Philippine Journal of Science
149 (2): 279-284, June 2020
ISSN 0031 - 7683
Date Received: 07 Nov 2019
Structural, Textural, and Thermal Properties
of Freeze-thawed Quick-frozen Cooked Rice
PSB Rc 18 (Oryza sativa L.)
Una Grace M. Dollete1,2* and Maria Patricia V. Azanza1
1Department
of Food Science and Nutrition, College of Home Economics
University of the Philippines Diliman, Quezon City, Philippines
2Food Processing Division, Industrial Technology Development Institute
Department of Science and Technology, Bicutan, Taguig City
The study characterized the quality properties of freeze-thawed quick-frozen intermediate
amylose cooked rice PSB Rc 18 (Oryza sativa L.). Scanning electron microscopy (SEM), texture
profile analysis (TPA), and differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) were employed to monitor
structural, textural, and thermal properties including retrogradation in quick-frozen rice as
subjected to 1, 3, and 5 freeze-thaw cycles (FTCs) (–18 °C for 16 h; 10 °C for 8 h). Data from
SEM, TPA, and DSC explained progressive deteriorative quality changes with increasing FTC.
The SEM micrographs revealed the formation of honeycomb structures. The TPA results
showed significant (p < 0.05) increase in hardness, cohesiveness, chewiness, springiness; as well
as a decrease in adhesiveness. The DSC analysis demonstrated the decreasing trend of thermal
transition temperatures. Based on the obtained results, it is recommended that quick-frozen
cooked rice should not be exposed to more than 3 FTCs.
Keywords: freeze-thaw cycle, frozen rice, intermediate amylose, Oryza sativa L., retrogradation
INTRODUCTION
FTCs have established negative effects in the overall
quality of frozen commodities that alter functional,
structural, textural, physical, and chemical properties of
food products – particularly those that are carbohydratebased (Srichuwong et al. 2012; Tao et al. 2015; Wu et
al. 2017; Wang et al. 2018). Recent advances in rice
processing technologies now encompass freezing. In fact,
frozen cooked rice – as a convenience food – is already
being marketed in Japan, Australia (Yu et al. 2016),
Korea (Kwak et al. 2015), and Thailand (Trithavisup and
Charoenrein 2018) using their own specific rice varieties.
Several studies reported that quick freezing technology
has a lot more potential to efficiently retain the desirable
*Senior Corresponding Author: udollete@yahoo.com
qualities of which rice consumers prefer (Yu et al. 2010a;
Kwak et al. 2013, 2015). Unfortunately, cooked rice – as a
convenience food-to-go traded under a cook-freeze-thaw
scheme – is subject to the negative effects of FTC during
conveyance and distribution.
Definitively, exposure to FTC may nullify whatever
positive effects of quick freezing to frozen products.
Studies reported a loss of textural, structural, sensorial and
decrease in shelflife of frozen rice due to retrogradation
(Wu et al. 2017; Wang et al. 2018) upon subject to 5 FTC.
Moreover, the fake rice incident in the Philippines is a
possible example of a severe occurrence of retrogradation
in cooked rice during FTC (Perez 2015). The rice involved
in the reported fake rice incident was described to have
styrofoam appearance with a chalky texture after being
subjected apparently to a number of FTC, as reported by
279
Dollete and Azanza: Properties of Freeze-thawed
Quick-frozen Cooked Rice
Philippine Journal of Science
Vol. 149 No. 2, June 2020
Ranada (2015). The properties of the so-called fake rice
deviated from the preferred characteristics of the freshly
cooked rice that is soft and fluffy (Cuevas et al. 2016).
