This book bridges the gap between theory and practice, showing how a detailed definition of the shear-wave velocity (Vs) profile can be efficiently obtained using limited field equipment and following simple acquisition procedures. It... more
This book bridges the gap between theory and practice, showing how a detailed definition of the shear-wave velocity (Vs) profile can be efficiently obtained using limited field equipment and following simple acquisition procedures. It demonstrates how surface waves (used to define the Vs profile) and vibration data (used to describe the dynamic behaviour of a building) can be recorded using the same equipment, and also highlights common problems, ambiguities and pitfalls that can occur when adopting popular methodologies, which are often based on a series of simplistic assumptions. Today, most national and international building codes take into account a series of parameters aimed at defining the local seismic hazard. Sites are characterised based on the local Vs profile, and the dynamic behaviour of existing buildings is defined through the analysis of their eigenmodes. The book includes a series of case studies to help readers gain a deeper understanding of seismic and vibration data and the meaning (pros and cons) of a series of techniques often referred to as MASW, ESAC, SPAC, ReMi, HVSR, MAAM and HS. It also provides access to some of the datasets so that readers can gain a deeper and more concrete understanding of both the theoretical and practical aspects.
Software para análisis de ondas superficiales (MASW, ReMi, ESAC, MFA y RPM), modelamiento e inversión de dispersion de ondas Rayleigh y Love, análisis de atenuación de las ondas Rayleigh para estimar factores de calidad QS, determinación... more
Software para análisis de ondas superficiales (MASW, ReMi, ESAC, MFA y RPM), modelamiento e inversión de dispersion de ondas Rayleigh y Love, análisis de atenuación de las ondas Rayleigh para estimar factores de calidad QS, determinación de la frecuencia de resonancia a partir del análisis de microtremors (HVSR, método Nakamura) y modelamiento del cociente espectral H/V para mejorar el perfil VS hacia capas más profundas. Sismograma sintético e inversion de Espectro de Velocidad Completo (FVS) (no necesita de picking o interpretacion de las curvas de dispersión). Análisis (inversión conjunta con dispersión de data) de Superficie RPM frecuencia - offset (Movimiento de Partícula de ondas Rayleigh “Rayleigh-wave Particle Motion”). Análisis Back-scattering. Análisis de data MASW con espaciamiento no constante.
Metode HVSR dapat digunakan untuk estimasi frekuensi natural yang tidak bergantung sumber dan waktu (Bonnefoy-Claudet, 2006). Sedangkan untuk estimasi amplifikasi dipengaruhi oleh sumber, walaupun pengaruhnya sangat kecil (Nakamura, 2008).
The present study illustrates a series of technical aspects regarding the holistic acquisition and analysis of Rayleigh waves acquired by a single multi-component geophone. Compared with the common multi-channel and multi-offset active... more
The present study illustrates a series of technical aspects regarding the holistic acquisition and analysis of Rayleigh waves acquired by a single multi-component geophone. Compared with the common multi-channel and multi-offset active and passive methodologies, this approach requires simple and straightforward acquisition procedures and takes advantage of the joint analysis of the group-velocity spectra of both the vertical and radial components together with the Radial-to-Vertical Spectral Ratio (RVSR), i.e. the ratio between the amplitude spectra of the radial and vertical components. In this way we can fully describe the Rayleigh-wave propagation both in terms of velocities (group-velocity spectra) and relative amplitudes (RVSR) and jointly invert the data by means of a three-objective optimization scheme based on the Pareto optimality. Since the group-velocity spectra of the vertical and radial components are analyzed according to the Full Velocity Spectrum (FVS) approach, data inversion is performed without interpreting the velocity spectra in terms of dispersion curves. The results of the described methodology are assessed by considering two case studies and by comparing the retrieved shear-wave velocity profiles with the ones obtained through the analysis of the dispersion retrieved from standard active and passive multi-channel and multi-offset data also considering the Horizontal-to-Vertical Spectral Ratio (HVSR). Eventually, through a synthetic dataset, the effect of significant lateral variations is discussed with respect to the group-velocity spectra and the RVSR and RPM (Rayleigh-wave Particle Motion) curves.
