On the meteoritical gold from Kobilnik near Tolmin
Kobilnik is a 688 m high hill situated above the confluence of the Tolminka and Zadlaščica Rivers near Tolmin in the Soča region. In a paper on meteorite falls in the territory of Slovenia, written by geologists M. Jeršek and U. Herlec and published in the book Mineralna bogastva Slovenije (Mineral riches of Slovenia, 2006), is the narrative by M. Šorli about a meteorite falling on this hill around 1885 (
http://www.zobodat.at/pdf/Scopolia_Suppl_3_0480-0485.pdf). After World War II a piece of metal was found here by a metal detector, and was immediately declared as a meteorite. The geologists saw a slice of this piece, kept by the son of the finder Ciril Cuder – Tiljo. Since it consists mostly of copper, it is clear that this piece of metal did not fall from the sky.
Jeršek and Herlec were unaware of a short report on the discovery of the piece of metal on the Kobilnik hill that was published in the journal Delo in 1964. The journalist Just Perat reports that the searchers (Cuder and Nuk), originally looking for iron remains from World War I, were surprised by the discovery of an unusually formed piece of copper. They thought that it might represent a meteorite because they knew the legend about the apparitions of Virgin Mary on Kobilnik at the end of the 19th century. One small part of the copper find was sent to Ljubljana for analysis, one slice was kept by Cuder, and the biggest part, as large as a big male fist, was donated to the Tolminski muzej.
At the beginning of November 2016 I came to the conclusion that the supposed fall of a meteorite on Kobilnik around 1885 is an invention of Šorli because it is not documented at all in the newspapers of that time or in later publications. Written reports on the apparitions of the Virgin Mary in 1890, the first of which was published in 1937, also do not mention any meteorites falling on the same hill five years earlier. After the apparitions a big cross of cast iron was erected on Kobilnik, which still stands there. I have written a text with the title Kobilnik nad Zadlazom / Kobilnik above Zadlaz and uploaded it on the Academia.edu portal on November 7, 2016:
https://www.academia.edu/29718206. This stimulated Miha Mlinar, curator of Tolminski muzej, to search in the notebooks of Marija Rutar, museum’s director, from 1964. He was lucky and found three mentions of the copper piece from Kobilnik above Zadlaz, among them even a notice telling that it was detected only 5 m from the iron cross.
The staff of the Tolmin museum also succeeded in finding the “lost” major portion of the copper object on November 9, 2016. The piece is approximately one quarter of a large plano-convex ingot dating to the Ha B period. The chemical analysis performed in Ljubljana immediately after its rediscovery showed that it contained around 75 % copper, but also more than 20 % lead. Such a composition differs from those of other plano-convex ingots from the Late Bronze Age in Slovenia, which are made of copper, and corresponds to those of the cast ingots from the Ha B period. Around 80 % of these ingots contain more than 10 % lead, and some of them even more than 50 % lead (Trampuž Orel 1996, 196, Tab. 12 on p. 190).
Exactly one month after its rediscovery in the museum collections, the plano-convex ingot from Kobilnik was included in the exhibition Prapoti skozi praproti (Ancient trails through the ferns) that opened on December 9, 2016, at the Tolminski Muzej. The piece is described and illustrated in the exhibition catalogue (Mlinar, Turk 2016, 24, Kobilnik, 54, Cat. No. 22, and 86–87).
Mlinar, Turk 2016
M. Mlinar, M. Turk, Prapoti skozi praproti. Arheološka topografija dolin Tolminke in Zadlaščice, Tolmin 2016.
Trampuž Orel 1996
N. Trampuž Orel, Spectrometric Research of the Late Bronze Age Hoard Finds, in: B. Teržan (ed.), Hoards and Individual Metal Finds from the Eneolithic and Bronze Ages in Slovenia 2, Katalogi in monografije 30, Ljubljana 1996, 165–242.
The abstract was proof read by Emily Zavodny from Penn State University (USA).