"Unrest and trauma stays with you!": Navigating mental health and professional service-seeking in Kashmir
Abstract
1 Introduction
2 Background
3 Related Work
3.1 Mental Health and HCI
3.2 Ecological Systems Theory Framework
4 Methodology
4.1 Participants and Recruitment
Name | Age | Gender | Occupation | Martial Status | Clinically Diagnosed |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
P1 | 26 | Female | Employed | Single | Major depressive disorder |
P2 | 31 | Male | Employed | Married | Obsessive compulsive disorder |
P3 | 23 | Female | Student | Single | Generalised anxiety disorder |
P4 | 28 | Male | Employed | Single | Major depressive disorder |
P5 | 35 | Female | Employed | Married | Generalised anxiety disorder |
P6 | 27 | Female | Unemployed | Single | Major depressive disorder |
P7 | 22 | Male | Student | Single | Generalised anxiety disorder |
P8 | 25 | Female | Student | Single | Anxiety and PTSD |
P9 | 21 | Female | Student | Single | Generalised anxiety disorder |
P10 | 33 | Female | Employed | Married | Obsessive compulsive disorder |
P11 | 26 | Female | Employed | Single | Generalised anxiety disorder |
P12 | 28 | Female | Employed | Single | Major depressive disorder |
P13 | 20 | Male | Student | Single | Generalised anxiety disorder |
P14 | 22 | Male | Student | Single | Obsessive compulsive disorder |
P15 | 29 | Female | Employed | Married | Major depressive disorder |
P16 | 32 | Male | Employed | Married | Obsessive compulsive disorder |
P17 | 25 | Male | Student | Single | Generalised anxiety disorder |
P18 | 27 | Male | Employed | Single | Generalised anxiety disorder |
4.2 Data Collection
4.3 Ethics
4.4 Data Analysis
4.5 Study Limitations
4.6 Positionality
5 Findings
5.1 Mental Health struggles rooted in the Context
5.1.1 Impact of socio-political influences.
“obviously, it (mental health) has been impacted because the focus is never on our mental health or well-being; it is rather on other things, so it has been impacted.” (P2, Male)
“…if you leave late from the office, you think you can be stopped anywhere; ID cards are often checked… checkings happen more often... Recently, a gun was pointed at one of my colleagues, so he was scared of coming to the office...and it scares me...these things always remain there subconsciously in my mind…” (P1, Female)
“...even when we used to go to tuition centers, I’ve seen firings and bullets…we used to go to hide in some neighbor’s places…those impressions are in my mind, and they affect you really deeply...” (P3, Female)
“my classmate in college got killed. I used to see him in the bus daily, which was shocking when I got the news. It does impact somewhere.” (P3, Female)
“...we had this CASO in our area...my kid was in school...cordon in my area started everywhere...my kid had not reached home...during that period nobody is allowed to come inside to that area or go out from that area...that builds up stress and trauma in you…” (P5, Female)
“kashmiri’s are looked at with suspicion outside, then you have to prove your loyalty. So this unrest and trauma stays with you…crises spills beans on your psyche and affect you too much.” (P4, Male)
5.1.2 Impact of socio-cultural influences.
“…here, people didn’t even know that mental health issues can be treated…people are not even aware of the availability of services…the awareness is still lacking among the people.” (P2, Male)
“an irony I recently realized, especially in Kashmir, if you are a girl of marriageable age, you are not supposed to say that you have some mental health disorders, then no one will marry you…” (P15, Female)
“if I tell my parents, I feel that I am having anxiety, they will tell me you should have offered Namaz (prayer); it’s because you don’t offer Namaz, that’s why it happens to you. Pray, and everything will be fine” (P7, Male)
“I prefer a male psychiatrist...But for a therapist, you have very long sessions, you have to talk a lot, and a lot of times, you are not really comfortable talking about issues with the opposite gender. I think religion has to play a role and also the social context or the culture we are in…in Kashmir we have grown up where we are taught not to have male friends...and, I think religion also permits us to have the bare minimum contact and interaction with male people…in ample of cases the concept of transference and counter-transference, like eventually the client or the patient falls for the therapist or something, that’s very true, and I’ve seen in a lot of cases that happen. I tend to prefer a female therapist for me.” (P6, Female)
5.2 Moving Forward and Embracing Support
5.2.1 Recognition of the need for help.
“I don’t just use any strategy I just used to you know going to my bed and just sleep not think about it. Sleep has been my coping mechanism to be very honest...” (P2, Male)
“pandemic was a blessing in disguise at least this topic was touched multiple times. I think it has been a major topic being discussed in our society after these incidents. It might have reached many people during that time and many might have considered seeking help.” (P8, Female)
“we had a project called “well being” at the organisation I am working at and I read that document once... I took the permission from lead to text her (psychologist) and that’s how I connected with her... At that time I only knew that there was something going on with me...I was clueless and had no idea regarding seeking help.That document triggered me to at least think about it...” (P1, Female)
5.2.2 Stigma, Privacy Concerns, and Personal Experiences: Navigating Help-seeking.
“I think you should go first to a clinical psychologist and only if, you know, you cannot, I think you overcome everything by only seeking help from a psychologist rather than going to a psychiatrist. Only if that doesn’t help you then only you can go to a psychiatrist and seek medical help.” (P5, Female)
“I did not know who would be there on the other end of the call. I do know people can check through true callers whose number it is. I was scared what if it would be someone who would even remotely know me or know who I am. I did not want to take the risk of sharing my problem with anyone like that.” (P9, Female)
“…everything to proper scheduling, there are no proper clinics, and the therapists I was seeking before she was taking these offline sessions. And then she switched to the online thing. So I went to no proper clinic here. So a proper clinical infrastructure is not here…” (P6, Female)
“I was forcefully taken to a faith healer, and luckily that faith healer was educated he had studied psychology, and he told me that this is not a matter of her being possessed by someone but rather take her to a doctor.” (P13, Male)
