-
Spectral model selection in the electronic measurement of the Boltzmann constant by Johnson noise thermometry
Authors:
Kevin J Coakley,
Jifeng Qu
Abstract:
In the electronic measurement of the Boltzmann constant based on Johnson noise thermometry, the ratio of the power spectral densities of thermal noise across a resistor at the triple point of water, and pseudo-random noise synthetically generated by a quantum-accurate voltage-noise source is constant to within 1 part in a billion for frequencies up to 1 GHz. Given this ratio, and the values of oth…
▽ More
In the electronic measurement of the Boltzmann constant based on Johnson noise thermometry, the ratio of the power spectral densities of thermal noise across a resistor at the triple point of water, and pseudo-random noise synthetically generated by a quantum-accurate voltage-noise source is constant to within 1 part in a billion for frequencies up to 1 GHz. Given this ratio, and the values of other known or measured parameters, one can determine the Boltzmann constant. Due, in part, to mismatch between transmission lines, the experimental ratio spectrum varies with frequency. We model this spectrum as an even polynomial function of frequency where the constant term in the polynomial determines the Boltzmann constant. When determining this constant (offset) from experimental data, the assumed complexity of the ratio spectrum model and the maximum frequency analyzed (fitting bandwidth) dramatically affects results. We select the complexity of the model by cross-validation. For each of many fitting bandwidths, we determine the component of uncertainty of the offset term that accounts for random and systematic effects associated with imperfect knowledge of model complexity. We select the fitting bandwidth that minimizes this uncertainty. In the most recent measurement of the Boltzmann constant, results were determined, in part, by application of an earlier version of the method described here. Here, we extend the earlier analysis by considering a broader range of fitting bandwidths and quantify an additional component of uncertainty that accounts for imperfect performance of our fitting bandwidth selection method. For idealized simulated data our method correctly selects the true complexity of the ratio spectrum model for all cases considered. A new analysis of data from the recent experiment yields evidence for a temporal trend in the offset parameters.
△ Less
Submitted 2 February, 2017; v1 submitted 19 June, 2016;
originally announced June 2016.
-
Preparation of entangled states through Hilbert space engineering
Authors:
Y. Lin,
J. P. Gaebler,
F. Reiter,
T. R. Tan,
R. Bowler,
Y. Wan,
A. Keith,
E. Knill,
S. Glancy,
K. Coakley,
A. S. Sørensen,
D. Leibfried,
D. J. Wineland
Abstract:
Entangled states are a crucial resource for quantum-based technologies such as quantum computers and quantum communication systems (1,2). Exploring new methods for entanglement generation is important for diversifying and eventually improving current approaches. Here, we create entanglement in atomic ions by applying laser fields to constrain the evolution to a restricted number of states, in an a…
▽ More
Entangled states are a crucial resource for quantum-based technologies such as quantum computers and quantum communication systems (1,2). Exploring new methods for entanglement generation is important for diversifying and eventually improving current approaches. Here, we create entanglement in atomic ions by applying laser fields to constrain the evolution to a restricted number of states, in an approach that has become known as "quantum Zeno dynamics" (3-5). With two trapped $^9\rm{Be}^+$ ions, we obtain Bell state fidelities up to $0.990^{+2}_{-5}$, with three ions, a W-state (6) fidelity of $0.910^{+4}_{-7}$ is obtained. Compared to other methods of producing entanglement in trapped ions, this procedure is relatively insensitive to certain imperfections such as fluctuations in laser intensity, laser frequency, and ion-motion frequencies.
△ Less
Submitted 11 March, 2016;
originally announced March 2016.
-
Precision Measurement of the Radiative $\Beta$ Decay of the Free Neutron
Authors:
M. J. Bales,
R. Alarcon,
C. D. Bass,
E. J. Beise,
H. Breuer,
J. Byrne,
T. E. Chupp,
K. J. Coakley,
R. L. Cooper,
M. S. Dewey,
S. Gardner,
T. R. Gentile,
D. He,
H. P. Mumm,
J. S. Nico,
B. O'Neill,
A. K. Thompson,
F. E. Wietfeldt
Abstract:
The standard model predicts that, in addition to a proton, an electron, and an antineutrino, a continuous spectrum of photons is emitted in the $β$ decay of the free neutron. We report on the RDK II experiment which measured the photon spectrum using two different detector arrays. An annular array of bismuth germanium oxide scintillators detected photons from 14 to 782~keV. The spectral shape was…
▽ More
The standard model predicts that, in addition to a proton, an electron, and an antineutrino, a continuous spectrum of photons is emitted in the $β$ decay of the free neutron. We report on the RDK II experiment which measured the photon spectrum using two different detector arrays. An annular array of bismuth germanium oxide scintillators detected photons from 14 to 782~keV. The spectral shape was consistent with theory, and we determined a branching ratio of 0.00335 $\pm$ 0.00005 [stat] $\pm$ 0.00015 [syst]. A second detector array of large area avalanche photodiodes directly detected photons from 0.4 to 14~keV. For this array, the spectral shape was consistent with theory, and the branching ratio was determined to be 0.00582 $\pm$ 0.00023 [stat] $\pm$ 0.00062 [syst]. We report the first precision test of the shape of the photon energy spectrum from neutron radiative decay and a substantially improved determination of the branching ratio over a broad range of photon energies.
