A Zug comedy of errors: New news about the well-known Neolithic axe blade type Zug from Gotthard-Serpentinite. Part 2: Design, raw material and cultural context After the confusing stories about the discovery and the many mistakes of the...
moreA Zug comedy of errors: New news about the well-known Neolithic axe blade type Zug from Gotthard-Serpentinite. Part 2: Design, raw material and cultural context
After the confusing stories about the discovery and the many mistakes of the eponymous Zug-type blade from Zug-Alpenstrasse 2 in the first part (see KMUZ report, 77-86) have been cleared as far as possible, in the second part cultural context.we deal with the question of how the main character of this comedy of errors came into being, then with the question of its raw material and where it comes from. Finally the axe blade is placed in a larger cultural context.
TPETREQUIN A.-M., PETREQUIN P., ERRERA M., GROSS E. et HUBER R., 2024.- The eponymous axe type Zug. The history of its discovery. Cultural prominence and its raw material from the Gotthard massif. Rapport de recherche, Besançon MSHE C.-N....
moreTPETREQUIN A.-M., PETREQUIN P., ERRERA M., GROSS E. et HUBER R., 2024.- The eponymous axe type Zug. The history of its discovery. Cultural prominence and its raw material from the Gotthard massif. Rapport de recherche, Besançon MSHE C.-N. Ledoux et Gray, Centre de recherche archéologique de la vallée de l'Ain, 23 p., 12 fig., 1 map and inventory, multigraphié.
Abstract
There is some controversy regarding the site and history of discovery of the eponymous axe blade of the type Zug. A reappraisal of the archive material has now ascertained that the axe blade corresponds to the one found in 1867 at Alpenstrasse 2 in Zug. A similar blade was fished out of Lake Zug in 1860 in the very area where the site of Cham-Eslen was discovered in 1996. It was later assumed by some that this had been the eponymous blade of the type Zug; however, it is likely that the blade found at Cham-Eslen corresponds, in fact, to a perforated axe blade that was later mistakenly assumed to be from Unterägeri.
These two axe blades as well as the double axe of Cham-Eslen are early pieces of evidence of the quarrying of Serpentinite in the Gotthard area as well as of the processing of said stone in the lakeside dwellings around Lake Zug during the 5th and 4th millenium BC. Contrary to earlier hypotheses, it would not have been possible to meet the requirements for such a specialised and selective Serpentinite production using only the moraine boulders from within the vicinity of the production centres as raw materials. Geoarchaeological prospection and the comparison between spectroradiometric analyses of the geological and archaeological material established that the raw material of the eponymous axe blade was instead either extracted directly from the Serpentinite lenses in the Gemsstock area or from moraines near those outcrops. The same is true for some very similar axe blades of the type Zug found in the Swiss Plateau and around Lake Constance.
The group of remarkable Serpentinite blades from the Gotthard discussed in this article is closely related to the extraordinary blades from the Breton Carnac sphere which in turn is connected to the Jadeite blade tradition of Monte Viso and Monte Beigua.
Key words : axe type Zug, Neolithic, serpentinite, Gotthard Massif, raw material extraction, history of research, object biography.
For the first time, a large and well-preserved tusk of a late-glacial mammoth from central Switzerland was examined in toto with use of a clinical scanning device featuring an improved design with an 82-cm-wide bore (SOMATOM X.ceed,...
moreFor the first time, a large and well-preserved tusk of a late-glacial mammoth from central Switzerland was examined in toto with use of a clinical scanning device featuring an improved design with an 82-cm-wide bore (SOMATOM X.ceed, Siemens Healthineers). The CT scans showed annual increments of dentin apposition from the central canal. A total of 32 cones were counted, resulting in an estimation of a minimum age of 32 years at the time of death. Please follow link for fulltext:
http://dx.doi.org/10.1148/radiol.220265.
In archaeology, environmental history all too often focused on the individual settlements and on the economic use of their immediate environment. This view fails to acknowledge the importance of other actors (e.g. animals, plants, waters)...
moreIn archaeology, environmental history all too often focused on the individual settlements and on the economic use of their immediate environment. This view fails to acknowledge the importance of other actors (e.g. animals, plants, waters) interacting with humans. Outside the settlements, the traces of humans and these other actors are entangled and become difficult to discern. This is especially true for processes in deltas, which are inherently dynamic, complex, short-lived and fragmented. The life and activities of humans in such areas can only be properly assessed if the habitat as a whole with all its actors is understood and a long-term perspective is adopted. Due to intensive construction work in the Lorze Delta since the 1980s, the archaeological department of Canton Zug has carried out a number of excavations. However, only now has the basic information about the sites (e.g. location, sediments and dating) been more broadly compiled and the results of the different studies been collated. This has led to ground-breaking insights into the cultural and natural interactions in the catchment area of the Lorze River. In the early stages of the Lorze Delta during the Late Glacial and Early Holocene, after the melting of the Reuss Glacier, the only just populated landscape was characterised by unstable geological conditions. When analysing Neolithic and Bronze Age pile dwellings, understanding the Lorze Delta’s formation is a prerequisite for appreciating the sites’ location. In the alluvial fan, long-term changes in human and riverine activity from the Bronze Age to the Middle Ages can be detected. Today, human impact instead of geological processes write the delta’s story: the river course has been diverted to give way for a motorway while the delta itself has been altered artificially.