5.2.3 Aspirations and Hopes for a Better Future.
“now there has been a lot of improvement I believe people are talking about it, people are not shying away from talking about mental health problems. But still, you know, a lot can be improved in this area.” (P1, Female)
“people don’t have that much reach, these resources are not accessible. No doubt people have got those helplines, or they have got those numbers, but they can’t take online consultations” (P6, Female)
“community leaders giving a speech or sermon [on mental health] during Friday prayers might have a special impact... build clinic’s, infrastructure...introduce these concepts to more colleges so that people can learn and then eventually bridge the gap...not everyone can get education from outside...do something so that you can produce therapist and mental health professionals here...” (P4, Male)
“I think elders should listen to the younger generation they might be experienced but they should be open to learn more understanding.” (P7, Male)
5.3 Patterns, Challenges and Expectations: Technology for Mental Health Support
5.3.1 Usage patterns: Role of Technology in seeking support.
“I use an app called CALM its kind of related to nature sounds like waterfall, birds these kind of things you can use for meditate...I Just mainly use YouTube to see motivational videos for example some motivational videos of 5 minutes like of Jay Shetty, or psychology on YouTube...” (P13, Male)
“there are a lot of pages on Instagram from psychologists. I used to follow that and it used to give me a little pump for a few seconds only though, but still somewhere you feel a little better about it. But I believe the social media has drastically affected the mental health of people, especially Instagram” (P12, Female)
“before visiting the doctor physically, I listened to Dr. Aseem (psychiatrist) on a program on DD Kasher, and from that, I texted him on Facebook. Although I did not expect any reply back, I at least tried…” (P11, Female)
5.3.2 Struggles in Using Technology for Seeking Support.
“in 2019 I used to go insane...I stay stable by learning new things on the internet...2019 was very harsh and hard as compared to the pandemic.” (P11, Female)
“there is a lot of misinformation and everybody these days has become a counselor or a psychologist. There are people who are making wrong claims and giving false information. I know a lot of people who do not even have medical background talk about being professionals and surprisingly these people have become influencers and are talking about whatever fits their narrative. And it’s sad for people who don’t really know anything and they buy that information.” (P10, Female)
5.3.3 Participants’ perspectives: Towards Technology-Enabled Support.
“…schools and colleges now let other people come and give talks and any kind of awareness like we have drug abuse as an issue today…believe me, these university students are going through a hell of stress presently because of competition, unemployment… I think that is one of the platforms where you can introduce technology show them the impact of mental health or display inspirational stories…”(P5, Female)
“the people who have the platform who have the voice, they can talk about it. similarly, people who are following them, see or listen to that, they might feel that no, it’s not a problem with me. Other people are also facing the same issue.that’s what I believe could be done...talking about it, on platforms and social media.” (P16, Female)
“there are a few apps like ACE online or Made Easy, if you purchase their prerecorded courses, and if you wish to screenshot or screen record the content, the app doesn’t allow that. Similarly, if online therapy or sessions have the same features, a person can ensure that the session can neither get recorded nor allow taking screenshots. That way, patients will get privacy, and they won’t hesitate to talk about everything…” (P11, Female)
6 Discussion
6.1 The interplay of Influences: Ecological Model of Mental Health Support Seeking
6.1.1 Chronosystem Level Influences .
6.1.2 Macrosystem Level Influences .
6.1.3 Exosystem Level Influences .
6.1.4 Microsystem Level Influences .
7 Conclusion
Acknowledgments
Footnotes
Supplemental Material
- Download
- 184.89 MB
- Transcript
References
Index Terms
- "Unrest and trauma stays with you!": Navigating mental health and professional service-seeking in Kashmir
Recommendations
Self-tracking for Mental Wellness: Understanding Expert Perspectives and Student Experiences
CHI '17: Proceedings of the 2017 CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing SystemsPrevious research suggests an important role for self-tracking in promoting mental wellness. Recent studies with college student populations have examined the feasibility of collecting everyday mood, activity, and social data. However, these studies do ...
Computing in Mental Health
CHI EA '16: Proceedings of the 2016 CHI Conference Extended Abstracts on Human Factors in Computing Systems18.5% of adults in the US suffer mental illness. Just under half of all adults will experience mental illness at some point in their life. These compelling statistics have prompted computing researchers and practitioners to work toward developing ...
Leveraging technology to improve quality of mental health care in Karnataka
WebSci '21 Companion: Companion Publication of the 13th ACM Web Science Conference 2021Health is multidimensional and “there is no health without mental health”. We document ongoing technology-enabled initiatives for enhancing mental health care in the state of Karnataka. Multi-disciplinary teams have collaborated on a set of four ...
Comments
Information & Contributors
Information
Published In
Sponsors
Publisher
Association for Computing Machinery
New York, NY, United States
Publication History
Check for updates
Author Tags
Qualifiers
- Research-article
- Research
- Refereed limited
Conference
Acceptance Rates
Upcoming Conference
- Sponsor:
- sigchi
Contributors
Other Metrics
Bibliometrics & Citations
Bibliometrics
Article Metrics
- 0Total Citations
- 1,428Total Downloads
- Downloads (Last 12 months)1,428
- Downloads (Last 6 weeks)278
Other Metrics
Citations
View Options
View options
View or Download as a PDF file.
PDFeReader
View online with eReader.
eReaderHTML Format
View this article in HTML Format.
HTML FormatLogin options
Check if you have access through your login credentials or your institution to get full access on this article.
Sign in