△ Less
Submitted 26 May, 2016; v1 submitted 1 March, 2016;
originally announced March 2016.
-
Stochastic modeling and survival analysis of marginally trapped neutrons for a magnetic trapping neutron lifetime experiment
Authors:
K. J. Coakley,
M. S. Dewey,
M. G. Huber,
P. R. Huffman,
C. R. Huffer,
D. E. Marley,
H. P. Mumm,
C. M. O'Shaughnessy,
K. W. Schelhammer,
A. K. Thompson,
A. T. Yue
Abstract:
In a variety of neutron lifetime experiments, in addition to $β-$decay, neutrons can be lost by other mechanisms including wall losses. Failure to account for these other loss mechanisms produces systematic measurement error and associated systematic uncertainties in neutron lifetime measurements. In this work, we develop a physical model for neutron wall losses and construct a competing risks sur…
▽ More
In a variety of neutron lifetime experiments, in addition to $β-$decay, neutrons can be lost by other mechanisms including wall losses. Failure to account for these other loss mechanisms produces systematic measurement error and associated systematic uncertainties in neutron lifetime measurements. In this work, we develop a physical model for neutron wall losses and construct a competing risks survival analysis model to account for losses due to the joint effect of $β-$decay losses, wall losses of marginally trapped neutrons, and an additional absorption mechanism. We determine the survival probability function associated with the wall loss mechanism by a Monte Carlo method. Based on a fit of the competing risks model to a subset of the NIST experimental data, we determine the mean lifetime of trapped neutrons to be approximately 700 s -- considerably less than the current best estimate of (880.1 $\pm$ 1.1) s promulgated by the Particle Data Group [1]. Currently, experimental studies are underway to determine if this discrepancy can be explained by neutron capture by ${}^3$He impurities in the trapping volume. Analysis of the full NIST data will be presented in a later publication.
△ Less
Submitted 10 August, 2015;
originally announced August 2015.
-
Nonproportionality in the scintillation light yield of bismuth germanate
Authors:
T. R. Gentile,
M. J. Bales,
H. Breuer,
T. E. Chupp,
K. J. Coakley,
R. L. Cooper,
J. S. Nico,
B. O'Neill
Abstract:
We present measurements of nonproportionality in the scintillation light yield of bismuth germanate (BGO) for gamma-rays with energies between 6 keV and 662 keV. The scintillation light was read out by avalanche photodiodes (APDs) with both the BGO crystals and APDs operated at a temperature of approximately 90 K. Data were obtained using radioisotope sources to illuminate both a single BGO crysta…
▽ More
We present measurements of nonproportionality in the scintillation light yield of bismuth germanate (BGO) for gamma-rays with energies between 6 keV and 662 keV. The scintillation light was read out by avalanche photodiodes (APDs) with both the BGO crystals and APDs operated at a temperature of approximately 90 K. Data were obtained using radioisotope sources to illuminate both a single BGO crystal in a small test cryostat and a 12-element detector in a neutron radiative beta-decay experiment. In addition one datum was obtained in a 4.6 T magnetic field based on the bismuth K x-ray escape peak produced by a continuum of background gamma rays in this apparatus. These measurements and comparison to prior results were motivated by an experiment to study the radiative decay mode of the free neutron. The combination of data taken under different conditions yields a reasonably consistent picture for BGO nonproportionality that should be useful for researchers employing BGO detectors at low gamma ray energies.
△ Less
Submitted 1 May, 2015;
originally announced May 2015.