Ambient noise Horizontal-to-Vertical Spectral Ratio (HVSR) technique is commonly used approach to obtain 1D models of the shear-wave velocity in the shallow surface of an investigated area. However, obtained models can have a wide margin... more
Ambient noise Horizontal-to-Vertical Spectral Ratio (HVSR) technique is commonly used approach to obtain 1D models of the shear-wave velocity in the shallow surface of an investigated area. However, obtained models can have a wide margin of uncertainty if inversions have not been appropriately constrained by detailed strati-graphic information. An application of HVSR inversion constrained by lithostrati-graphic data is presented in order to verify the effectiveness of this technique for purposes of geological and geophysical reconstruction of a sedimentary basin in a densely urbanized area. This is often the case of seismic microzonation studies, in which almost all the information derives from near surface stratigraphic drillings, since other geophysical methods are logistically difficult to carry out. In our work, we used stratigraphic constraints derived from 93 superficial boreholes whose depth rarely exceeds 30 m. In an area called "La Bandita", located in Palermo Plain (Sicily, Italy), a geophysical survey was performed by means of 55 microtrem-or recordings. Part of these was distributed randomly, while others very close to the available stratigraphic perforations. The reconstruction of the stratigraphy in the studied area has been obtained by a review of the main stratigraphic sequences and by a consequent stratigraphic three-dimensional modelling. HVSR curves have been interpreted taking care the thicknesses of the near surface successions derived by the stratigraphic 3-D model. The results , in terms of vertical profiles of the shear-wave velocity, have been interpolated to obtain a 3D seismic model. This has been used to extract basic information to identify and reconstruct the seismic bed-rock and the main geological boundaries that were not directly identifiable by means of only stratigraphic logs. It results that the bedrock is affected by a fault system that generated adjacent depressions where Quaternary successions deposited.
Determinazione del profilo Vs dall'analisi congiunta delle velocità di gruppo delle componenti Z e R (HoliSurface®) e HVSR: caso studio con commenti Determination of the Vs profile from the joint analysis of group velocities of the Z... more
Determinazione del profilo Vs dall'analisi congiunta delle velocità di gruppo delle componenti Z e R (HoliSurface®) e HVSR: caso studio con commenti
Determination of the Vs profile from the joint analysis of group velocities of the Z and R components (HoliSurface®) and the HVSR: commented case study [in Italian]
Journal of Applied Geophysics Volume 134, November 2016, Pages 112–124 Abstract. The paper intends to compare three different methodologies which can be used to analyze surface-wave propagation, thus eventually obtaining the vertical... more
Journal of Applied Geophysics Volume 134, November 2016, Pages 112–124
Abstract. The paper intends to compare three different methodologies which can be used to analyze surface-wave propagation, thus eventually obtaining the vertical shear-wave velocity (VS) profile. The three presented methods (currently still quite unconventional) are characterized by different field procedures and data processing. The first methodology is a sort of evolution of the classical Multi-channel Analysis of Surface Waves (MASW) here accomplished by jointly considering Rayleigh and Love waves (analyzed according to the Full Velocity Spectrum approach) and the Horizontal-to-Vertical Spectral Ratio (HVSR). The second method is based on the joint analysis of the HVSR curve together with the Rayleigh-wave dispersion determined via Miniature Array Analysis of Microtremors (MAAM), a passive methodology that relies on a small number (4 to 6) of vertical geophones deployed along a small circle (for the common near-surface application the radius usually ranges from 0.6 to 5 m). Finally, the third considered approach is based on the active data acquired by a single 3-component geophone and relies on the joint inversion of the group-velocity spectra of the radial and vertical components of the Rayleigh waves, together with the Radial-to-Vertical Spectral Ratio (RVSR). The results of the analyses performed while considering these approaches (completely different both in terms of field procedures and data analysis) appear extremely consistent thus mutually validating their performances. Pros and cons of each approach are summarized both in terms of computational aspects as well as with respect to practical considerations regarding the specific character of the pertinent field procedures.
