11th PCC Agenda Final 03.07.2013
11th PCC Agenda Final 03.07.2013
11th PCC Agenda Final 03.07.2013
Agenda
For
11th Protection Coordination Sub-Committee Meeting
Time of meeting : 10:00 AM.
Date of meeting : 10th July, 2013 (Wednesday)
Venue
A.
CONFIRMATION
OF
MINUTES
ITEMS
B.
FOR
DISCUSSION
FOLLOW UP ACTION
Zones
Z1
Z2
Zone Setting
The setting shall be 80 % - 85% of the protected
line length.
Time delay
Instantaneous
0.5
Z3
0.9 to 1.5
Seconds
section
0.9 to 1.5
seconds
However, the zone settings of distance relays for unusual cases may be treated
separately.
During 84th OCC meeting and 8th PCC meeting NERLDC gave a presentation on
system studies and other related issues pertaining to System Protection Scheme
(SPS) associated with following conditions:
Case 1: Tripping of generating unit of OTPC at Palatana
Case 2: Tripping of 400 kV D/C Palatana-Silchar line
Case 3: Tripping of 400 kV Silchar-Byrnihat line.
NERLDC informed that the study was carried out by taking the base case of NER
peak and off-peak conditions in July, 2013.
During off-peak hours, the above trippings may not create serious problem. But
during peak hours, above trippings may lead to grid disturbance.
As pre-condition, for successful operation of the proposed System Protection
Scheme (SPS), the following lines should be kept in open condition for all the three
cases mentioned above:
132
kV
D/C
Khliehriat(PG)
Khliehriat(MeECL)
Khliehriat(MeECL)
132 kV Khliehriat(MeECL) NEHU line
132 kV Khliehriat(MeECL) NEIGRIHMS line
132 kV Pailapool Jiribam line at Jiribam end
The scheme for all the three cases will be as follows:
3
lines
at
ii.
This signal should trip the CB of 132 kV Silchar Srikona D/C & 132 kV
Silchar Panchgram lines at Silchar.
iii.
iv.
After these trippings an instant load of 80 MW will be relieved during offpeak hours & 130 MW will be relieved during peak hours which will
prevent the system from cascade tripping
v.
When both the ckts of 400 kV Palatana Silchar lines trip, a signal will
be generated from trip relays at Silchar
ii.
This signal should trip the C CBs at Silchar end of 132 kV Silchar
Srikona D/C & 132 kV Silchar Panchgram lines.
iii.
iv.
After these trippings an instant load of 80 MW will be relieved during offpeak hours & 130 MW will be relieved during peak hours which will
prevent the system from cascade tripping
v.
When 400 kV Byrnihat Silchar lines trip, signal will be generated from
trip relays at Silchar
4
iii.
iv.
In 86th OCC meeting the matter was discussed. The representative of OTPC
informed that necessary action has already been taken at their end for successful
implementation of the proposed SPS pertaining to tripping of generating Unit#1
(Case-I). The auxiliary contact of CB has been wired up to PLCC panel in
consultation with POWERGRID.
OTPC requested the forum that the SPS pertaining to other two cases [Case-II &
Case-III], requiring automatic tripping of STG/GT of generating Unit#1, needs
further discussion. The tripping of STG may lead to reduction of generation to a very
low level. Hence detail discussion is required with BHEL, POWERGRID, NERLDC
and NERPC before implementation of the SPS for Case II & III. NERLDC informed
that when generation is low, tripping of identified lines may not be required.
However, when Unit is running under full load, tripping of 400 kV Silchar
Byrnihat line / 400 kV Silchar-Palatana line may require reduction of generation by
about 200MW.
Meghalaya stated that Leshka HEP has started full generation and since so many
Meghalaya lines are kept in open condition for implementation of SPS, NERLDC
need to ensure the evacuation of full generation of power of Leshka HEP.
NERLDC stated that full generation of Leshka can be evacuated during peak hours
keeping 132 kV D/C Khliehriat(PG) Khliehriat(Me.ECL) lines and 132 kV
Panchgram - Lumshnong line in open condition. However during off-peak hours
modus operandi will be finalized after discussion with Me.ECL based on system
study.
After detailed deliberation, the committee suggested that the system study group
need to study the proposal in detail, particularly SPS pertaining to Case-II & III and
prepare action plan for implementation of SPS.
Committee may like to discuss the status of implementation of SPS. NERLDC
may inform about the status of studies relating to SPS.
After detailed discussion in 86th OCC & 10th PCC meetings, the committee has
decided the following islanding schemes in NER:
Sl. No.
Islanding Scheme
Frequency
1.
48.80 Hz
2.
48.20 Hz
3.
47.90 Hz
Further, the committee suggested for discussion with ER regarding isolation of NER
from NEW grid at ER-NER boundary. The matter was also deliberated at length
during 85th OCC meeting held on 9th May, 2013. All constituents were requested to
study the proposal so that the matter can be discussed further before finalization.
During the 86th OCC meeting and 10th PCC meeting, the committee had requested
the system study Group to study the proposed islanding Scheme in detail and
discuss in OCC/PCC forum so that further action can be planned for
implementation of islanding schemes.
Committee may like to discuss. NERLDC may inform about the status of
studies relating to Islanding scheme.
Feeder
Nos.