-
Improving Photoelectron Counting and Particle Identification in Scintillation Detectors with Bayesian Techniques
Authors:
M. Akashi-Ronquest,
P. -A. Amaudruz,
M. Batygov,
B. Beltran,
M. Bodmer,
M. G. Boulay,
B. Broerman,
B. Buck,
A. Butcher,
B. Cai,
T. Caldwell,
M. Chen,
Y. Chen,
B. Cleveland,
K. Coakley,
K. Dering,
F. A. Duncan,
J. A. Formaggio,
R. Gagnon,
D. Gastler,
F. Giuliani,
M. Gold,
V. V. Golovko,
P. Gorel,
K. Graham
, et al. (57 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Many current and future dark matter and neutrino detectors are designed to measure scintillation light with a large array of photomultiplier tubes (PMTs). The energy resolution and particle identification capabilities of these detectors depend in part on the ability to accurately identify individual photoelectrons in PMT waveforms despite large variability in pulse amplitudes and pulse pileup. We…
▽ More
Many current and future dark matter and neutrino detectors are designed to measure scintillation light with a large array of photomultiplier tubes (PMTs). The energy resolution and particle identification capabilities of these detectors depend in part on the ability to accurately identify individual photoelectrons in PMT waveforms despite large variability in pulse amplitudes and pulse pileup. We describe a Bayesian technique that can identify the times of individual photoelectrons in a sampled PMT waveform without deconvolution, even when pileup is present. To demonstrate the technique, we apply it to the general problem of particle identification in single-phase liquid argon dark matter detectors. Using the output of the Bayesian photoelectron counting algorithm described in this paper, we construct several test statistics for rejection of backgrounds for dark matter searches in argon. Compared to simpler methods based on either observed charge or peak finding, the photoelectron counting technique improves both energy resolution and particle identification of low energy events in calibration data from the DEAP-1 detector and simulation of the larger MiniCLEAN dark matter detector.
△ Less
Submitted 12 December, 2014; v1 submitted 8 August, 2014;
originally announced August 2014.
-
Update on the MiniCLEAN Dark Matter Experiment
Authors:
K. Rielage,
M. Akashi-Ronquest,
M. Bodmer,
R. Bourque,
B. Buck,
A. Butcher,
T. Caldwell,
Y. Chen,
K. Coakley,
E. Flores,
J. A. Formaggio,
D. Gastler,
F. Giuliani,
M. Gold,
E. Grace,
J. Griego,
N. Guerrero,
V. Guiseppe,
R. Henning,
A. Hime,
S. Jaditz,
C. Kachulis,
E. Kearns,
J. Kelsey,
J. R. Klein
, et al. (21 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The direct search for dark matter is entering a period of increased sensitivity to the hypothetical Weakly Interacting Massive Particle (WIMP). One such technology that is being examined is a scintillation only noble liquid experiment, MiniCLEAN. MiniCLEAN utilizes over 500 kg of liquid cryogen to detect nuclear recoils from WIMP dark matter and serves as a demonstration for a future detector of o…
▽ More
The direct search for dark matter is entering a period of increased sensitivity to the hypothetical Weakly Interacting Massive Particle (WIMP). One such technology that is being examined is a scintillation only noble liquid experiment, MiniCLEAN. MiniCLEAN utilizes over 500 kg of liquid cryogen to detect nuclear recoils from WIMP dark matter and serves as a demonstration for a future detector of order 50 to 100 tonnes. The liquid cryogen is interchangeable between argon and neon to study the A$^{2}$ dependence of the potential signal and examine backgrounds. MiniCLEAN utilizes a unique modular design with spherical geometry to maximize the light yield using cold photomultiplier tubes in a single-phase detector. Pulse shape discrimination techniques are used to separate nuclear recoil signals from electron recoil backgrounds. MiniCLEAN will be spiked with additional $^{39}$Ar to demonstrate the effective reach of the pulse shape discrimination capability. Assembly of the experiment is underway at SNOLAB and an update on the project is given.
△ Less
Submitted 19 March, 2014;
originally announced March 2014.
