Current Status and Species Diversity of Seagrass in Panjang Island, Banten
Current Status and Species Diversity of Seagrass in Panjang Island, Banten
Current Status and Species Diversity of Seagrass in Panjang Island, Banten
Abstract
Damage to seagrass beds in Panjang Island, Banten, has increased every year. The most significant decline
occurred at an interval of 2000-2005 with a decrease of about 22.9 ha. Seagrass damage continued to increase
at the year between 1989-2002 as a result of natural stone mining and coastal reclamation activities to become
industrial areas and ports. The objective of this study was to determine the characteristics of the species and
current status of seagrass communities in Panjang Island waters, Banten. Analysis of seagrass data included
identification of species, frequency, density, percent coverage, and important value index. Based on these results,
it was found three species of seagrass on Panjang Island, Banten, including species of Enhalus acoroides,
Cymodocea serrulata, and Syrongodium isoetifolium. The percentage of seagrass coverage at five different
research stations, the highest percentage of seagrass coverage was at station IV with a percentage of coverage of
48.94% and the lowest coverage was obtained at station V of 10.28%. The calculation of the importance value
index (INP) of seagrass in Panjang Island waters, Banten, showed that the highest INP value was found in the
Cymodocea serrulata seagrass species which was 41.47 and the lowest was found in the Syrongodium
isoetifolium seagrass species which was 16.81. PCA analysis was also conducted to determine the relationship of
seagrass density with chemical physics parameters. The results obtained showed the condition of seagrass
ecosystems in Panjang Island waters, Banten, which was at a level of moderate to severe damage. The results of
PCA analysis showed that water temperature, nitrate concentration, DO, and TSS greatly influenced the density of
seagrass in these waters.
16 Current Status and Species Diversity of Seagrass (Y. Sugianti and Mujiyanto)
ILMU KELAUTAN: Indonesian Journal of Marine Sciences March 2020 Vol 25(1):15-22
from the coast to the edge of the coast. Station seagrass in their community (Brower et al., 1998).
determination and transect placement are adapted The higher the INP value of a species relative to
from the Seagrass Net monitoring method (Short et other species, the higher the role of species in the
al., 2004), where locations have seagrass community. INP is calculated using the following
communities with a homogeneous or nearly equal formula:
percentage of closure, communities with relatively
even seagrass closure, far from human disturbance INP = KR + FR + PR
or destructive sources such as port and location
easily accessible. Note: INP= Important value index; FR= Relative
frequency; KR= Relative density; PR= Relative
Data were collected during three transects closure
(development of research method from Hartati et al.,
2012), with a length of 50 m each and the distance Water quality analysis was carried out
between one transect, and the other was 50 m, so descriptively. The relationship of seagrass density
the area was 50 x 100 m2. The quadratic frame was with chemical-physical parameters were analyzed
placed on the right side of the transect with the using Principal Component Analysis (PCA) by
distance between one square and the other being STATISTICA software.
25 m, so the total square of each transect is 3.
Transects starting point was placed at a distance of
5-10 m from the first time the seagrass was found Results and Discussion
from the direction of the beach (Sugianti, 2016).
Based on the results of the study, it was
Parameters were done in-situ such as
found three species of seagrass on Panjang Island,
temperature, brightness, salinity, pH, and the rest
Banten, including species of Enhalus acoroides,
was done ex-situ, which was then analyzed in the
Cymodocea serrulata, and Syrongodium
laboratory. Data analysis of the seagrass included
isoetifolium. Seagrass species found in these waters
identification of species, frequency of seagrass
were native to Indonesia (www.iucnredlist.org).
species, calculating the density, percentage of
Seagrass communities in Panjang Island waters
seagrass coverage, and important value index
were classified as mixed communities consisting of
(Leefan et al., 2013; Adli et al., 2016). From these
1-5 species of seagrasses (Hartati et al., 2012). The
results, it can be seen that the level of seagrass
species found compared with studies in 2008-2010
conditions at a particular location within a particular
showed that there had been a reduction and change
time was assessed based on the standard criteria
in the number of seagrass species. Zulkarnain’s
for seagrass damage using a percentage of
study (2009) found 4 species of seagrasses,
coverage area based on the Decree of the Minister
including Enhalus acoroides, Cymodocea serrulata,
of Environment No. 200/2004.
