Democratic representation in Europe:
diversity, change, and convergence
Contents
List of Figures
x
List of Tables
xv
Notes on Contributors
xviii
Preface
xxii
1. Parliamentary Representatives from Early Democratization to the Age
of Consolidated Democracy: National Variations and International
Convergence in a Long-term Perspective
Maurizio Cotta and Heinrich Best
1.1. A long-term perspective on the democratization of Europe:
political representation and the great change of European societies
1.2. Research bases
1.3. Theoretical perspectives
1.4. Previous findings: variations and common trends in the long-term
change of European parliamentary recruitment and careers
1.5. Mapping differences arid similarities: research questions and
guidelines for this book
1.6. Searching for explanations
1.7. The plan of the book, chapters, and their contents
1
1
5
7
13
16
22
23
Part I Dimensions of Variation
2. The Decline of the Nobility
Michael Rush
2.1. Introduction
2.2. The pre-democratic role of the nobility
2.3. The nobility and democratization
2.4. Conclusion
3. From Servants of the State to Elected Representatives: Public Sector
Background among Members of Parliament
Maurizio Cotta and Pedro Tavares de Almeida
3.1. Preliminary remarks
3.2. Two perspectives for understanding the weight of the étatiste
background among parliamentary elites
29
29
33
38
48
51
51
53
Contents
3.3.
3.4.
3.5.
3.6.
3.7.
3.8.
The variables and data in the DATACUBE
An historical trend
Components of the public service
Variations across countries
Variations across parties
Concluding remarks
4. Why so Few and Why so Slow? Women as Parliamentary
Representatives in Europe from a Longitudinal Perspective
Verona Christmas-Best and Ulrik Kjœr
4.1. Introduction
4.2. The concept of gender parity
4.3. Research findings from the literature
4.4. Hypotheses and methods
4.5. Data analysis
4.6. Conclusion: why so slow, and why so few? Gender parity in the
European Parliaments
5. Cultural Capital and Political Selection: Educational Backgrounds
of Parliamentarians
Daniel Gaxie and Laurent Godmer
5.1. Historical transformations of educational backgrounds
of parliamentarians
5.2. The causes of the elevation of parliamentarians' education level
5.3. Consequences: towards new forms of political professionalization
and new channels of representation
6. A Career through the Party: The Recruitment of Party Politicians in
Parliament
Stefaan Fiers and Ineke Secker
6.1. Introduction
6.2. Parties and 'party politicians'
6.3. Recruitment of party officials
6.4. Recruitment of party functionaries
6.5. The role of the parties
6.6. Concluding analysis and discussion
7. The Geographical Dimension of Parliamentary Recruitment — among
Native Sons and Parachutists
Mogens N. Pedersen, Ulrik Kjœr, and Kjell A. Eliassen
7.1. Geography and recruitment
7.2. A conceptual framework
7.3. A micro approach
7.4. A quick tour of Western Europe
56
57
59
61
68
74
77
77
78
79
84
86
101
106
109
123
131
136
136
137
139
143
145
152
160
160
163
166
168
Contents
7.5. The longitudinal perspective
7.6. A two-country exploration:
7.7. Propositions for future research
Denmark
and
Norway
175
180
187
Part II. Variations across Party Families
8. The Changing Nature and Role of European Conservative Parties in
Parliamentary Institutions from 1848 to the Twenty-first Century
Valerie Cromwell and Luca Verzichelli
8.1. Questions, expectations, and rationale of the chapter
8.2. The fortunes of conservative parties within European
parliaments
8.3. The original profile of conservative parliamentary
recruitment
8.4. Conservative politicians in the age of 'catch-all parties':
towards a 'centre-right' pattern of recruitment?
8.5. The recent 'neoconservative' elite
8.6. Conclusions
9. Restructuring of the European Political Centre: Withering Liberal and
Persisting Agrarian Party Families
Ilkka Ruostetsaari
9.1. The liberal party family
9.2. The agrarian party family
9.3. Transformation of the agrarian parties into centre parties
9.4. Hypotheses
9.5. Education
9.6. Occupation
9.7. Political experience
9.8. Female representation
9.9. Conclusions
10. Christian Democratic Parliamentarians: From a Century of
Multifaceted Recruitment to the Convergence within a
'Larger Family'?
Luca Verzichelli
10.1. Introduction: research questions and structure of the chapter
10.2. The emergence of a Christian Democratic parliamentary elite:
When and how?
10.3. Parliamentary recruitment of the European Christian democratic
parties: long-term trends
10.4. Recent developments: new types of Christian Democratic
representation?
193
193
1%
198
205
210
214
217
219
223
226
227
229
233
241
248
248
253
253
255
265
276
Contents
10.5. Conclusion: from the multifaceted recruitment patterns of an
historical party family to converging but 'less Christian
Democratic' elites
11. Socialist and Communist Members of Parliament: Distinctiveness,
Convergence, and Variance
Gabriella Ilonszki
11.1. Framework and hypotheses
11.2. The
beginning
—
how
to
be
distinctive
11.3. Socialists, communists, and the others
11.4. Variations within the party family
11.5. Conclusions
280
284
284
288
292
309
313
12. The Extreme Right
316
Juan J. Linz, Miguel Jerez Mir, and Carmen Ortega
12.1. Introduction:extremisms on the right
316
12.2. From the late nineteenth century to the Second World War 322
12.3. Post-war extremists and neo-fascists
339
12.4. Conclusions
350
13. Parliamentary Elites of New European Party Families: Unsuccessful
Challenges
or
Chaotic
Signs
of
Change?
Filippo Tronconi and Luca Verzichelli
13.1. Anarchists, alternatives, beginners?'New politics'
representative elites after 1970
13.2. The impact of three 'new' party families within parliamentary
representation in European countries
13.3. How to deal with data on new parties: the small 'N' problem
and the significance of 'challengers' MPs
13.4. Working hypotheses and data exploration
13.5. Towards a tentative interpretation
13.6. Final remarks
353
353
356
358
360
380
387
Part III. Comprehensive Analyses
14. Cleavage Representation in European Parliamentary History
Heinrich Best
14.1. The cleavage concept and elite theory
14.2. Research concepts and methods
14.3. Elite structure and cleavage development: France in
comparative perspective
14.4. Strategies and dynamics of cleavage representations: a
comprehensive view
393
393
397
401
413
Contents
15. Paths of Institutional Development and Elite Transformations
Maurizio Cotta and Luca Verzichelli
15.1. Democratization and the transformation of parliamentary
elites
15.2. Searching for explanations: some preliminary hypotheses
15.3. The dependent variables
15.4. The independent variables
15.5. What empirical evidence for our hypotheses?
15.6. Between discontinuity and adaptation: the effects of regime
changes on the European parliamentary elites of the late
twentieth century
15.7. Conclusions
417
417
420
424
429
440
459
470
16. Conclusions
Maurizio Cotta
474
References
483
Index
509