This study aimed to evaluate the quality parameters of
the quick-frozen cooked rice that have been subjected
to 5 FTC.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Collection and Preparation Rice Samples
The intermediate amylose (20–24%) test Philippine rice
variety used in the study was Philippine Seed Board Rice
cultivar 18 (PSB Rc 18). Rice sample was harvested
during the wet season (October 2017) and obtained
from a reputable rice miller (JD Aguilar Rice Mill, San
Leonardo, Nueva Ecija). It was washed-drained using a
heavy-duty mixer (5K5SS, 315W, 220V, Kitchen Aid,
USA) with a 1:3 rice-tap water ratio at 60 rpm for 10 s
(four times), admixed with 1:2 grain-water ratio, cooked
in an automatic rice cooker (KW-2042, 1L, 400 W, 220
V, 60Hz, Kyowa, Japan), quick-frozen using a laboratoryscale freezing conveyor system (–35 ± 5 °C, 5 m), packed
in a CPET tray, and stored at –18 ± 1 °C.
FTC
The FTC applied in the study was storing quick-frozen
cooked rice samples at –18 ± 1 °C for 16 h then thawing
at 10 ± 1 °C in a chiller for 8 h. This FTC was repeated
up to 5 cycles. Freeze-thawed quick-frozen cooked rice
samples (FTC 1, FTC 3, and FTC 5) were subjected to
SEM, DSC, and TPA analyses. Raw, freshly cooked, and
quick-frozen cooked rice samples were also included in
the analyses.
TPA
The TPA of samples was performed using a texture
analyzer (TA XT.plus, Texture Technologies Corp., UK)
with a 50 kg load cell using a two-cycle compression. A
7.5-mm diameter compression plate was used to compress
three equidistant grains with a speed of 1.0 mm/s (Ma and
Sun 2009). The analysis was done in triplicates.
DSC
Samples' thermal properties were analyzed using a
Perkin Elmer DSC 4000 differential scanning calorimeter
(Perkin Elmer, USA). Rice samples (≈ 3 mg) were
weighed accurately into an aluminum pan and held
isothermally at 20 °C for 1 min before being heated from
20 to 100 °C at 10 °C/min (Ma and Sun 2009). For raw
grain samples, distilled water (≈ 6 mg) was added prior
isothermal holding process. Then, DSC was calibrated
with indium (melting point = 156.6 °C, ∆Hf = 28.6 J/g)
and an empty pan was used as a reference. Rice samples
were scanned using the heating profiles describe for rice
gelatinization. The onset (To), peak (Tp), and conclusion
(Tc) temperatures plus enthalpy (∆H) of gelatinization/
retrogradation were obtained by Pyris Software, version 11
(Perkin Elmer, USA). The degree of retrogradation (%DR)
was calculated using the formula: %DR = ∆HR/∆HG x
100%. The analysis was conducted in triplicates.
Statistical Analysis
Data obtained were reported as mean values and standards
deviations. Analysis of variance (ANOVA) by Scheffe’s
test (p < 0.05) were conducted using SAS 9.4 (SAS
Institute, Inc., USA).
RESULTS
Scanning Electron Microscope (SEM)
The micrographs of the surface and cross-section
of samples were viewed using an SEM (FEI Helios
Nanolab 600i, Dual Beam System, USA). Thawed rice
samples were freeze-dried and sputter-coated with gold
using an ion sputter (Jeol JFC-1001E Sputter Coater,
Nikon, USA). For cross-sectional observation, samples
were cut with a razor blade prior to sputter-coating.
Observations were made at magnifications of 100x and
500x with an accelerating voltage of 5 kV. For surface
observation, magnifications of 500x and 1000x with
an accelerating voltage of 2 kV were used (Teng et al.
2013). Representative micrographs from all the samples
were presented to compare structural changes of all rice
samples. The analysis was done in triplicates.