Thalassis hemprichii, and Halophila spinullosa. In
Frequency, density and percentage of contrast to seagrass found in 2010, where three
seagrass species coverage is calculated using seagrass species were found, including Enhalus
formula from English et al., 1997. To see the acoroides, Cymodocea serrulata, and Syrongodium
condition of seagrass from the value of the amount isoetifolium. Among the three seagrass species
of coverage ranging from 0-100%, it can be found in Pulau Panjang waters, Banten, the highest
categorized as follows: 0-25 = Rare; 26-50 = number of species (Fi) and relative frequency (FR)
Medium; 51-75 = Dense; 76-100 = Very dense. The was Cymodocea serrulata with Fi of 0.77 and FR of
level of seagrass beds damage greatly determines 15.4. While the lowest was Syrongodium isoetifolium
the condition of its ecosystem (Poedjirahajoe et al., seagrass with Fi of 0.11 and FR of 2.2.
2013). To determine the level of damage, it requires
standard criteria that apply in all regions in The frequency of seagrass species presence
Indonesia. Seagrass status according to Minister of in all research locations (Table 2) showed that the
Environment Decree Number 200/2004 concerning species of Cymodocea serrulata had the highest
standard criteria for damage and guidelines for value in Panjang Island waters, Banten. This showed
determining seagrass status based on seagrass that the species was found in almost all quadratic
cover is divided into three criteria, namely observations and was able to adapt to disturbed
rich/healthy with closure >60%, less rich/less environmental conditions. The chance of finding a
healthy with closure of 30-59%, and poor <29,9%. seagrass species usually depends on the type of
substrate in the field because each seagrass
Important Value Index (INP) species has a preference for different types of
substrate. The disrupted condition of Panjang Island
The important value index (INP) is used to waters due to surrounding activities caused the
calculate and predict the role of each species of existing seagrass species to be able to adapt to their
Current Status and Species Diversity of Seagrass (Y. Sugianti and Mujiyanto) 17
ILMU KELAUTAN: Indonesian Journal of Marine Sciences March 2020 Vol 25(1):15-22
environment. Cymodocea serrulata was a seagrass Based on the calculation of the importance
species that quickly recovered after disruption (Short value index (INP) of seagrass in Panjang Island
and Waycott, 2010). waters, Banten, the results obtained were showed in
Table 4, where the calculation results showed that in
Seagrass density on Panjang Island, Banten, these waters, the highest INP value was found in the
ranged from 80-856 ind.m-2, where the highest species of Cymodocea serrulata seagrass species
density was found at station III and lowest at station which was 41.47 and the lowest was found in the
V (Figure 2). Seagrass with the highest density was Syrongodium isoetifolium seagrass species which
Cymodocea serrulata. The density of each species was 16.81. The same seagrass species may have a
was different, Enhalus acoroides species ranged different INP value although it is always present in
from 21.5-47 ind.m-2, Cymodocea serrulata ranged all research locations. A high INP value is highly
from 56.75-101 ind.m-2, while Syrongodium related to water conditions and substrate type.
isoetifolium ranged from 69-75 ind.m-2.