Surface Wave (SW) dispersion and Horizontal-to-Vertical Spectral Ratio (HVSR) are known as tools able to provide possibly complementary information useful to depict the vertical shear-wave velocity profile. Their joint analysis might then... more
Surface Wave (SW) dispersion and Horizontal-to-Vertical Spectral Ratio (HVSR) are known as tools able to provide possibly complementary information useful to depict the vertical shear-wave velocity profile. Their joint analysis might then be able to overcome the limits which inevitably affect such methodologies when they are singularly considered.When a problem involves the optimization (i.e. the inversion) of two or more objectives, the standard practice is represented by a normalized summation able to account for the typically different nature and magnitude of the considered phenomena (thus objective functions). This way, a single cost function is obtained and the optimization problem is performed through standard solvers.This approach is often problematic not only because of the mathematically and physically inelegant summation of quantities with different magnitudes and units of measurements. The critical point is indeed represented by the inaccurate performances necessarily obtained while dealing with problems characterized by several local minima and the impossibility of a rigorous assessment of the goodness and meaning of the final result.In the present paper joint analysis of both synthetic and field SW dispersion curves and HVSR datasets is performed via the Pareto front analysis. Results show the relevance of Pareto's criterion not only as ranking system to proceed in heuristic optimization (Evolutionary Algorithms) but also as a tool able to provide some insights about the characteristics of the analyzed signals and the overall congruency of data interpretation and inversion.Possible asymmetry of the final Pareto front models is discussed in the light of relative non-uniqueness of the two considered objective functions.A tool for retrieving the Vs profile while also evaluating correctness of data interpretation and overall consistency of the analyses.►Joint analysis of surface wave dispersion curves and Horizontal-to-Vertical Spectral Ratio (HVSR) is performed in the framework of a Multi-Objective optimisation scheme based on an evolutionary algorithm. ►Symmetry of the final Pareto front models is a distinctive feature validating overall consistency of the inversion. ►Possible data interpretation errors and/or inadequate modelling criteria are put in evidence by such a (a)symmetry. ►Contribution of body waves to observe HVSR is thus discussed while analyzing a field dataset.
In this study, we analyze acceleration data using H/V spectral ratio to study characteristics of local site effect. We then, investigate reliability of HVSR method to classified the stations according Zhao (2006) scheme. The final results... more
In this study, we analyze acceleration data using H/V spectral ratio to study characteristics of local site effect. We then, investigate reliability of HVSR method to classified the stations according Zhao (2006) scheme. The final results show the convenience of HVSR scheme to classified the stations that could be used with more confidence for the stations with more records.
RAPPORTO TECNICO - Kaiserjagerstrasse (Trentino Alto Adige) Determinazione del profilo Vs da analisi congiunta delle velocità di gruppo delle componenti R e T e della curva HVSR Il presente caso studio rappresenta una sorta di trait... more
Determinazione del profilo Vs da analisi congiunta delle velocità di gruppo delle componenti R e T e della curva HVSR Il presente caso studio rappresenta una sorta di trait d'union tra il mondo MASW (da noi sempre considerato nella sua implementazione multi-componente) e il mondo HS (HoliSurface®): in fase di acquisizione sono state acquisite le classiche tracce attive multi-offset delle componenti R (radiale delle onde di Rayleigh) e T (trasversale, cioè onde di Love) [l'obiettivo era quello di effettuare l'analisi congiunta MASW in onde di Rayleigh e Love]. In fase di analisi del dato ci si è resi conto di quanto confusi fossero gli spettri della velocità di fase (cioè il classico mondo delle cosiddette MASW) e si è dunque optato per l'analisi degli spettri della velocità di gruppo computati considerando un'unica traccia, quella ad offset maggiore (naturalmente sia per la componente R che T). Tali spettri di velocità di gruppo sono stati quindi modellati (secondo l'approccio FVS - Full Velocity Spectrum) assieme alla curva HVSR media ottenuta dai dati raccolti in tre diversi punti dello stendimento. In pratica è fare una sorta di parziale analisi HS (il software HS consente di fare molto di più) in winMASW® Academy (essendo di fatto necessaria l'acquisizione di solamente 1 traccia per componente).
Joint analysis of the Z (vertical) and R (radial) group-velocity spectra jointly with the HVSR (Horizontal-to-Vertical Spectral Ratio) via HoliSurface®
In questo articolo vengono sintetizzati una serie di problemi relativi all'acquisizione ed analisi delle onde di superficie secondo una serie di tecniche (attive e passive) utili a definire le proprietà dispersive del mezzo e poter poi... more
In questo articolo vengono sintetizzati una serie di problemi relativi all'acquisizione ed analisi delle onde di superficie secondo una serie di tecniche (attive e passive) utili a definire le proprietà dispersive del mezzo e poter poi ricavare un modello del sottosuolo in termini di velocità delle onde di taglio (Vs). L'obiettivo è chiarire come dietro ad una nutrita serie di abusati acronimi (MASW, ReMi, ESAC, SPAC, MFA/FTAN, HS, MAAM eccetera) si possano celare significative ambiguità e differenze che solamente un approccio fondato sulla consapevolezza di alcuni snodi teorici può risolvere e superare.