280
SEM
Figure 1 shows SEM cross-section (A–E) and surface
(F–J) images of raw, newly quick-frozen, and freezethawed quick-frozen cooked rice samples at FTC 1, 3,
and 5, respectively. Raw grain images (Figures 1A and
1F) were observed to have a starch granular appearance at
the cross-section (Figure 1A), with fissures and cracks on
the surface (Figure 1F). Quick-frozen rice images, on the
other hand, did not show the previously described granular
appearance, fissures, and cracks. Only images showing
some level of porosity were observed both in the surface
and cross-section (Figure 1B and 1G). With increasing
FTC, rice samples showed prominent reappearance of
fissures and cracks on cross-section (Figure 1C–E) and
increasing level of porosity on the surface (Figures 1H–J).
Dollete and Azanza: Properties of Freeze-thawed
Quick-frozen Cooked Rice
Philippine Journal of Science
Vol. 149 No. 2, June 2020
Figure 1. SEM images of cross-section A–E (100x) and surface F–J (1000x) of rice samples.
Legends: raw grain (A and F), quick-frozen cooked rice (B and G), FTC 1 (C and H), FTC 3 (D and I), FTC 5 (E and J),
smooth area (A-1), and rough area (A-2).
Table 1. Texture profile of rice samples (PSB Rc18).
Hardness
(kgf)
Cohesiveness
Springiness
(mm)
Gumminess
(kgf)
Chewiness
(kgf.mm)
Adhesiveness
(kgf.mm)
Stiffness
(kgf.mm)
Freshly
cooked
5.11 ± 0.15a
0.04 ± 0.01a
0.94 ± 0.08a
0.18 ± 0.05a
0.19 ± 0.01a
0.02 ± 0.01a
10.08 ± 1.68a
FreezeThawed
Cycle 1
5.12 ± 0.14a
0.07 ± 0.02a
0.99 ± 0.14a
0.33 ± 0.15a
0.22 ± 0.02a
0.0001 ± 0.0000a
8.76 ± 1.22a
FreezeThawed
Cycle 3
5.66 ± 0.11b
0.14 ± 0.04b
1.94 ± 0.23b
0.69 ± 0.18b
1.29 ± 0.12b
–0.0011 ±
0.0001b
9.65 ± 0.71a
a,b
Mean values (n= 30) with the same letter within the same column are not significantly different (p ≥ 0.05) using Scheffe grouping
TPA
The TPA results of freshly cooked (C) and freeze-thawed
cooked rice (FTC 1 and FTC 3) samples were shown in
Table 1. Raw grain, quick-frozen cooked rice, and 5th
cycle freeze-thawed quick-frozen cooked rice could not
be subjected to the TPA analysis since the sample hardness
was beyond the maximum instrument measurement
capacity of 5.00 ± 0.50 kgf.
The results showed that hardness, cohesiveness,
springiness, gumminess, and chewiness significantly (p <
0.05) increased after FTC 3. Conversely, the adhesiveness
value significantly (p < 0.05) decreased after samples
were exposed to FTC 3. Results on stiffness values were
not conclusive.
DSC
The DSC results shown in Figure 1 illustrated that
rice samples exhibited endothermic reactions except
for the freshly cooked and quick-frozen cooked rice,
which remarkably had no peaks depicted in the same
temperature range.
The raw rice grain curve was found to have a broad
endotherm and the peak was noticeable between 80–90
°C. Moreover, it was observed that there was a notable
shifting (decreasing) of endotherms as FTC is increased.
DISCUSSION
SEM
Structurally, starch granular appearance with two distinct
areas, smooth (Figure 1A–1) and rough (Figure 1A–2)
were observed in the SEM image cross-section (Figure
1A) of raw rice grain. These two distinct areas were
hypothesized by Buggenhout et al. (2013) as starch
granules of different orientations. While the observed
fissures and cracks in the surface of raw grain (Figure
1F) were attributed to the loss of water through the course
of maturation of the grain (Ogawa et al. 2003) and will
eventually function as water passages during cooking
(Jung et al. 2017). Moreover, the appearance of pores
on both cross-section (Figure 1B) and surface (Figure
1G) images of quick-frozen cooked rice was reported to
281
Philippine Journal of Science
Vol. 149 No. 2, June 2020
Dollete and Azanza: Properties of Freeze-thawed
Quick-frozen Cooked Rice
Figure 2. Endothermic heat flow diagram of raw, freshly cooked, quick-frozen cooked, and FTC 1, 3, 5 rice samples.
represent the emptied starch granule periphery resulted
from the leaching of starch into the water during cooking
(Yang et al. 2016; Jung et al. 2017). These dissolved
starches then form films on the surface producing a smooth
appearance (Ogawa et al. 2003; Jung et al. 2017).