Important value index (INP) shows the
In addition to the high frequency of its importance of a seagrass species and its role in the
presence, the density of Cymodocea serrulata community, the diversity of INP values indicates the
seagrass species was also highest during the influence of the environment where the seagrass
observation. Seagrass species with high density grows like nutrient concentration and substrate
usually also have a high frequency of presence and conditions. The dominant species has a large
coverage, generally the contribution of seagrass productivity where its existence will be an indicator
species (density and biomass) in a community tends that the community is in a suitable and supportive
to be dominated by one or several species only habitat (Rustam et al., 2015). Cymodocea serrulata
(Terrados et al., 1997). This is thought to be related species can grow on muddy sand substrate or sand
to the ability to adapt of a seagrass species to its of coral fragments in tidal areas. During observation,
environmental conditions. the condition of the substrate in Panjang Island
waters was muddy sand (Sugianti, 2016). Based on
For the percentage of seagrass coverage at the standard criteria for damage to seagrass of
five different research stations, the highest Decree of Minister of Environment Number 200 of
percentage of seagrass coverage was at station IV 2004, seagrass ecosystems on Panjang Island were
with a percentage of coverage of 48.94% and the at a moderate level of damage.
lowest coverage was obtained at station V of
10.28% (Table 3). Seagrass coverage could describe Physical-chemical parameter conditions will
the level of seagrass coverage by each species of directly or indirectly affect all life forms of aquatic
seagrass or seagrass community. The percentage of organisms. Physical-chemical characteristics of a
seagrass coverage is not always linear with the high habitat will support a structure of the biota
number of species or the high density of species community that lives in it, including seagrass
because the observed coverage is the leaf blade communities (Purba et al., 2015). During the
while the species density seen is the number of observation, the value of physical parameters in the
stands (Minerva et al., 2014). seagrass ecosystem of Panjang Island waters,
Table 2. Frequency of seagrass species presence in the research location of Panjang Island, Banten
Location
No Seagrass Species
St. I St. II St. III St. IV St. V
1 Enhalus acoroides 0.68 0.54 0.57 0.58
2 Cymodocea serrulata 0.32 0.77 0.46 0.32 0.42
3 Syrongodium isoetifolium 0.23 0.11
Total 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00
Table 3. Percentage of seagrass coverage (%) in research location of Panjang Island, Banten
18 Current Status and Species Diversity of Seagrass (Y. Sugianti and Mujiyanto)
ILMU KELAUTAN: Indonesian Journal of Marine Sciences March 2020 Vol 25(1):15-22
120
80
60
40
20
0
St.I St. II St. III St. IV St. V
Research Station
Table 4. Importance value index (INP) of seagrass species in research location of Panjang Island, Banten
Location
No Seagrass Species
St. I St. II St. III St. IV St. V
1 Enhalus acoroides 27.60 17.81 30.24 19.01
2 Cymodocea serrulata 33.48 41.47 40.09 27.36 16.81
3 Syrongodium isoetifolium 27.03 16.81
Table 5. Physical-chemical parameter values during the observation in the seagrass ecosystem on Panjang Island, Banten
Banten, such as turbidity ranged from 3.56-53.91 Principal component analysis (PCA) showed
NTU, water temperature ranged from 29.22- that information related to the environment in
30.34°C, salinity ranged from 21.50-35.89‰, pH Panjang Island waters seagrass ecosystem, Banten,
ranged from 7.93-9.17, and TSS ranged from 19.85- was centered on 2 main axes (F1 and F2) with
111.00 mg.L-1. Whereas for chemical parameters contributions of 53.70% and 25.85% (Figure 3a.).
such as DO, it ranged from 5.97-8.70 mg.L-1, COD PCA analysis showed the grouping of stations based
ranged from 90.03-176.00 mg.L-1, nitrate ranged on differences in the values of physical and
from 0.13-1.11 mg.L-1, and Phosphate ranged from chemical parameters between stations. Figure 3b.
0.00-0.67 mg.L-1 (Table 5.). Some physical and showed that the density of seagrass in Panjang
chemical parameters had exceeded the seawater Island waters was strongly influenced by the
quality standard for marine biota, indicating that parameters of water temperature, nitrate, DO, and
there had been a change in the condition of the TSS. Each observation station was characterized by
aquatic environment due to input from surrounding specific physical-chemical parameters in the same
activities. quadrant. There were 3 main factors of PCA analysis
Current Status and Species Diversity of Seagrass (Y. Sugianti and Mujiyanto) 19
ILMU KELAUTAN: Indonesian Journal of Marine Sciences March 2020 Vol 25(1):15-22
4a. 4b.
