Location via proxy:   [ UP ]  
[Report a bug]   [Manage cookies]                
Skip to main content
  • Las Vegas, United States
We investigated the relationship between two kinds of problem solving using Kitchener's model of hierarchical cognitive processing. We predicted that performance on well-defined problems (i. e. those with a single, guaranteed solution)... more
We investigated the relationship between two kinds of problem solving using Kitchener's model of hierarchical cognitive processing. We predicted that performance on well-defined problems (i. e. those with a single, guaranteed solution) would be independent of ill-defined problems (i. e. those with multiple, non-guaranteed solutions). We also predicted that self-reported epistemic beliefs (i. e. assumptions about the nature and acquisition of knowledge) would be related to ill-defined, but not well-defined, solutions. Results confirmed these predictions. We concluded that well-defined and ill-defined problems require separate cognitive processes and that epistemic beliefs play an important role in ill-defined problem solving. These findings supported Kitchener's three-level model of problem solving.
This review synthesizes and critically examines 19 empirical studies that have addressed the domain-specificity/domain-generality issue in personal epistemology. We present an overview of traditional and more contemporary epistemological... more
This review synthesizes and critically examines 19 empirical studies that have addressed the domain-specificity/domain-generality issue in personal epistemology. We present an overview of traditional and more contemporary epistemological stances from philosophical perspectives to offer another basis from which to examine this issue. Explicit examples of academic domains are described and epistemological comparisons are made based on our synthesized definition. Given the epistemological similarities and differences across domains that we identified from empirical and philosophical considerations, we propose that beliefs are both domain general and domain specific. Accordingly, we present a theoretical framework of personal epistemology that incorporates both positions and hypothesize how the belief systems might interact in terms of the development of personal epistemology and relations to various facets of cognition, motivation, and achievement. The article ends with a discussion of educational implications.
Two experiments investigated whether monitoring is better characterized as a domain-specific or a domain-general phenomenon. In Experiment 1, college students' performance and discrimination accuracy were not correlated across 8... more
Two experiments investigated whether monitoring is better characterized as a domain-specific or a domain-general phenomenon. In Experiment 1, college students' performance and discrimination accuracy were not correlated across 8 different domains, whereas confidence and judgment bias were. With tests matched on all salient dimensions except content, in Experiment 2, students' performance, confidence, discrimination, and bias were correlated across all or most domains. In addition, confidence was correlated even after the effect of performance was removed. These findings lend qualified support to the domain-general hypothesis, which states that monitoring within a specific domain is governed by general metacognitive processes in addition to domain-specific knowledge. Theoretical and educational implications are discussed, with particular attention given to the origin and development of the general monitoring skill.
The current study examines the personal epistemology of fourth-grade elementary school teachers from Germany (n= 10) and the United States (n= 10) to gain a more nuanced understanding of teachers' beliefs about knowledge and... more
The current study examines the personal epistemology of fourth-grade elementary school teachers from Germany (n= 10) and the United States (n= 10) to gain a more nuanced understanding of teachers' beliefs about knowledge and knowing through a cross-cultural ...
... Neuman, & Biezuner, 2000; Teichert & Stacy, 2002; Tien, Roth, & Kampmeier, 2002; Webb, 1995), improvements in writing skills... more
... Neuman, & Biezuner, 2000; Teichert & Stacy, 2002; Tien, Roth, & Kampmeier, 2002; Webb, 1995), improvements in writing skills (Reznitskaya et al., 2001), better scientific reasoning (Goldman, Duschl, Ellenbogen, Williams, & Tzou, 2003; Nussbaum & Sinatra, 2003; Schwarz & ...
Our understanding of the cross-cultural aspects of personal epistemology is limited. In particular, cross-cultural comparisons of elementary school teachers’ and students’ personal epistemology have received very little theoretical or... more
Our understanding of the cross-cultural aspects of personal epistemology is limited. In particular, cross-cultural comparisons of elementary school teachers’ and students’ personal epistemology have received very little theoretical or empirical attention. The current chapter aims to examine German and U.S. elementary schools in terms of their philosophical and practical similarities and differences in personal epistemology. Both theoretical and empirical work will be reviewed to support a more holistic model of personal epistemology, the Educational Model of Personal Epistemology (Haerle, 2006). In light of this model, we discuss our expectations for differences and similarities in the epistemic climate of elementary classrooms in the U.S. and Germany. Drawing from this discussion, we suggest that researchers should approach cross-cultural research in personal epistemology from a more holistic standpoint, employ a diversity of methods, and obtain a solid understanding of the educational context under study. Regarding educational implications, we propose a possible fusion of the educational philosophies held in the U.S. and Germany concerning the implementation of teacher training and classroom education. Finally, we recommend that fostering evaluativistic thinking (i.e., a way of knowing that focuses on the evaluation and decision-making among differing viewpoints) should be a main goal for education starting at the elementary level to ensure students’ future roles as productive citizens in Western societies and stress the role of the teacher in this endeavor.
Research Interests:
Critical Theory, Sociology, Cognitive Psychology, Cognitive Science, Developmental Psychology, and 89 more
... Guiding Model Lisa D. Bendixen and Deanna C. Rule Department of Educational Psychology University of Nevada, Las Vegas This commentary brings together a collection of articles that addresses several of the important issues in research... more
... Guiding Model Lisa D. Bendixen and Deanna C. Rule Department of Educational Psychology University of Nevada, Las Vegas This commentary brings together a collection of articles that addresses several of the important issues in research on personal epistemology. ...