Here is my evaluation of the Hölzel et al. study in two strengths and two weaknesses:
Strengths:
1. The use of MRI scans allowed for precise measurements of changes in brain structure, providing objective data on the effects of mindfulness meditation. This strengthened the conclusions that could be drawn.
2. The study design involved experienced meditators, increasing the likelihood that observed brain changes were directly caused by regular meditation practice rather than other factors.
Weaknesses:
1. As a single study, its findings cannot necessarily be generalized to all people or contexts. More research is needed to understand how meditation may differently affect various populations.
2. Being a cross-sectional study rather than longitudinal, it could not determine the
Here is my evaluation of the Hölzel et al. study in two strengths and two weaknesses:
Strengths:
1. The use of MRI scans allowed for precise measurements of changes in brain structure, providing objective data on the effects of mindfulness meditation. This strengthened the conclusions that could be drawn.
2. The study design involved experienced meditators, increasing the likelihood that observed brain changes were directly caused by regular meditation practice rather than other factors.
Weaknesses:
1. As a single study, its findings cannot necessarily be generalized to all people or contexts. More research is needed to understand how meditation may differently affect various populations.
2. Being a cross-sectional study rather than longitudinal, it could not determine the
Here is my evaluation of the Hölzel et al. study in two strengths and two weaknesses:
Strengths:
1. The use of MRI scans allowed for precise measurements of changes in brain structure, providing objective data on the effects of mindfulness meditation. This strengthened the conclusions that could be drawn.
2. The study design involved experienced meditators, increasing the likelihood that observed brain changes were directly caused by regular meditation practice rather than other factors.
Weaknesses:
1. As a single study, its findings cannot necessarily be generalized to all people or contexts. More research is needed to understand how meditation may differently affect various populations.
2. Being a cross-sectional study rather than longitudinal, it could not determine the
Here is my evaluation of the Hölzel et al. study in two strengths and two weaknesses:
Strengths:
1. The use of MRI scans allowed for precise measurements of changes in brain structure, providing objective data on the effects of mindfulness meditation. This strengthened the conclusions that could be drawn.
2. The study design involved experienced meditators, increasing the likelihood that observed brain changes were directly caused by regular meditation practice rather than other factors.
Weaknesses:
1. As a single study, its findings cannot necessarily be generalized to all people or contexts. More research is needed to understand how meditation may differently affect various populations.
2. Being a cross-sectional study rather than longitudinal, it could not determine the
Download as PPTX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
Download as pptx, pdf, or txt
You are on page 1of 20
Psychology - AS Level
BIOLOGICAL APPROACH H Ö LZEL ET AL (MINDFULNESS & BRAIN SCANS) Biological Approach HÖLZEL ET AL (Mindfulness & Brain Scans)
What is mindfulness meditation?
Britta Hölzel is a psychologist, neuroscientist & mindfulness based stress reduction / yoga teacher. She used magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) scans to investigate structural & functional brain changes that occur following regular mindfulness meditation. Mindfulness is a stress-reduction technique used to improve wellbeing. Develop awareness of the present moment Encourages a compassionate / non-judgemental attitude Anxiety / chronic pain / substance abuse cure Positive impact on personal well-being Mindfulness Meditation Practice - Make yourself comfortable - Close your eyes - Relax your body - Focus on the rise and fall of your breathing - Start to focus your attention on different parts of the body – a “body scan” - Begin at your toes / feet and work your way up your whole body – Focus on your muscles and any tension you might feel
Do you meditate? How does it feel? Do you think it works? Is it a
useful strategy for relaxation? Does it make you feel strange? Phineas Gage Who was he? Born in 1823, Phineas Gage was a U.S. railroad construction worker. He was known as being smart and shrewd, as well as a hard-worker. Physically, he was well-built and strong. On 13th September 1848, an accident caused an iron rod – 3.2 cm wide and 1.1 metre long) to shoot up and enter the left side of his face. Through his lower jaw, the iron rod passed through his whole head, behind his left eye, fracturing his cheekbone, penetrating the left side of his brain and exiting through the top of his skull. The rod landed 25m away covered in brain and blood. After some body convulsions, he was speaking within a few minutes, could walk and displayed evidence of rationality. He lost site in his left eye, suffering occasional lapses in memory, concentration and recognising people he had known throughout his life. How do you feel brains were studied 100-years ago? Localisation of Function Specific areas of the brain are associated with certain functions and psychological processes. Physical damage and internal trauma can change a person’s personality. - Stroke - Alzheimers / Dementia – Trauma - Heart attacks (restricted oxygen to the brain) Localisation of Function Different parts of the brain perform specific functions. The Hippocampus deals with learning / memory / emotional control / spatial navigation. Amygdala helps to process fearful and threatening stimulae. However, proper function relies on all areas working together in harmont. The Hölzel et al. study investigates how mindfulness mediation may affect localisation of function in the brain via changing actual brain density. Evidence suggests that increased brain volume or density is linked to increased performane abilities. Localisation of Function Detailed MRI scans were used to create models of the human brain. These models were used to measure microscopic changes that occur in specific brain structures following mindfulness practice. Plasticity of the brain: The above changes are called structural plasticity and can be quantified using voxel- based mophometry (VBM). VBM: A process which measures the concentration of grey matter (a type of brain tissue) in key brain structures. Mindfullness-Based Stress Reduction A technique developed by Profession Jon Kabat-Zinn (USA). Combines Buddhist mediation with a scientific approach. Developed an 8-week programme of 2.5 hour weekly group meetings, plus a 6.5 training day. Members are encouraged to: BODY SCAN / MINDFUL YOGA / SITTING MEDITATION
”Five Facets of Mindfulness Questionairre” Baer et al.
Ruth Bear developed a way to measure changes in five key areas of mindfulness. Mindfullness-Based Stress Reduction Passing thoughts and feelings: (1) Observe them (2) Describe them (3) How to not react to them (4) Awareness of your actions
Biophysicists are still uncertain as to how mindfulness techniques increase well-
being, yet neuroimaging is beginning to reveal which brain structures are involved. Previous Research Experienced meditators have significantly more grey matter in some key brain areas. Hippocampus and insula have been identified as important areas. fMRI scans show that the hippocampus is particularly active during meditation (Lazar et al. 2000). Likewise, longitudinal studies have shown that grey matter increases in key brain structures when people learn new skills, knowledge and languages. *fMRI: Produce FUNCTIONAL scans, rather than STRUCTURAL. Measures heightened blood flow in key areas. Voxel Based Morphometry “Volume & Pixel”: A tiny cubic measurement used to quantify the volume o three- dimensional structures. It allows researchers to compare the relative size of brain structures between people, as well as to monitor changes in a single individual over time. Involves classifying brain tissue into grey matter & white matter. White matter is found closer to the centre of the brain. It contains nerve fibers (axons) – the endings of neurons – and makes up 60% of the structure. Grey Matter vs. White Matter 40% of the brain is made up of grey matter. It can be found on the outer edges of the sphere. Grey matter contains most of the brain’s neuronal cell bodies, and fully develops when a person is in his/her early twenties. It is responsible for sending information around the body and conducts the significant neurological processes. White matter develops until a person is middle-aged. It is responsible for interpreting information from various parts of the body, essentially “reading” any responses received from the signals sent out by grey matter neurons. Evaluate the study by Hölzel et al. (mindfulness and brain scans) in terms of two strengths and two weaknesses. At least one of your evaluation points must be about generalisations.