On the other hand, samples subjected to continuous freezing
and thawing resulted in the prominent reappearance of
fissures and cracks on the cross-section (Figure 1C–E)
and increasing level of porosity on the surface (Figure
1H–J). It is assumed that the prominent reappearance of
fissures and cracks on the cross-section (Figure 1C–E)
were attributed to the result of moisture redistribution and
starch molecules association during retrogradation (Jung
et al. 2017), and the increase in porosity and formation
of honeycomb structures are results of surface film
removal during successive thawing through syneresis.
Similarly, the same findings of honeycombing were also
obtained by Ye et al. (2016). This honeycomb structure
may be responsible for the spongy-like texture of severely
retrograded cooked rice.
TPA
As shown in Table 1, results in all the parameters were
found to have high standard deviations and, therefore,
indicate a highly dispersed data sets. This high variability
in results may be attributed to the heterogeneity and
varying starch composition of each rice kernel samples.
However, despite the variability, statistical differentiation
was obtained.
The results showed all parameters, except for adhesiveness,
increased with repetitive FTC. The notable increase in
the 5 TPA parameters could possibly be related to the
reassociation of starch molecules during the cycles; on the
282
other hand, the decrease in adhesiveness may be attributed
to the removal of leached starches through syneresis
during thawing. The observed textural changes may
indicate the starch structural damage due to retrogradation
during FTCs (Perdon et al. 1999; Yu et al. 2010b; Wang
et al. 2013; Katekhong and Charoenrein 2014; Zambrano
et al. 2016; Trithavisup and Charoenrein 2018).
DSC
The DSC results showed that all rice samples exhibited
an endothermic heat flow (Figure 2) except for the freshly
cooked and quick-frozen cooked rice. Broad endotherm
was observed in the raw grain sample. The DSC parameter
setting used was not able to capture the complete curve of
the raw grain sample. Apparently, To and Tp were only
obtained. Tc and ∆H, which are needed for the calculation
of %DR of all other test samples, were not detected. The
broadness of the endotherm may be attributed to the intact
physical structure of raw grain, where compartments
such as subaleurone and endosperm layers are present
and may serve as natural barriers that retard heat and
water penetration (Normand and Marshall 1989) during
the analysis.
Freshly cooked and quick-frozen cooked rice samples,
on the other hand, showed no peaks. The complete
gelatinization of starch granules during cooking
(Nakazawa et al. 2014) and hindered the movement of
starch chains as a result of quick freezing (Yu et al. 2010;
Charoenrein and Udomrati 2013) may have caused the
absence of endothermic heat flow curve.
Furthermore, with repetitive FTC, notable shallowing and
shifting of endotherms towards decreasing temperature
with respect to the To and Tp were observed. This may
Philippine Journal of Science
Vol. 149 No. 2, June 2020
indicate instability and non-uniformity of the crystallites
due to the several irreversible structural and functional
transformations during freezing and thawing (Tao et
al. 2015). Also, several studies reported that there is a
disruption of crystalline and molecular order of starch
that causes the decrease of transition temperatures upon
retrogradation (Zambrano et al. 2016; Jung et al. 2017;
Zhu et al. 2017).
