View Content
View Content
View Content
Scholars' Mine
International Conference on Case Histories in (2004) - Fifth International Conference on Case
Geotechnical Engineering Histories in Geotechnical Engineering
Recommended Citation
Akili, Waddah, "Foundations over Salt-Encrusted Flats (Sabkha): Profiles, Properties, and Design Guidelines" (2004). International
Conference on Case Histories in Geotechnical Engineering. 30.
http://scholarsmine.mst.edu/icchge/5icchge/session01/30
This Article - Conference proceedings is brought to you for free and open access by Scholars' Mine. It has been accepted for inclusion in International
Conference on Case Histories in Geotechnical Engineering by an authorized administrator of Scholars' Mine. This work is protected by U. S. Copyright
Law. Unauthorized use including reproduction for redistribution requires the permission of the copyright holder. For more information, please contact
scholarsmine@mst.edu.
FOUNDATIONS OVER SALT-ENCRUSTED FLATS (SABKHA):
PROFILES, PROPERTIES, AND DESIGN GUIDELINES
Waddah Akili
Professor of Civil Engineering (Retired)
Principal, Geotechnical Engineering
Ames, Iowa-USA-50014
ABSTRACT
The evaporative and sedimentary environment that has prevailed over the southern shores of the Arabian Gulf region (eastern Saudi
Arabia, Qatar, and United Arab Emirates) has produced salt-encrusted flat areas known in Arabic as “sabkha”. Building activities on
sabkha areas have posed problems and challenges to the construction industry triggered primarily by the excessive salts present in
both the sediments and their shallow ground waters. The paper sheds light on the general setting of sabkha, including: its
development, its geology, its hydrogeology and the make up of its sediments. In general, sabkha sediments are cemented and
uncemented layers of sand /silt material, interbedded with pockets of clay and mud, where calcium carbonate and more recent
digenetic minerals (gypsum, anhydrite) serve as the principal cementing agent.
The geotechnical aspects of sabkha are addressed with particular reference to building foundations. Simplified soil profiles from
selected sabkha sites with Standard Penetration Test Results are shown. The effectiveness of some soil densification methods, as a
means of improving engineering properties of sabkha sediments, is explored. Arrival at appropriate foundation recommendations
hinges on a properly conducted site investigation, consistent with field conditions, with a geochemical component as an essential part
of the investigation. The most likely problems created by chemical changes within sabkha sediments are: settlement and strength loss
due to solution of flowing ground water, and the creation of a chemically aggressive environment in foundations.
INTRODUCTION
Salt-encrusted flat surfaces, known as “sabkha” in the Arabic- • puffy and hard surface often dotted with halite,
speaking countries, are common in the coastal and inland • lack of any vegetal cover over the surface,
areas of the Arabian Peninsula. These features are products of • highly saline ground water table (usually within two
the evaporative environment that has dominated the Arabian meters from surface), and
(Persian) Gulf area for several thousand years. See Fig. 1 for • readily visible precipitated salts (halite, anhydrite,
location of major sabkhas along the southern shores of the gypsum, and calcite) within the upper portion of the
Arabian Gulf. Conditions leading to the formation of these salt profile.
flats and their properties in the coastal and inland areas are
different, and Kinsman & Park (1969) refer to these features At most times, and in open terrain, sabkha’s hard surface is
as “coastal sabkha” and “continental sabkha” respectively. sufficiently strong and durable to serve as a substitute for
surfaced roads. Unfortunately, if the surface becomes wet due
The geomorphology, the geochemistry, and regional to occasional rainfall, flash floods or storm tides, the soluble
environmental parameters that influence the nature of sabkha salts (mainly halite)- which provide the cementation in the
sediments have been reported on by a number of investigators crust, dissolve and the sabkha becomes impassible (Ellis 1973;
(Kinsman 1969; Bush 1973; Evans et al.1969; Butler 1969; Fookes 1976).