Figure 3. Relationship of several water quality parameters and seagrass density in Panjang Island waters, Banten
Table 6. Diversity of principal component analysis (PCA) data in research location of Panjang Island, Banten
that were able to explain the diversity of data around to the Decree of Minister of Environment No. 51/
93.00% where factors 1, 2, and 3 described the 2004, because if DO concentration was low in the
diversity of data respectively of 53.70%, 79.55%, waters, it could cause disruption to the biota
and 93.00% (Table 6.). The analysis showed that respiration process. For TSS value during the
water temperature, nitrate concentration, DO, and observation was categorized high and exceeded the
TSS greatly affected the density of seagrass in TSS quality standard for seagrass that was <20 mg.l-
Panjang Island waters, Banten. 1. The high value of TSS usually affects the high
20 Current Status and Species Diversity of Seagrass (Y. Sugianti and Mujiyanto)
ILMU KELAUTAN: Indonesian Journal of Marine Sciences March 2020 Vol 25(1):15-22
Brower, J.E, Zar, J.H., & Von Ende, C.N. 1998. Field Purba, H.E., Djuwito, & Haeruddin. 2015. Distribusi
and Laboratory Methods for General Ecology. dan keanekaragaman makrozoobentos pada
Third Edition. USA: Wm. C. Brown Publisher. lahan pengembangan konservasi mangrove di
Desa Timbul Sloko Kecamatan Sayung
Donald, D.B., Bogard, M.J., Finlay, K., Bunting, L., & Kabupaten Demak. J. Maquares. 4(4): 57-65.
Leavitt, P.R. 2013. Phytoplankton-Specific
Response to Enrichment of Phosphorus-Rich Rustam, A., Kepel, T.L., Kusumaningtyas, M.A., Ati,
Surface Waters with Ammonium, Nitrate, and R.N.A., Daulat, A., Suryono, D.D., Sudirman, N.,
Urea. PLoS ONE 8(1): e53277. Rahayu, Y.P., Mangindaan, P., Heriati, A., &
Hutahaean, A.A. 2015. Ekosistem lamun
Effendi, H. 2003. Telaah kualitas air bagi sebagai bioindikator lingkungan di P. Lembeh
pengelolaan sumberdaya dan lingkungan Bitung, Sulawesi Utara. J. Biologi Ind., 11(2):
perairan. Kanisius. Yogyakarta. 258pp. 233-241.
English, S., Wilkinson, C., & Baker, C. 1997. Survey Setiawan, F., Harahap, S.A., Andriani, Y., &
Manual for Tropical Marine Resources. Second Hutahaean, A.A. 2012. Deteksi perubahan
Edition. Australian Institute of Marine Science. lamun menggunakan teknologi penginderaan
Townsville: 390 pp. jauh dan kaitannya dengan kemampuan
menyimpan karbon di perairan Teluk Banten. J.
Fahruddin, M., Yulianda, F., & Setyobudiandi, I. Perikan. Kel., 3(3): 275-286.
2017. Kerapatan dan penutupan ekosistem
lamun di pesisir Desa Bahoi, Sulawesi Utara. J. Short, F.T., McKenzie, L.J., Coles, R.G., & Gaeckle,
Ilmu dan Teknologi Kelautan Tropis. 9(1): 375- J.L. 2004. SeagrassNet manual for scientific
383. monitoring of seagrass habitat. Worldwide
Edition. University of New Hampshire, USA:
Hartati, R., Djunaedi, A., Hariyadi & Mujiyanto. 2012. QDPI, Northern Fisheries Centre, Australia. 71p.
