Commercial Buildings – Chilled water systems efficiency

By Jens Nørgaard, Senior Application Manager, Grundfos, Denmark

Introduction: Table of content

 Background: ................................................................ 2
Energy use is the single largest operating expense in
System Efficiency ........................................................ 3
commercial office buildings, representing
approximately one-third of typical operating budget. Chilled water schemes................................................ 3
On an average 30-40% of energy in a commercial Primary pumping system ............................................ 3
building is consumed by HVAC systems. By becoming
Secondary pumping system ....................................... 3
more energy efficient in HVAC, commercial buildings
can reduce operating expenses, increase property Chilled Water systems ................................................ 4
asset value, and enhance the comfort of their tenants. Increased efficiency .................................................... 4
*(http://www.bluehatmechanical.com/save-on-the-biggest-use-of-power-in-your-building/) Traditional solution .................................................... 5
Primary-secondary...................................................... 6
Primary-secondary-tertiary ........................................ 7
Purpose: Variable Primary Flow Systems .................................. 7
The purpose of this white paper is to look at chilled Design of VPF systems ................................................ 8
water systems design, and to describe ways in which Conclusions: ................................................................ 9
efficient systems can contribute to lower energy
consumption and improvements to the environment
by reducing pollution and the CO2 emissions that
contribute to global warming.

1
 and selecting the quantity, type and
Background: configuration of chillers based upon the
Modern societies are becoming increasingly expected load profile are other factors
urbanised, at the same time as mankind is that influence efficient design.
becoming aware of the global environmental  Efficient components - Chillers, pumps,
impact our cities are having on the planet. The fans and motors should all be selected
problems thus created are complex and inter- for their stand-alone as well as systemic
connected. efficiency. Also consider premium
efficiency motors, pumps with high
In developing economies, air conditioning -which efficiency at the designed operating
was previously seen as a luxury- has now become condition, chillers that are efficient at
a necessity due to changing climatic conditions. both full and partial loads.
People have started using air conditioning in  Proper installation, commissioning and
their daily lives and expect the same indoor operation - A chiller plant that meets
comfort in the places they visit. As we know, air these first two criteria can still waste a
conditioning is normally the most energy lot of energy and provide poor comfort
intensive application in any establishment, be it a to building occupants, if it is not installed
commercial building or an industrial process or operated properly.
requirement.

Faced with global warming and dwindling energy

resources, the design of energy-efficient air
conditioning systems is of prime importance to
any designer, as it has a huge bearing on the
operating expenses of the building throughout its
life cycle. This requires a holistic approach,
including building orientation, selection of facade
glazing, construction materials, shading, thermal
mass, lighting etc. Above all, the air-conditioning
system and its components.

An efficient chiller plant has the following

characteristics:
 An efficient design concept - Selection of
an appropriate design concept that is
responsive to changing operating Energy consumption break down in a typical commercial
conditions is essential to achieving building
efficiency. Variable flow pumping
systems for large campus applications,

2
System Efficiency (either upstream or downstream of the chiller),
provided the pump satisfies the following
In common with all types of pumping
conditions:
applications, system efficiency for HVAC systems
such as air cooling in commercial buildings
 Maintains the minimum dynamic
depends on balancing the piped network with
pressure head (inlet pressure) at the heat
the other components.
exchangers (evaporator coil) at the
chiller. If the recommended inlet
While chillers and cooling towers are large
pressure is not high enough at these
contributors to chilled water performance, a
components, proper flow will not be
primary player in determining how well a plant
established through them
performs is the efficiency of the chilled water
distribution system. To appreciate the various  Accommodates the total pressure (static
plus dynamic head) on system
hydraulic considerations associated with
planning chilled water and how they influence components such as chiller’ s evaporator,
system performance, it is important to valves etc.,
understand how technology and design  Meets the minimum net positive suction
challenges over the years have influenced head requirements. That is the system
today’s approach to chilled water pumping. inlet pressure at the pump must be
positive and high enough for the pump
Basically, each piping scheme in air conditioning to operate properly.
application is classified according to its use. One
is meant for distribution of chilled water from
the chiller plant to the conditioned space. While
the other is to dissipate the heat from the chiller
into the atmosphere through cooling towers. i.e.,
condenser water pumping schemes.

In this white paper, we shall discuss in brief the

various schemes generally employed in
commercial buildings HVAC system.