Nos. / Month
Nos.
Nos. / Month
Kurung- Kamey
470
24.73
296
14.8
304
16.00
136
6.8
Kimin Feeder
783
38.84
425
21.25
Tripping (Oct11
Jun13)
Feeder
Nos.
Nos. /
Month
Nos.
Nos. / Month
AP - 1
109
5.73
153
7.28
AP 2
258
13.57
332
15.80
AP - 4
48
2.52
34
1.62
Me. ECL has dismantled 2 Nos BPL make PLCC panels of 132 kV Khliehriat (PG)Khliehriat (MeECL) # I at Khliehriat (MeECL) station without informing/ discussing
POWERGRID. Thus at present the PLCC link between these two stations through
the PLCC link is out of service.
During the 10th PCC meeting, the Sub-committee requested all the constituents that
before carrying out dismantling works or any other works which involves more than
one agency, the affected party should be informed in advance. The representative of
Meghalaya informed that 2 Nos. of PLCC panels will be re-installed soon.
Me. ECL may inform the plan for re-installation of the panels.
Name of the
Feeder
RelaySettings
Original
Imphal SS
132 kV Loktak
TZ2 = 500ms,
Imphal -II
TZ3 = 1000ms
Revised
Imphal SS
TZ2 = 300ms,
TZ3 = 700ms
Status
Done
132
kV
Khliehriat (PG)
Khliehriat
(MeECL) I
Khliehriat (PG)
TZ2 = 500ms,
TZ3 = 10000ms
67N=TMS-0.45
Khliehriat (PG)
TZ2 = 200ms,
Done
TZ3 = 6000ms
67N=TMS-0.25
132
kV Khliehriat (PG)
Khliehriat (PG)
TZ2 = 500ms,
Khliehriat
TZ3 = 10000ms
(MeECL) II
Khliehriat (PG)
Done
TZ2 = 200ms,
TZ3 = 6000ms
4
5
132 kV LoktakNinthoukhong
Zone-2, Zone-3 and B/U Protection to be
132 kV Loktak- reviewed.
Rangpeng
132
kV
Khliehriat
(MeECL) Nehu
132
kV
Protective switchgear to be checked for
Khliehriat
operation and Zone-2 & Zone-3 delay to be
(MeECL) Lesika
reduced.
132
kV
Khliehriat
(MeECL)
Lumslung
During the 10th PCC meeting, Me.ECL representative informed that necessary action
has already been taken to reduce the fault in downstream area of Meghalaya system
(beyond 132kV Khliehriat) and committee requested POWERGRID to monitor the
status and bring to the notice of the committee, if there is no improvement.
9
Me. ECL may inform the current status. Similarly POWERGRID/DOP Manipur
& NHPC may kindly inform the current status
B.12. Installation of 2nd Distance Protection Relay (DPR) for 220KV and above
System
The status of installation of 2nd DPR in respect of following lines as given in 9th
PCC is as follows:
SN
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
Station
Kopili HEP
Kopili HEP
Kopili HEP
Kathalguri PH
Kathalguri PH
Samaguri SS
BTPS SS
BTPS SS
Line
220 KV Misa #1
220 KV Misa #II
220 KV Misa #III
220 KV Misa
220 KV Mariani
220 KV Balipara
220 KV Salakati # I
220 KV Salakati # II
Utility
NEEPCO
NEEPCO
NEEPCO
NEEPCO
NEEPCO
AEGCL
AEGCL
AEGCL
Status
By May 2013
By May 2013
By May 2013
Completed
Completed
Oct, 2013
Oct, 2013
Oct, 2013
Regarding Sl. No. 1 to 3 above, the status could not be updated during the 10th PCC
meeting, since no representative from NEEPCO was present.
NEEPCO may intimate the current status.
During the 10th PCC meeting, the representative of Manipur informed that
renovation work in various substations is in progress and after completion of works
the situation would improve.
10
B.14. Parallel Operation of 3x20 MVA Transformer with 160 MVA Autotransformer at Kopili
During 10th PCC meeting, the status could not be updated since no representative
from NEEPCO was present.
The representative of POWERGRID was requested to fix a suitable date for the
meeting in consultation with NEEPCO and to take necessary action to complete the
paralleling operation of transformers at the earliest so that 3x20MVA, 220/132kV
transformers can be utilized effectively.
POWERGRID/NEEPCO may give the current status.
11
C.
NEW
ITEMS
At 1404 Hrs on 29.05.13, 132 kV Loktak-Jiribam II and 132 kV LoktakNingthoukhong tripped, followed by tripping of 132 kV Loktak-Imphal, 132 kV
Loktak-Rengpang lines and all units of Loktak, at 1407 Hr.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
At 0630 Hrs on 19.06.13, all three units of Loktak , 132 kV Loktak Jiribam II
& 132 kV Dimapur Imphal line tripped.
7.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
2.
13
2.
3.
At 1217 Hrs on 05.06.13, Palatana GTG I tripped & followed by STG I tripping
at 1227 Hrs.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
At 1026 Hrs on 12.06.13, 400 kV Palatana Silchar D/C & 400 kV Silchar
Byrnihat S/C tripped.
ii) At 0413 Hrs on 03.06.13, AGBPP Gas Compressor I stalled, leading to tripping
of Unit II & IV.
15
*****
16