Struktur komunitas padang lamun di perairan
Pulau Kumbang Kepulauan Karimunjawa. Ilmu Short, F.T & Waycott, M. 2010. Cymodocea
Kelautan, 17(4): 217-225. doi: 10.14710/ serrulata. The IUCN Red List of Threatened
ik.ijms.17.4.217-225 Species 2010: e.T173363A6999692. doi: 10.
2305/IUCN.UK.2010-3.RLTS.T173363A6999
692.en.
Kiswara, W. 2009. Perspektif lamun dalam
produktifitas hayati pesisir. Prosiding Lokakarya
Smith, T.M., Jenkins, G.P., & Hutchinson, N. 2012.
Nasional I Pengelolaan Eksistem Lamun. Peran
Seagrass edge effects on fish assemblages in
Ekosistem Lamun Dalam Produktifitas Hayati
deep and shallow habitats. Estuarine, Coastal
dan Meregulasi Perubahan Iklim. PKSPL-IPB,
and Shelf Science. 115:291-299. doi: 10.101
DKP, LH dan LIPI. Jakarta.
6/j.ecss.2012.09.013
Leefan, P.T, Setiadi, D., & Djokosetiyanto, D. 2013. Sugianti, Y. 2016. Analisis respon perifiton terhadap
Struktur komunitas lamun di pesisir pencemaran di ekosistem padang lamun Pulau
Manokwari. Maspari J., 5(2): 69-81. Panjang, Serang-Banten. Tesis. Institut
Teknologi Bandung. 106pp.
Lembaga Ilmu dan Pengetahuan Indonesia (LIPI).
2001. Laporan penelitian wilayah pesisir Teluk Supriadi, Soedharma, D., & Kaswadji, R.F. 2006.
Banten Tahap Kedua. Jakarta, Indonesia. Beberapa aspek pertumbuhan lamun Enhalus
acoroides (Linn.F) Royle di Pulau Barrang
Minerva, A., Purwanti, F., & Suryanto, A. 2014. Lompo Makasar. Biosfera, 1(1): 1-8.
Analisis hubungan keberadaan dan kelimpahan
lamun dengan kualitas air di Pulau Susetiono. 2004. Fauna Padang Lamun Tanjung
Karimunjawa, Jepara. J. Maquares. 3(3):88-94. Merah Selat Lembeh. Jakarta: Pusat
Oseanografi, LIPI.
Poedjirahajoe, E., Mahayani, N.P.D., Sidharta, B.R., &
Salamuddin, M. 2013. Tutupan lamun dan Terrados, J., Duarte, C.M., Fortes, M.D., Borum, J.,
kondisi ekosistemnya di Kawasan Pesisir Agawin, N.S.R., Bach, S., Thampanya, U., Kamp-
Madagaskar, Jelenga, dan Maluk Kabupaten Nielsen, L., Kenworthy, W.J., Geertz-Hansen, O.,
Sumbawa Barat. J. Ilmu Teknol. Kel. Trop., 5(1): & Vermaat, J. 1997. Changes in community
36-46. structure and biomass seagrass communities
Current Status and Species Diversity of Seagrass (Y. Sugianti and Mujiyanto) 21
ILMU KELAUTAN: Indonesian Journal of Marine Sciences March 2020 Vol 25(1):15-22
along gradient of siltation in SE Asia. Est. Coast. Zafren, Lestari F., & Zen, L.W. 2018. Hubungan
Shelf Sci., 46: 757-768. parameter kualitas perairan terhadap
kerapatan lamun di perairan Desa Kelong
Yunus, S. 2008. Penilaian dampak aktivitas Kecamatan Bintan Pesisir Kabupaten Bintan
manusia pada kerusakan ekosistem padang Provinsi Kepulauan Riau. Jurnal Umrah, 1(2):1-
lamun di Pantai Barat Teluk Banten. Tesis. 8.
Universitas Indonesia.
22 Current Status and Species Diversity of Seagrass (Y. Sugianti and Mujiyanto)