Chilled water schemes

A chilled water pumping scheme is one by which
chilled water is circulated throughout the
building or through cooling coils in air handling Grundfos TPD twin pumps used in a medium size chilled
units (AHU) to provide space cooling. water plant
It basically consists of production and
distribution loops. Production loop takes care of Secondary pumping system
chilled water production in the plant which Here the main objective to distribute the chilled
consists of chillers, primary chilled water pumps, water to the various cooling coils overcoming the
control valves and accessories. The distribution frictional resistance offered by the pipes, valves
loop takes care of pumping water to the and bends in the entire network. The distribution
changing demands of the space through a system may contain other components such as
network of pipes, valves and cooling coils. expansion tanks, control valves, balancing valves,
check valves, air separators etc.
Primary pumping system
The main objective of the primary pump is to These pumps are usually configured in headered
circulate chilled water within the production fashion, for system redundancy.
loop. This pump is typically located anywhere

3
Chilled Water systems

Schematic of a primary / secondary / tertiary chilled water system

A central chilled water system (shown above)  Controls loop - Integrates the complete
generally consists of the following five sub- system to ensure that it works as
systems as individual heat-transferring loops of intended. All the sub systems: Chillers,
circulating water: pumps, cooling towers, fan coil units,
 Refrigeration loop - Consists of a chiller cooling tower fans and water treatment
in which a refrigerant changes its state at systems are all integrated into a single
various stages to either absorb or reject system for easy monitoring and control.
heat from the evaporator and condenser
respectively.
 Heat rejection loop - Consists of cooling Increased efficiency
towers, condenser water pumps and Possibilities for optimizing the energy
water treatment systems. This loop is consumption of a central air conditioning plant
used to reject the heat from the hot lie mainly with chillers, fans and pumps in the
refrigerant into the atmosphere either order of their contribution. Modern chillers from
through radiators (in the case of air renowned chiller manufacturers have evolved
cooled systems) or through cooling over the years and offer sophisticated designs,
towers wherein water removes heat delivering better energy performance over their
from the condenser coil and ejects it to previous designs.
the atmosphere.
 Chilled water loop - Consists of Variable speed chillers utilize more efficient
circulation pumps, which carry the operation by offering more adaptable chillers
chilled water from the chiller to the where compressor speed is varied relative to
various distribution systems like Fan Coil plant load. In 1998, for example, minimum full
Units (FCU) or Ceiling Suspended Units load efficiency (COP) for a 1800 kW centrifugal
(CSU) or Air Handling Units (AHU) or chiller was around 4.7, whereas building owners
Radiant Cooling Panels (RCP) today are aiming towards a COP of 6.4 for the
 Air side loop - Consists of a low side (air whole plant (including pumps, fans and
side) distribution network like Fan Coil ancillaries).
Units (FCU) or Ceiling Suspended Units
(CSU) or Air Handling Units (AHU).
Centrifugal fans are used in AHUs which There are a great many details associated with
are VFD (Variable Frequency Drive) designing an efficient chiller plant; however, the
driven based temperature requirement following are some of the most essential ones to
of conditioned space. be considered:

4
  Focus on chiller part load efficiency: Peak water from 35 °C to 30 °C when the
loads in most commercial buildings are a ambient wet bulb temperature is 26 °C.
rarity, and it is imperative to look for Assumption of wet bulb conditions can
chillers which offer the best part load lead to improper sizing of a cooling
efficiency. tower.
 Design efficient pumping systems: Design  Integrated chiller controls: Modern
of variable volume pumping systems by chillers provide a wealth of detailed
incorporating variable speed drives on operating data which can be used to
the pumps can result in significant make decisions about how to operate
savings in the operating costs of the the rest of the system.
plant. Chiller plants which allow varying  Commission the system: Commissioning
flow through chillers use less space, a HVAC system, (i.e., functionally testing
fewer components and reduce pumping it under all anticipated operating
energy to nearly 40%, compared to the conditions to ensure the system
conventional constant flow approach. performs as intended) is also vital as it
 Proper selection of cooling tower: Proper establishes a reliable basis for measuring
sizing and control of cooling towers is performance and any improvements in
essential to efficient chiller operation. A system efficiency and reliability.
tower may be rated to cool 800 m3/h of

