Robin George Collingwood
3,082 Followers
Most cited papers in Robin George Collingwood
Conspiracy theories are widely deemed to be superstitious. Yet history appears to be littered with conspiracies successful and otherwise. (For this reason ‘cock-up’ theories cannot in general replace conspiracy theories since in many... more
Along with utilitarianism, British idealism was the most important philosophical and practical movement in Britain and its Empire during the late-nineteenth and early-twentieth centuries. Even though the British idealists have regained... more
This article discusses the issue of the conceptual accuracy of descriptions of social life, which, although fundamental for the social sciences, has in fact been neglected. I approach this task via an examination of Paul Roth’s recent... more
R. G. Collingwood's New Leviathan (1942) presents an account of two 'dialectical' political processes that are ongoing in any body politic. Existing scholarship has already covered the first: a dialectic between a 'social' and a... more
Abstract: In the contemporary literature, transcendental arguments are presented either as ambitious truth-directed arguments with an anti-sceptical agenda (only to be castigated soon afterwards for failing to deliver robust ontological... more
This paper argues that God, despite his perfection, can have faith in us. The paper includes exegesis of various Midrasihc texts, so as to understand the Rabbinic claim that God manifested faith in creating the world. After the exegesis,... more
This paper explores certain issues that arise at the borderline between conceptual analysis and metaphysics, where answers to questions of a conceptual nature compete with answers to questions of an ontological or metaphysical nature. I... more
Öz: R. G. Collingwood, metafiziği reddetmenin moda olduğu Çağdaş Felsefede, Aristoteles’e dönerek metafiziği yeniden yorumlamanın imkânını soruşturur. Bu soruşturma bağlamında metafizik, her türlü bilimsel ve entelektüel etkinliğin... more
Review of: R. G. Collingwood: The Philosophy of Enchantment: Studies in Folktale, Cultural Criticism, and Anthropology, edited by David Boucher, Wendy James and Philip Smallwood. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 2007, 1st edn, 2005, pp. cxx þ... more
"Michel Weber and Will Desmond, (eds.), Handbook of Whiteheadian Process Thought, Frankfurt / Lancaster, ontos verlag, Process Thought X1 & X2, 2008. (695 p. + 726 p. ; ISBN 978-3-938793-92-3 ; 398 €) Gathering 115 entries written by 101... more
Abstract. This paper seeks to clarify the precise sense in which Collingwood’s “metaphysics without ontology” is a descriptive metaphysics. It locates Collingwood’s metaphysics against the background of Strawson’s distinction between... more
Current research in affectivity is often dominated by perspectives on the feeling/thinking dichotomy. In the paper first I reconstruct Collingwood’s position on this point as it is presented in his Religion and Philosophy, The Principles... more
This paper defends an idealist form of non-reductivism in the philosophy of mind. I refer to it as a kind of conceptual dualism without substance dualism. I contrast this idealist alternative with the two most widespread forms of... more
It is the ambition of natural science to provide complete explanations of reality. Collingwood argues that science can only explain events, not actions. The latter are the distinctive subject matter of history and can be described as... more
Strauss’s invitation to understand Greek authors as they understood themselves was attacked by influential scholars as anti-historical. In the first part of the paper, I argue that the charge is due to a misunderstanding of Strauss’s... more
Este ensaio explora a dimensão existencial e ética do passado histórico a partir de duas perspectivas diferentes. Na primeira parte, o ensaio aborda a questão, examinando a dimensão pessoal do passado histórico a partir da perspectiva do... more
Recently, James Alexander has proposed a ‘dialectical definition’ of conservatism which, he believes, goes beyond ‘dispositional’ definitions, such as those proposed by Brennan and Hamlin, and by Martin Beckstein, which are ‘incomplete’.... more
Social constructivism is a sociological theory of knowledge based on the way human knowledge is constructed through social interactions amongst individuals (Brooks & Brooks, 1993). In light of our recent obsession with improving and... more
In this essay, Ahlskog examines R. G. Collingwood’s conception of the philosophy of history and its metaphilosophical import. Ahlskog shows that Collingwood’s philosophy of history is simultaneously both a descriptive metaphysics of... more
In what sense is historical knowledge dependent on testimony? The essay approaches this question by examining one of the most important philosophers of history during the twentieth century, Robin George Collingwood, and his controversial... more
It is often assumed that science provides the most accurate knowledge about nature. This view not only collapses distinctions between different forms of knowing but also results in a paradox whereby understanding what it means to exist in... more
Abstract In my dissertation I show that classical pragmatists understood their philosophical projects to be broadly anti-sceptical in nature—a point recent literature sometimes obscures. I then extend their ideas and deploy them against... more
Does R. G. Collingwood’s meta-philosophical theory that concepts in philosophy are organized as “scales of forms” apply to his own work on the nature of history? Or is there some inconsistency between Collingwood’s work as a philosopher... more
Previous research has focused on various methods, strategies and concepts that impact the teaching of history in classrooms (Brush & Saye, 2002; Hicks, Doolittle & Ewing, 2004; Levstik & Barton, 2011; Shepherd, 2010). However, research... more
Political philosophy seems to have fallen on hard times. Though plenty of academics in departments of Philosophy and Political Science still lay claim to the field, those who actually have something illuminating to say about our political... more
The barbarian is the bugbear of the classicist. Because they rejected Christendom they are like the fool Othello, the “base Indian who threw away the pearl.” Lonergan shares the concern with the Christian civilization, but what to do? On... more
R. G. Collingwood's declaration that belief in "eternal questions" in philosophy is "merely a vulgar error, consequent on a kind of historical myopia which, deceived by superficial resemblances, failed to detect profound differences" has... more
In this paper, I examine Strauss's critique of Collingwood's interpretive approach and argue that Strauss's accusation of historicism partly misses its target. While Collingwood can be said to be a " historicist " thinker insofar as he... more
R. G. Collingwood’s 'The Principles of Art' argues that art is the expression of emotion. This dissertation offers a new interpretation of that philosophy, and argues that this interpretation is both hermeneutically and philosophically... more
By means of a reading of the penultimate chapter of Collingwood’s An Essay on Philosophical Method, this paper offers a re-evaluation of several points in leading interpretations of his philosophy. It is argued that this chapter,... more
The expedition’s events are summarised in his The First Mate’s Log, published in 1940. I am less interested in the actual narrative of that book. Rather, my aim is to make sense, that is, to understand the philosophical stake of the... more
This article asks to what extent R.G. Collingwood’s ‘logic of question and answer’ is compatible with the central tenets of Giovanni Gentile’s ‘actualism’. It is argued that, interpreted as an actualist device, Collingwood’s ‘logic’... more
The aim of this exposition is not to defend Collingwood's explanation of art, but to show important errors of interpretation that have become a common place in the objections that are made against his proposal. To accomplish it, I pretend... more
The status of art in Plato's philosophy has always been a difficult problem. As a matter of fact, he even threw the poets out from his ideal state, a passage that has led some interpreters to assess that Plato did not develop a proper... more