Hsu & Seigenthaler 1969). In general terms, coastal sabkha
sediments are loose to moderately dense silt/sand material of Documented engineering type information on sabkha with
varying: size, composition, texture, and origin. Mud and clays reference to foundations and potential problems associated
are often interbedded with the sands and silts, as seams or with buildings on sabkha sediments has remained scanty. Ellis
pockets, or may be found down below towards the bottom. (1973) and Fookes (1976) have evaluated coastal sabkha in the
Some distinguishing features of sabkha deposits may include United Arab Emirates as road bases. Akili & Torrance (1981)
some or all of the following: have simulated sabkha sands in the laboratory and have
The decision on the type of foundation and the selection of an • The potential adverse reactions and chemical changes that
appropriate site improvement method is highly dependent on: may influence sediment properties and foundations
the type of sediments and their relative density; degree of embedded in them. This would invariably include the
cementation and the evaporites providing the cementation; corrosion problems in the concrete and steel, resulting
from high concentration of chlorides and sulphates in
Descript ion
sabkha brines.
Blows / 0.3 m
10 20 30 40 50
0
Fine sand (Dense) • The inability to properly assess by conventional probes
the degree of cementation of sabkha sands, particularly in
3 Calcareous silty sand
(Loose to med.) the light to moderately cemented range. Cementation has,
Depth, m
6
1977) but potentially in any porous material. Counter
9 Calcareous sand + silty measures to deal with this problem and help reduce
sand cemented in places blistering have been outlined (French et al. 1982).
12 (Med. t o very dense)
Refusal
15 • Carbonate and gypsum contents in the sabkha sediments
could be a trouble source of shallow foundations. High
Project: Sewage treatment plant, Ras Tanu ra (6 borin gs)
carbonate content (above 20 percent by total weight) may
undermine foundations by carbonate leaching. Alternate
Fig. 3. Simplified soil profile data from three selected sabkha hydration and dehydration of gypsum-rich layers under
sites typical of material encountered, showing ranges of the hot and humid conditions that characterize the sabkha
standard penetration test results (SPT) in terms of blows per environment, is usually accompanied by volume changes
0.3 m. that could contribute to differential settlement and
foundation instability.
percent fines within the uncemented layers; and percent
carbonates, chlorides, and sulphates in the brines. Some of the
• The combination of loose sands with lightly cemented
noted problems and potential safe guards may include some or
grains in sabkha sediments may be susceptible to collapse
all of the following:
upon wetting or due to an increase in vertical stress. The
collapse, referred to here, is not necessarily the sudden or
• Because sabkha sediments are highly variable materials in the catastrophic break down of soil structure, but rather
vertical and horizontal extents, chances are that these the slow type (years versus months) of relatively small
variations (layer thickness, relative density, degree of magnitude(less than 1% percent). It is therefore highly
cementation, and type and percentage salts in sediments) recommended that the collapse potential of the sabkha site
would manifest themselves in extreme variations in be addressed.
compressibility characteristics. Precautionary measures
and safeguards during site exploration, design, and
6
... Refusal
the improvement work. The presence of undetected silts and
RQD=0.37 clay pockets, cemented sand-silt layers, and thin gypsum
Light gray porous RQD=0.17 Pre-treat ment
8 limestone with RQD=0.07
layers tend to inhibit densification of the cohesionless material
shells Post -treatment in sabkha. A review of a number of cases suggests that there
10
SPT before may be a definable maximum level of improvement that could
treatment be achieved for a particular soil. It has been suggested that this
12 S tatic Dutch Cone
limit is equivalent to a cone penetration resistance (qc ) of
about 150 kg/cm2 (Leonards et al. 1980). The data presented
Fig. 4. Simplified soil profile, SPT and static Dutch Cone test in Fig. 5 of pre- and post-treatment with dynamic compaction
results before and after vibroflotation on a sabkha site in of a selected sabkha site, show maximum improvement in
Rahima, eastern Saudi Arabia. value of SPT of 20 blows/0.3m, in qc of 160 kg/cm2, in
Pressuremeter limit pressure of 22 kg/cm2, and in
Vibro-replacement (stone column) Most stone column Pressuremeter modulus of 350 kg/cm2. The sediments
installations are accomplished using the vibro-replacement densified in this case were relatively clean sands. Based on the
method in a manner similar to vibroflotation. A cylindrical field data (Fig.5), the level of densification achieved appears
vertical hole is made by a vibrating probe penetrating by satisfactory.
