions save, besides, etc., when the verb DO (finite or non-finite) appears, as in
What had she done for her father save leave him at the first opportunity?
I hardly remember what I did besides read.
That afternoon I had nothing to do besides answer letters.
What has he done besides read the paper?
31
Bare infinitives used in some fix phrases or idioms
The omission of the infinitive sign, to, happens in some fix phrases, e.g. go hang, go fetch ( a
dog), make believe, make do, hear say, hear tell, let drop, let fall, let go, let slip, let drive, let
fly, etc., as in
55
He made believe he was innocent.
Don’t let slip such a good opportunity to learn.
He let go (of) the rope.
Make that dog leave go of my coat.
I’ve heard tell of such happenings.
I hear say that there will be an earthquake soon.
We can’t let things go hang.
I dare say he’ll come later.
He let fly a torrent of abuse at me.
He drew his sword and let drive at me.
It is do or die. (bare infinitive)
32
How +come + (that–clause)
How come is used to ask why something has happened or been said, especially when you are
surprised by it, as in
33
Why (not) + bare infinitive
Why + bare infinitive is used to introduce questions usually to suggest that it is stupid or
pointless to do something while why not + bare infinitive introduces suggestions and advice, as
in
Why worry? (Cf. “Why do you worry?” or “Why did you worry?)
Why worry about such trifling matters?
56
Why risk breaking the law?
Why pay more at other shops?
Why not consult your supervisor? (NOT Why not to consult …?)
You’re putting on weight. Why not have your tea without sugar?
It’s cold outside. Why not close the window?
Why not take a break/a holiday?
Why not make your dress, instead of buying it?
Remember a past adverbial cannot be used with this construction; therefore, we do not say:
But when a past adverbial is used, we will change the structure and we can say:
34
The split infinitive
An adverb is sometimes placed between the infinitive and its sign to. This construction is known
as the split infinitive, e.g.
The delay is bound to seriously hamper the progress of rebuilding the city.
The adverb seriously is inserted between the infinitive sign to and the infinitive verb, hamper.
Split infinitive constructions are quite common in English, especially in informal English. The
split infinitive should have been avoided here. Some people think the use of a split infinitive
incorrect. But sometimes, when the avoidance of a split infinitive involves “real ambiguity” or
“patent artificially,” as Fowler put it, we should not hesitate to use one (Huang 1979). Split
infinitives are common usage when we want the adverb to modify it, as in
35
The omission of the infinitive after the main verb
A We can leave an infinitive, but keep the infinitive sign to, in order to avoid its repetition, as
in
58
B: Yes, I allow you (to).
Note that we usually omit to after the verb like, but not would like (as seen below), e.g.
But when the finite verb has an auxiliary verb or perfect tense, we usually repeat them after the
infinitive sign to, e.g.
Ms. R was fired, but she didn’t expect to be. (Was is an auxiliary verb in main clause,
was fired.)
I haven’t finished as much work today as I’d like to have.
(Have is an auxiliary verb in the main clause haven’t finished.)
B When and is used to link the previous verb, we do not usually use the infinitive sign to, e.g.
I will come and let you know how to do it. (= I will come to let ….)
I’ll come to get you and drive you to Las Vegas.
I learnt to read and write at the age of six.
However, to is sometimes used after and or or because of emphasis shown in comparison with or
contrast with, the two or more coordination, as in
59
Better to die standing than to live on one’s knees.
36
The absolute construction
Besides infinitives used independent elements, which are looked upon as legitimate dangling
infinitives, the absolute construction of an infinitive, comparable with that of the participle, is
also in existence, e.g.
Books borrowed must be returned when due, the defaulter to pay a fine of 5 cents per
book per day.
Mrs. Roden went to Poland yesterday, her husband to join her next week.