performance of the main chiller plant caused by

Traditional solution low ΔT.
Note that chillers will control only the leaving
Traditionally, chilled water is delivered through a temperature from evaporator coil, whereas it is
simple direct-primary, constant flow pumping the cooling coil’s performance which will
scheme. Here, chilled water is pumped at a influence the temperature of the chilled water
constant flow rate which is independent of the returning to the plant room, and this has a large
cooling load. During part load conditions, which bearing on the ΔT of the plant.
occurs most of the time, three way control
valves at cooling coils are used to bypass the
chilled water back to the return line. Chilled
water mixes with return water from the cooling
coils and this results in lower chilled water return
Implications of low ΔT, example:
temperature to plant. This lower return water
temperature reduces the temperature
The designed performance of a chilled water
differential (ΔT) across the chillers.
system is 1.5 MW at a design ΔT of 6 °C.
If the system is suffering from low ΔT
syndrome, the cooling capacity will be
reduced.

If the real ΔT is only 2 C, the systems cooling

capacity is reduced with two thirds.
The performance of the system is now only
0.5 MW.

Constant flow primary pumping system

This method of chilled water pumping results in a

significant waste of energy and a loss of

5
Primary-secondary
A primary-secondary pumping scheme divides
the chilled water system into two distinct circuits
that are hydraulically separated by a de-coupler
(neutral bridge). In primary/secondary systems,
chilled water flows through the chiller primary
loop at a constant flow rate, whereas in
secondary loop, flow rate is varied according to
Primary-secondary pumping system
the load. The hydraulic independence of each
loop prevents variable flow in the secondary loop The decrease in flow from the secondary loop
from influencing the constant flow in the primary means the chilled water will flow from the supply
loop. side to the return side to maintain the constant
volume through the chillers. This happens since
the production loop (primary side) flow is greater
than the distribution loop (secondary side) flow.
Similarly, when the load increases at the space
area, zone temperature increases which makes
the 2 way valves to open more. This reduces
differential pressure across the cooling loads,
causing the secondary chilled water pumps to
ramp up.

In these changing load patterns a hydraulic de-

coupler located between the suction headers of
the secondary and primary pumps acts as a
balancing line which allows chilled water to flow
Secondary pumps in a large stadium chilled water plant in either direction (from supply to return and vice
versa). Without this de-coupler line, both the
The speeds of the secondary pumps are primary and secondary pumps would be in series,
determined by the controller measuring making the system unbalanced and causing
differential pressure (DP) across the supply and operational problems.
return mains of the chilled water loop or across
the most critical load in the pipe network.
Primary – secondary variable flow systems are
more efficient than constant flow systems,
because unnecessary pumping is avoided in the
distribution loop, resulting in better energy
efficiency.

During part-load conditions, the two way valves

begin to close, causing an increase in system
differential pressure which is detected by a DP
(differential pressure) sensor. Subsequently the
secondary pump control panel reduces the pump
speed and flow of the secondary pump to match Primary-secondary-tertiary pumping system
the load requirement.

6
Primary-secondary-tertiary

When the buildings to be served are distributed

over a larger area, such as a university campus,
so-called “primary-secondary-tertiary” schemes
help to reduce the pump pressures in the system.
By splitting the system head between the
secondary and tertiary pumps, excessive
pressurization in zones which do not need high
pressure is reduced.

In these systems, all cooling coils or building

loops may be served by a third set of pumps –
tertiary pumps.

These distributed pumping systems are well

suited for large, multiple zone buildings or
multiple building systems with central energy
plants. These systems are actually a collection of
smaller systems operating independently of each
other, but all of them using the same distribution
piping and the central chiller plant.

Tertiary pumps are sized for requirements of the

specific cooling coil alone. Pump head is also
calculated only to overcome the frictional loss in Tertiary pumping system
the tertiary loop.
Each of the tertiary pumps has its own pump
controller, responding quickly to any changes in
loop pressure caused by fluctuating demand.
These pumps are usually speed-controlled and
when used as part of a suitable building
connection strategy, they work in coordination
with speed-controlled central plant distribution
(secondary) pumps.

Variable Primary Flow Systems

Recall that the primary loop relies on maintaining
a constant flow through the chiller. This is a
challenge to engineers who are conscious of the
need to make energy savings. It would make
sense to employ modern pumps with variable
frequency drives which could provide the
following benefits:
 Low energy cost due to variable flow
(Chilled water is pumped only to the
requirement of the load). Variable primary flow system
 Reduced operating cost.