-
A gamma- and X-ray detector for cryogenic, high magnetic field applications
Authors:
R. L. Cooper,
R. Alarcon,
M. J. Bales,
C. D. Bass,
E. J. Beise,
H. Breuer,
J. Byrne,
T. E. Chupp,
K. J. Coakley,
M. S. Dewey,
C. Fu,
T. R. Gentile,
H. P. Mumm,
J. S. Nico,
B. O'Neill,
K. Pulliam,
A. K. Thompson,
F. E. Wietfeldt
Abstract:
As part of an experiment to measure the spectrum of photons emitted in beta-decay of the free neutron, we developed and operated a detector consisting of 12 bismuth germanate (BGO) crystals coupled to avalanche photodiodes (APDs). The detector was operated near liquid nitrogen temperature in the bore of a superconducting magnet and registered photons with energies from 5 keV to 1000 keV. To enlarg…
▽ More
As part of an experiment to measure the spectrum of photons emitted in beta-decay of the free neutron, we developed and operated a detector consisting of 12 bismuth germanate (BGO) crystals coupled to avalanche photodiodes (APDs). The detector was operated near liquid nitrogen temperature in the bore of a superconducting magnet and registered photons with energies from 5 keV to 1000 keV. To enlarge the detection range, we also directly detected soft X-rays with energies between 0.2 keV and 20 keV with three large area APDs. The construction and operation of the detector is presented, as well as information on operation of APDs at cryogenic temperatures.
△ Less
Submitted 18 July, 2012;
originally announced July 2012.
-
Scintillation yield and time dependence from electronic and nuclear recoils in liquid neon
Authors:
W. H. Lippincott,
K. J. Coakley,
D. Gastler,
E. Kearns,
D. N. McKinsey,
J. A. Nikkel
Abstract:
We have performed measurements of scintillation light in liquid neon, observing a signal yield in our detector as high as (3.5 $\pm$ 0.4) photoelectrons/keV. We measure pulse shape discrimination efficiency between electronic and nuclear recoils in liquid neon from 50 and 300 keV nuclear recoil energy. We also measure the \leff\, parameter in liquid neon between 30 and 370 keV nuclear recoil energ…
▽ More
We have performed measurements of scintillation light in liquid neon, observing a signal yield in our detector as high as (3.5 $\pm$ 0.4) photoelectrons/keV. We measure pulse shape discrimination efficiency between electronic and nuclear recoils in liquid neon from 50 and 300 keV nuclear recoil energy. We also measure the \leff\, parameter in liquid neon between 30 and 370 keV nuclear recoil energy, observing an average \leff$=0.24$ above 50 keV. We observe a dependence of the scintillation time distribution and signal yield on the pressure and temperature of the liquid neon.
△ Less
Submitted 13 August, 2012; v1 submitted 14 November, 2011;
originally announced November 2011.
-
Fast Neutron Detection with 6Li-loaded Liquid Scintillator
Authors:
B. M. Fisher,
J. N. Abdurashitov,
K. J. Coakley,
V. N. Gavrin,
D. M. Gilliam,
J. S. Nico,
A. A. Shikhin,
A. K. Thompson,
D. F. Vecchia,
V. E. Yants
Abstract:
We report on the development of a fast neutron detector using a liquid scintillator doped with enriched Li-6. The lithium was introduced in the form of an aqueous LiCl micro-emulsion with a di-isopropylnaphthalene-based liquid scintillator. A Li-6 concentration of 0.15 % by weight was obtained. A 125 mL glass cell was filled with the scintillator and irradiated with fission-source neutrons. Fast n…
▽ More
We report on the development of a fast neutron detector using a liquid scintillator doped with enriched Li-6. The lithium was introduced in the form of an aqueous LiCl micro-emulsion with a di-isopropylnaphthalene-based liquid scintillator. A Li-6 concentration of 0.15 % by weight was obtained. A 125 mL glass cell was filled with the scintillator and irradiated with fission-source neutrons. Fast neutrons may produce recoil protons in the scintillator, and those neutrons that thermalize within the detector volume can be captured on the Li-6. The energy of the neutron may be determined by the light output from recoiling protons, and the capture of the delayed thermal neutron reduces background events. In this paper, we discuss the development of this 6Li-loaded liquid scintillator, demonstrate the operation of it in a detector, and compare its efficiency and capture lifetime with Monte Carlo simulations. Data from a boron-loaded plastic scintillator were acquired for comparison. We also present a pulse-shape discrimination method for differentiating between electronic and nuclear recoil events based on the Matusita distance between a normalized observed waveform and nuclear and electronic recoil template waveforms. The details of the measurements are discussed along with specifics of the data analysis and its comparison with the Monte Carlo simulation.
△ Less
Submitted 22 June, 2011;
originally announced June 2011.