means of jetting action and under its own weight. Gravel
and/or gravel-sand backfill is dumped into the hole in
increments of 0.4 to 0.8 m and compacted by the probe which SITE INVESTIGATION
simultaneously displaces the material radially into the soft (or
loose) soil. Column diameters are usually in the range of 0.6 to To aid in planning of ground investigation of a sabkha site,
1.0 m. Stone columns are placed in a grid pattern with center preliminary information on the geology, geomorphology, and
to center spacing of 1.5 to 3.5 m. The column should extend brine chemistry of the specific location, should be made
into a firmer stratum below. A blanket of sand and/or gravel, available. Relevant information under this category may
0.3m or more in thickness, is usually placed over the top. This include:
blanket has two functions; it acts as a drainage layer, and aids i. The land forming processes: past processes, present
in distributing stress resulting from structures above. Useful processes, and those that may be controlling after
guidelines on the application of this method are presented by construction and development of the proposed site;
ASCE Committee on Placement and Improvement of Soils ii. Predominant sediments and whether marine or
(ASCE, 1978). The vibro-replacement method has been used continental: types of sediments and their
on several sabkha sites in conjunction with vibroflotation characteristics, bedrock/ hard pan information, and
application. Reports made available to the author appear buried algal mats, if any;
favorable, and tend to support its use with caution. iii. Salts in sediments: their type, amounts, presence of
continuous and discontinuous cemented layers,
Dynamic compaction Soil compaction by heavy tamping, particularly gypsum layers;
termed dynamic compaction, involves repeated dropping of iv. Groundwater flow characteristics: gradient, potential
heavy weights onto the ground surface. Pounders range from 6 water ingress, capillary zone, surface water courses,
to 25 tons, are dropped repeatedly from heights ranging from and water table fluctuations; and,
10 to 20 m. The repeated application of high energy impacts at v. Groundwater chemistry: major ions and their
the same impact points, causes densification/compaction of concentration, potential reactions, and the impact of
the soil mass to depths ranging from 3 to 8 m. Energy is construction and site development on: precipitation,
typically applied in several passes, with the initial pass on a 3 dissolution, and crystal growth.
2
Table 1. A proposed four-stage geotechnical investigation for
a sabkha terrain
Depth, m
3
Stage Purpose Major Tasks
I To plan subsequent • Desk study
4 Preliminary stages • Walk over survey
• Identify land forms and
To determine type
controlling processes
II and extent of
5
• Obtain preliminary in-
Dut ch
Defining required field and
Dut ch depth information through
Cone Cone lab work
6
open pits
• Mapping including:
Lim it P re s s ure , kg/c m 2 De f. M o dulus , kg/c m 2 topography, outcrops,
0 10 20 30 0 10 0 200 300 400 hydrology, water gradient
To obtain all field
0
• Perform fieldwork by:
d e and lab data at a
boreholes, sampling, in-
d
& e III standard, justified
situ testing
1 Main by size and
Using Menard
complexity of • Perform lab tests: strength,
pressuremeter compressibility,
project
2 conductivity, etc.
• Properties and
Avg. value for
Depth, m
classification
all tests before
3
• Chemical testing of soils
improve ment
and brines
4 Avg. value for Addressing • Assessing chemical
all tests after chemical stability due to
IV
improve ment equilibrium of construction and
Auxiliary
5 sediments and development
brines • Effect of leaching on
stability and strength
6
Fig. 5. Test results before and after dynamic compaction of a Field tests including: plate bearing tests, CBR tests,
sabkha site in Rahima, eastern Saudi Arabia. Pressuremeter tests, foundation and embankment loading tests,
dewatering, seismic surveys, etc. have been used, with varying
Because the soil-structure, and therefore stability of layers degrees of success, to investigate sites of major structures or to
within the sabkha profile, are dependent on chemical generate useful parameters for foundation design over sabkha
cementation due to the presence of salts (chlorides, sulphates, sites. Proper planning and relatively long time (one to two
carbonates); it is useful to identify those layers that appear years) are usually required to generate useful field data that
sensitive to the presence of salts versus those that are less could be relied upon.
affected. Therefore, it is imperative that chemical testing be
carried out (Stage IV) to assess: type, percentage, and manner When examining the behavior of granular materials in sabkha,
in which these salts are present within soil grains. it is important to distinguish between stable and metastable
structures. The former derive their strength predominantly
Examination of relatively large exposures in open test pits, from particle interlock, while the latter are dependent to a
trenches, or through large diameter shallow borings, will aid in large degree on weak cementation bonds derived largely from
delineating sediments and layering, help identify crystalline the presence of sulphates, chlorides, and/or carbonates