CONCLUSION
The study evaluated the changes in textural, structural,
and thermal properties of the quick-frozen cooked
rice. This study strongly established that repeated FTC
caused substantial deteriorative changes in the quality of
the quick-frozen cooked rice. Significant deteriorative
changes in structure, texture, and thermal properties were
prominently noted after the 3rd FTC. Therefore, quickfrozen cooked rice should be subjected to less than 3 FTC
to achieve quality cooked rice. Moreover, the three test
parameters (SEM, TPA, and DSC) were good indices for
determining the degree of structural, textural, and thermal
quality changes of the rice samples.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
The study would like to acknowledge the Department of
Science and Technology – Human Resource Development
Program and Advanced Device and Materials Testing
Laboratory – Philippine Council for Industry, Energy,
and Emerging Technology Research and Development
for the financial support, and to Mr. Rocky Marcelino
for the assistance in his field of specialization covered
in this study.
REFERENCES
BUGGENHOUT J, BRIJS K, DELCOUR J. 2013. Impact
of Starch Gelatinization and Kernel Fissuring on the
Milling Breakage Susceptibility of Parboiled Brown
Rice. Cereal Chemistry 90(5): 490–496.
CHAROENREIN S, UDOMRATI S. 2013. Retrogradation of Waxy Rice Starch Gel in the Vicinity of the
Glass Transition Temperature. International Journal
of Food Science.
CUEVAS R, PEDE V, MCKINLEY J, VELARDE O,
DEMONT M. 2016. Rice Grain Quality and Consumer
Preferences: A Case Study of Two Rural Towns in the
Dollete and Azanza: Properties of Freeze-thawed
Quick-frozen Cooked Rice
Philippines. PLoS ONE 11(3): 1–17.
JUNG K, LEE H, LEE S, KIM J. 2017. Retrogradation
of heat-gelatinized rice grain in sealed packaging: investigation of moisture relocation. Food Science and
Technology 37(1): 97–102.
KATEKHONG W, CHAROENREIN S. 2014. Effect of
rice ageing and freeze-thaw cycle on textural properties
of cooked rice (Oryza sativa L.) cv. Khao Dawk Mali
105. Internation Journal of Food Science & Technology 49: 2283–2289.
KWAK H, JEONG Y, KIM M. 2015. Influence of rice
varieties on sensory profile and consumer acceptance
for frozen-cooked rice. Emirates Journal of Food and
Agriculture 27(11): 793–800.
KWAK H, KIM H, KIM H, AHN Y, JUNG K, JEONG
H et al. 2013. Sensory Characteristics and Consumer
Acceptance of Frozen Cooked Rice by a Rapid Freezing Process Compared to Homemade and Aseptic
Packaged Cooked Rice. Preventive Nutrition and Food
Science 18(1): 67–75.
MA Y, SUN D. 2009. Hardness of Cooked Rice as Affected by Varieties, Cooling Methods and Chill Storage.
Journal of Food Process Engineering 32(2): 161–176.
NAKAZAWA F, NOGUCHI S, TAKAHASHI J, TAKADA M. 2014. Gelatinization and Retrogradation of Rice
Starch Studied by Differential Scanning Calorimetry.
Agricultural and Biological Chemistry 48(1): 201–203.
NORMAND F, MARSHALL W. 1989. Differential Scanning Calorimetry of Whole Grain Milled Rice and
Milled Rice Flour. Cereal Chemistry 66(4): 317–320.
OGAWA Y, GLENN G, ORTS W, WOOD D. 2003. Histological Structures of Cooked Rice Grain. Journal
of Agricultural and Food Chemistry 51: 7019–7023.
PERDON A, SIEBENMORGEN T, BUESCHER R,
GBUR E. 1999. Starch Retrogradation and texture of
Cooked Milled Rice During Storage. Journal of Food
Science 64(5): 828–832.