That is the end of the illustration of the use of the infinitive, one of the three non-finite forms -
the infinitive, the participles (which have two forms, the present participle and the past
participle), and the gerund. The infinitive also has two types of infinitives: the infinitive with to
(to-infinitive) and the infinitive without to (bare infinitive). English learners whose native
language is not English always find it difficult how to use the infinitive correctly. By amplifying
them with various kinds of attributives and/or adverbials, A.S. Hornby expanded them into his
25 sentence constructions in Guide to Constructions and Usage in English, Oxford University
Press (Oxford London, 1976). Moreover, Longman Dictionary of Contemporary English (Great
Britain: The Pitman Press, 1978) is also a good English dictionary for English learners because it
tells us how to use each word correctly in English. At the end of the dictionary there is a table of
codes to describe the constructions of each verb. The authors of the dictionary used simple and
basic English words to define, describe, and illustrate each word in the dictionary so that
English learners can easily read and understand each definition and description. In the future the
writer will illustrate the other two non-finite forms - the participles (which have two forms, the
present participle and the past participle), and the gerund. Any comment or critique is welcome
of the article.
60
References
Alexander, L G and Allen, W Stannard and Close R A and O’Neill R J (1977). English
grammatical structure. London: Longman.
Courtney, Rosemary (1983). Longman Dictionary of Phrasal Verbs. England: Longman
Cowie, A P, et al (1983). Oxford Dictionary of Current Idiomatic English. London: Oxford
University Press.
Eastwood, John (2002). Oxford Guide to English Grammar. Oxford University Press.
Evans, Bergen and Evans, Cornelia (1957). A Dictionary of Contemporary American Usage.
New York: Random House.
Ge, Chuangui (1962). A Dictionary of English Idiomatic Usage. Beijing: The Times Press.
Gu, Wenyuan (1984). On the Omission of the Infinitive Sign “to”, printed in the Journal of
Shanghai Maritime University, No. 1, Shanghai China.
Hornby, A S (1994). Oxford Advanced Learner’s English-Chinese Dictionary, Fourth edition.
Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Hornby, A S (1975). Guide to Patterns and Usage in English, Second edition. Oxford:
Oxford University Press.
Huang, Ziwen (1979). The English Verb. China: Commerce Press.
Leech, Geoffrey and Svartvik, Jan (1974). A Communicative Grammar of English. Great
Britain: Longman.
Leech, Geoffrey N (1978). Meaning and the English Verb. London: Longman.
L. X. H. (1982). Kaiming English Grammar. Foreign Language Teaching & Research Press,
Beijing Institute of Foreign Languages, Beijing China.
Long, T.H. and Summers, Della (1979). Longman Dictionary of English Idioms. London:
Longman.
Palmer, F.R. (1978). The English Verb. London: Longman.
Quirk, Randoph, et al (1972). A Grammar of Contemporary English. Longman House, Burnt
Mill, Hartow, Essex CM20 2JE, England and Associated Companies throughout the
world, Longman Group Ltd.
Quirk, Randolph (1978). Longman Dictionary of Contemporary English. Great Britain: The
Pitman Press.
Quirk, Randolph (2004). Longman Dictionary of Contemporary English with Chinese
Translation. Beijing: Foreign Language Teaching and Research Press.
R. A. Close (1975). A Reference Grammar for Students of English. Longman Group Limited
Landon.
R. A. Close (1976). Guide to Constructions and Usage in English. Oxford University Press,
Oxford.
Randall, Bernice (1988). Webster’s New World Guide to Current American Usage. New York:
Webster’s New World.
Schibsbye, Knud (1979). A Modern English Grammar, Second Edition. Oxford University
Press.
61
Swan, Michael (1980). Practical English Usage. Oxford University Press.
Wood, Frederick T. (1993). English Prepositional Idioms with Chinese Translation. Beijing:
Knowledge Press.
Wood, Fredrick T. (1981). Current English Usage. The Macmillan Press Limited, London
Xu, Liwu (1979) A Practical Grammar of Contemporary English. China: Hunan
People’s Press.
Zhang, Daozhen (1979). A Practical English Grammar. China: Commerce Press.
Zhang, Zhanbang (1981). A New English Grammar. Shanghai: Translation Press.
62