Analogamente, vengono anche ribaditi alcuni aspetti riguardanti il rapporto spettrale H/V (HVSR) e l'analisi di dati di sismica di pozzo (VSP, Vertical Seismic Profiling), troppo spesso utilizzati in modo acritico dando per scontate una serie di assunzioni che la teoria insegna non essere sempre e comunque applicabili.
Viene inoltre puntualizzata la profonda differenza concettuale (e quindi pratica) tra analisi congiunta (pratica puntuale e quantitativa) e integrazione di dati (modalità del tutto qualitativa e approssimativa).
The present study illustrates a series of technical aspects regarding the holistic acquisition and analysis of Rayleigh waves acquired by a single multi-component geophone. Compared with the common multi-channel and multi-offset active... more
The present study illustrates a series of technical aspects regarding the holistic acquisition and analysis of Rayleigh waves acquired by a single multi-component geophone. Compared with the common multi-channel and multi-offset active and passive methodologies, this approach requires simple and straightforward acquisition procedures and takes advantage of the joint analysis of the group-velocity spectra of both the vertical and radial components together with the Radial-to-Vertical Spectral Ratio (RVSR), i.e. the ratio between the amplitude spectra of the radial and vertical components. In this way we can fully describe the Rayleigh-wave propagation both in terms of velocities (group-velocity spectra) and relative amplitudes (RVSR) and jointly invert the data by means of a three-objective optimization scheme based on the Pareto optimality. Since the group-velocity spectra of the vertical and radial components are analyzed according to the Full Velocity Spectrum (FVS) approach, data inversion is performed without interpreting the velocity spectra in terms of dispersion curves. The results of the described methodology are assessed by considering two case studies and by comparing the retrieved shear-wave velocity profiles with the ones obtained through the analysis of the dispersion retrieved from standard active and passive multi-channel and multi-offset data also considering the Horizontal-to-Vertical Spectral Ratio (HVSR). Eventually, through a synthetic dataset, the effect of significant lateral variations is discussed with respect to the group-velocity spectra and the RVSR and RPM (Rayleigh-wave Particle Motion) curves.
The Horizontal-to-Vertical Spectral Ratio (HVSR) obtained from microtremor data recorded at three test sites are analyzed in order to highlight some issues related to the computation of the SESAME criteria that define the statistical... more
The Horizontal-to-Vertical Spectral Ratio (HVSR) obtained from microtremor data recorded at three test sites are analyzed in order to highlight some issues related to the computation of the SESAME criteria that define the statistical robustness of possible peaks. In case of multiple-peak HVSR curves, it is shown that to properly assess the statistical properties of a peak and avoid the problem of multimodal data distribution, it is crucial to isolate each peak by reducing the frequency range around it. It is also shown that, while the standard approach used to obtain a homogeneous data set is represented by the removal of large-amplitude transient events before the computation of the HVSR, the removal of outlier HVSR curves can be a more effective way to obtain such a goal, being outlier HVSR curves not necessarily associated to large-amplitude transient events. It is eventually briefly discussed the problem of the proper management of multi-peak HVSR curves in microzonation studies while defining the so-called soil frequency maps. It is argued that to focus these maps just on the lowest-frequency (f0) value is questionable because higher-frequency peaks can be much more important when the local urban landscape is characterized by low-rise buildings.
The 2006 Yogyakarta earthquake caused an extensive damage to various areas of Yogyakarta regions. The damage distribution indicates the role of local site effects during the earthquake as the damage extended from Bantul Regency in... more
The 2006 Yogyakarta earthquake caused an extensive damage to various areas of Yogyakarta regions. The damage distribution indicates the role of local site effects during the earthquake as the damage extended from Bantul Regency in Yogyakarta Province to Klaten Regency in Central Java. Microzonation based on the damage distribution is then carried out using Horizontal-to-Vertical Spectral Ratio (HVSR) technique. From this technique, amplification factor and predominant frequency can be obtained and then spatially mapped. Inversion can also be conducted to the HVSR curves to infer the geological condition of the study area.