PEREZ A. 2015 (Jul 14). NFA: 'It's mishandling,
not fake rice'. Sun Star Davao. Retrieved on 06
Aug 2015 from http://www.sunstar.com.ph/davao/
local-news/2015/07/14/nfa-its-mishandling-not-fakerice-418913
RANADA P. 2015 (Aug 6). "Fake rice" just sale, contaminated rice - NFA. Rappler. Retrieved on 07 Aug 2015
from http://www.rappler.com/nation/101771-fake-ricenfa-retograded-rice?utm_source=feedburner&utm_
medium=feed&utm_campaign=Feed%3A+rappler+
%28Rappler%29
283
Philippine Journal of Science
Vol. 149 No. 2, June 2020
Dollete and Azanza: Properties of Freeze-thawed
Quick-frozen Cooked Rice
SRICHUWONG S, ISONO N, JIANG H, MISHIMA
T, HISAMATSU M. 2012. Freeze-thaw stability of
starches from different botanical sources: Correlation
with structural features. Carbohydrate Polymers 87(2):
1275–1279.
YANG L, SUN Y, LIU Y, MAO Q, YOU L, HOU J et al.
2016. Effects of Leched Amylose and Amylopectin
in Rice Cooking Liquid on Texture and Structure
of Cooked Rice. Brazilian Archives of Biology and
Technology. 59p.
TAO H, YAN J, ZHAO J, TIAN Y, JIN Z, XU X. 2015.
Effect of Multiple Freezing/Thawing Cycles on the
Structural and Functional Properties of Waxy Rice
Starch. PLoS ONE 10(5).
YE J, HU X, ZHANG F, FANG C, LIU C, LUO S. 2016.
Freeze-thaw stability of rice starch modified by Improved Extrusion Cooking. Carbohydrate Polymers.
TENG L, CHIN N, YUSOF Y. 2013. Rheological and
textural studies of fresh and freeze-thawed native sago
starch-sugar gels. II. Comparisons with other starch
sources and reheating effects. Food Hydrocolloids
(31): 156–165.
TRITHAVISUP K, CHAROENREIN S. 2018. The Effect
of Acid Treatment and Freeze-Thaw Cycle on Texture
Properties and Microstructure of Cooked Aged Rice.
Unpublished.
WANG L, XIE B, XIONG G, WU W, WANG J, QIAO
Y et al. 2013. The effect of freeze-thaw cycles on
microstructure and physicochemical properties of four
starch gels. Food Hydrocolloids 31: 61–67.
WANG X, CHAGAM K, XU B. 2018. Towards functional
starch foods with longer shelf life: Effects of inulin
and konjac glucomannan on freeze-thaw stability,
retrogradation and pasting characteristics of selected
starches: Effects fibers on characteristics of starches.
Starch Journal.
WU X, ZHANG M, ADHIKARI B, SUN J. 2017. Recent
developments in novel freezing and thawing technologies applied to foods. Critical Reviews in Food Science
and Nutrition 57(17): 3620–3631.
284
YU L, TURNER M, FITZGERALD M, STOKES J, WITT
T. 2016. Review of the effects of different processing
technologies on cooked and convenience rice quality.
Trends in Food Science & Technology.
YU S, MA Y, SUN D. 2010a. Effects of freezing rates on
starch retrogradation and textural properties of cooked
rice during storage. Food Science and Technology 43:
1138–1143.
YU S, MA Y, LIU T, MENAGER L, SUN D. 2010b. Impact of cooling rates on the staling behavior of cooked
rice during storage. Journal of Food Engineering 96:
416–420.
ZAMBRANO A, BHANDARI B, HO B, PRAKASH S.
2016. Retrogradation- Digestibility Relationship of
Selected Glutinous and Non-Glutinous Fresh and Stale
Cooked Rice. International Journal of Food Properties
19(11): 2608–2622.
ZHU H, XIE X, XU C, CHANG X, WU X, SHEN Y. 2017.
Effect of bacterial cellulose on freeze-thaw stability
of rice starch gels. Journal of Food Engineering and
Technology 6(1): 38–47.