7
  Better ability to tolerate below design
chilled water temperature differentials.
 Less capital cost, since secondary pumps
and its accessories are eliminated
altogether.
With the advent of more sophisticated control
systems and improvements in chiller technology
over the past few decades, variable primary flow
(VPF) systems are widely used in the air
conditioning industry. It provides immediate cost
savings, as it eliminates secondary distribution
pumps, associated pipes and accessories from
the circuit.
Variable primary flow system with bypass valve
Here the primary pump is sized for circulating
chilled water through the chiller evaporator coil Minimum flow bypass valve
and further to the cooling coil loads In VPF systems, a bypass valve may be fitted in
the common line. It is via a controller connected
to a flow meter in the water loop. When the
chilled water flow is above the evaporator’s safe
Design of VPF systems minimum flow, the valve is normally closed. If
the cooling load requirement decrease to a level
There are certain limitations within which where the flow is less than the evaporator safe
variable primary flow systems should be minimum flow, excess pumping is taking place in
designed: the chiller plant.
 In order to reduce the risk for freezing, In such a scenario, the amount of flow that is in
chiller manufacturers recommend a safe excess to the cooling load requirement needs to
minimum evaporator flow beyond which be bypassed back to the chiller plant. Only in
flow should not be reduced such instances, bypass valve opens up
 Velocity of flow through evaporator to be proportionately to divert the volume of chilled
maintained between 1 and 3 m/s contain water back to the chiller plant.
tube erosion. An example, say if the cooling coils need only 12
 Rate of change of flow through the m3/h whereas the minimum safe recommended
chiller should be as described by the evaporator coil flow in the active chiller itself is
respective chiller manufacturer 20 m3/h, the excess 8 m3/h is diverted through
 Chillers in parallel configuration are to be bypass line.
of equal capacity
 System should be tolerant on
temperature variations Selection of bypass valve
Selecting an appropriate valve actuator is critical
Evaporator flow and velocity limitations to ensure the proper functioning of the bypass
Every chiller manufacturer recommends the function. One which maintains a linear
minimum flow range which can be pumped relationship between the valve position and flow
through the evaporator coil. Turn down ratio rate will do.
depends on chiller type also. Normally the
minimum evaporator coil flow is 40 to 60% of the Can bypass valves be avoided?
design flow. Bypass valves in VPF systems may be avoided
Any operation of the chiller less than the safe when:
minimum flow will result in ice formation in the
evaporator potentially damaging the equipment.  The building load is constant
 The building load is never is never below
the evaporator safe minimum flow,
which is typically 40 to 60 % of the
nominal load.

8
  A by-pass pump is substituting the When the flow through the chiller is well above
bypass valve. the minimum flow, the pump is stopped.

The solution with a Grundfos TPE2 pump as the Introducing a bypass pump in a variable primary
by-pass pump: flow system will substitute a bypass valve, a
A Grundfos TPE2 pump can be used to maintain a controller and flow meter. The pump is self-
minimum water flow rate. The pump is controlled and does not require any additional
controlled in constant ΔP mode ensuring that a controller or flow meter. Hence, in most cases
constant pressure and hence flow is maintained there will be an initial cost, commissioning and
over the chiller evaporator. maintenance saving connected to this
installation.

Set-up a TPE2 pump for this application is

discussed further in the one-pager “Chilled
water. By-pass pump control” and related
commissioning paper.

Variable primary flow system with bypass pump

Conclusions:
Chilling water systems are a key part of HVAC solutions for commercial buildings, and their
installation and continuous operation represent quite a significant operating expense. A variety of
suitable system designs, each tailored to fit specific building layouts and load requirements can
provide efficient, comfortable living conditions at the lowest possible price.
Variable primary flow systems are the one of the simplest piping schemes, none the less it is a
very efficient one because the risk of excess pumping is eliminated. This may be achieved either
by installing a bypass pump or valve. However, installing a bypass pump will in most cases lead to
a lower system life time cost.

9
www.grundfos.com
Tel: +45 87 50 14 00
DK-8850 Bjerringbro
Poul Due Jensens Vej 7
GRUNDFOS Holding A/S
10
The name Grundfos, the Grundfos logo, and be think innovate are registered trademarks owned by Grundfos Holding A/S or Grundfos A/S, Denmark. All rights reserved worldwide.