-
Frequentist Coverage Properties of Uncertainty Intervals for Weak Poisson Signals in the Presence of Background
Authors:
K. J. Coakley,
J. D. Splett,
D. S. Simons
Abstract:
We construct uncertainty intervals for weak Poisson signals in the presence of background. We consider the case where a primary experiment yields a realization of the signal plus background, and a second experiment yields a realization of the background. The data acquisitions times for the background-only experiment,T_bg, and the primary experiment,T, are selected so that their ratio varies from…
▽ More
We construct uncertainty intervals for weak Poisson signals in the presence of background. We consider the case where a primary experiment yields a realization of the signal plus background, and a second experiment yields a realization of the background. The data acquisitions times for the background-only experiment,T_bg, and the primary experiment,T, are selected so that their ratio varies from 1 to 25. The expected number of background counts in the primary experiment varies from 0.2 to 2. We construct 90 and 95 percent confidence intervals based on a propagation-of-errors method as well as two implementations of a Neyman procedure where acceptance regions are constructed based on a likelihood-ratio criterion that automatically determines whether the resulting confidence interval is one-sided or two-sided. The first Neyman procedure (due to Feldman and Cousins) neglects uncertainty in the background. In the other Neyman procedure, we account for uncertainty in the background with a parametric bootstrap method. We also construct minimum length Bayesian credibility intervals. For each method, we test for the presence of a signal based on the value of the lower endpoint of the uncertainty interval. When T_bg/T is 5 or more and the expected background is 2 or less, the Feldman Cousins method outperforms the other methods considered.
△ Less
Submitted 27 December, 2009; v1 submitted 24 April, 2008;
originally announced April 2008.
-
Optimal Proton Trapping in a Neutron Lifetime Experiment
Authors:
Kevin J. Coakley
Abstract:
In a neutron lifetime experiment conducted at the National Institute of Standards and Technology, protons produced by neutron decay events are confined in a Penning trap. In each run of the experiment, there is a trapping stage of duration $τ$. After the trapping stage, protons are purged from the trap. A proton detector provides incomplete information because it goes dead after detecting the fi…
▽ More
In a neutron lifetime experiment conducted at the National Institute of Standards and Technology, protons produced by neutron decay events are confined in a Penning trap. In each run of the experiment, there is a trapping stage of duration $τ$. After the trapping stage, protons are purged from the trap. A proton detector provides incomplete information because it goes dead after detecting the first of any purged protons. Further, there is a dead time $δ$ between the end of the trapping stage in one run and the beginning of the next trapping stage in the next run. Based on the fraction of runs where a proton is detected, I estimate the trapping rate $λ$ by the method of maximum likelihood. I show that the expected value of the maximum likelihood estimate is infinite. To obtain a maximum likelihood estimate with a finite expected value and a well-defined and finite variance, I restrict attention to a subsample of all realizations of the data. This subsample excludes an exceedingly rare realization that yields an infinite-valued estimate of $λ$. I present asymptotically valid formulas for the bias, root-mean-square prediction error, and standard deviation of the maximum likelihood estimate of $λ$ for this subsample. Based on nominal values of $λ$ and the dead time $δ$, I determine the optimal duration of the trapping stage $τ$ by minimizing the root-mean-square prediction error of the estimate.
△ Less
Submitted 28 March, 2007; v1 submitted 4 December, 2006;
originally announced December 2006.
-
Spatial methods for event reconstruction in CLEAN
Authors:
Kevin J. Coakley,
Daniel N. McKinsey
Abstract:
In CLEAN (Cryogenic Low Energy Astrophysics with Noble gases), a proposed neutrino and dark matter detector, background discrimination is possible if one can determine the location of an ionizing radiation event with high accuracy. We simulate ionizing radiation events that produce multiple scintillation photons within a spherical detection volume filled with liquid neon. We estimate the radial…
▽ More
In CLEAN (Cryogenic Low Energy Astrophysics with Noble gases), a proposed neutrino and dark matter detector, background discrimination is possible if one can determine the location of an ionizing radiation event with high accuracy. We simulate ionizing radiation events that produce multiple scintillation photons within a spherical detection volume filled with liquid neon. We estimate the radial location of a particular ionizing radiation event based on the observed count data corresponding to that event. The count data are collected by detectors mounted at the spherical boundary of the detection volume. We neglect absorption, but account for Rayleigh scattering. To account for wavelength-shifting of the scintillation light, we assume that photons are absorbed and re-emitted at the detectors. Here, we develop spatial Maximum Likelihood methods for event reconstruction, and study their performance in computer simulation experiments. We also study a method based on the centroid of the observed count data. We calibrate our estimates based on training data.
△ Less
Submitted 4 September, 2003;
originally announced September 2003.