In archaeology, environmental history all too often focused on the individual settlements and on the economic use of their immediate environment. This view fails to acknowledge the importance of other actors (e.g. animals, plants, waters)...
moreIn archaeology, environmental history all too often focused on the individual settlements and on the economic use of their immediate environment. This view fails to acknowledge the importance of other actors (e.g. animals, plants, waters) interacting with humans. Outside the settlements, the traces of humans and these other actors are entangled and become difficult to discern. This is especially true for processes in deltas, which are inherently dynamic, complex, short-lived and fragmented. The life and activities of humans in such areas can only be properly assessed if the habitat as a whole with all its actors is understood and a long-term perspective is adopted.
Due to intensive construction work in the Lorze Delta since the 1980s, the archaeological department of Canton Zug has carried out a number of excavations. However, only now has the basic information about the sites (e.g. location, sediments and dating) been more broadly compiled and the results of the different studies been collated. This has led to ground-breaking insights into the cultural and natural interactions in the catchment area of the Lorze River.
In the early stages of the Lorze Delta during the Late Glacial and Early Holocene, after the melting of the Reuss Glacier, the only just populated landscape was characterised by unstable geological conditions. When analysing Neolithic and Bronze Age pile dwellings, understanding the Lorze Delta’s formation is a prerequisite for appreciating the sites’ location. In the alluvial fan, long-term changes in human and riverine activity from the Bronze Age to the Middle Ages can be detected. Today, human impact instead of geological processes write the delta’s story: the river course has been diverted to give way for a motorway while the delta itself has been altered artificially.
Introduction to a series of papers representing some of the contributions to a session with the same title, organised by the authors together with Ekaterina Dolbunova, Tryfon Giagkoulis and Goce Naumov, at the 25th Meeting of the European...
moreIntroduction to a series of papers representing some of the contributions to a session with the same title, organised by the authors together with Ekaterina Dolbunova, Tryfon Giagkoulis and Goce Naumov, at the 25th Meeting of the European Association of Archaeologists (EAA), 4-7 September 2019, in Bern. Abstracts of all the presentations can be found on the following web page:
https://www.e-a-a.org/EAA2019/Programme.aspx?Program=3#Program; the papers are published open access here:
https://www.dguf.de/earlyview.htmlA small exhibition near their find spot shows the remains of the Rotkreuz mammoth bones and tusk found in 2015. In addition to display cases containing the finds and panels with text and images, the exhibition links to interactive 3D...
moreA small exhibition near their find spot shows the remains of the Rotkreuz mammoth bones and tusk found in 2015. In addition to display cases containing the finds and panels with text and images, the exhibition links to interactive 3D models of the bones derived from CT scans (accessible via
https://skfb.ly/6BRT6). These can be 3D printed and used in museum education.
B. Bigler, R. Huber, J. Reinhard, G. Pegurri, Ein Mammut kehrt zurück. Tugium 35, 2019, 43.
Three elk (Alces alces) bones found in 1955 in Zug-Gartenstadt, Switzerland, two shoulder blades and a tibia fragment, have been analysed anew: They date to the Late Ice Age around 12400 BP (12776-12220 calBC) according to two C14 dates -...
moreThree elk (Alces alces) bones found in 1955 in Zug-Gartenstadt, Switzerland, two shoulder blades and a tibia fragment, have been analysed anew: They date to the Late Ice Age around 12400 BP (12776-12220 calBC) according to two C14 dates - the finds are currently the oldest known elk bones in Switzerland after the Last Glacial Maximum and represent the expansion of elk habitats in the Bølling interstadial. The tibia fragment shows cut marks and has been crushed for bone marrow extraction. The dating of the bones corresponds to late Magdalenian sites in the vincinity.
J. Reinhard, R. Huber, D. Drucker, W. Müller, Von Irrtümern, Übersehenem und moderner Analytik. Neue Erkenntnisse zu den spätglazialen Elchknochen von Zug-Gartenstadt. Tugium 35, 2019, 129-138.
165 years after the discovery of pile dwellings in Switzerland, this meeting in Bern should be an occasion to relate archaeological waterscapes to their surrounding landscapes. Due to their inherent fluidity and their impact on cultural...
more165 years after the discovery of pile dwellings in Switzerland, this meeting in Bern should be an occasion to relate archaeological waterscapes to their surrounding landscapes. Due to their inherent fluidity and their impact on cultural phenomena, waterscapes are destined to make us look beyond rigid paradigms, dichotomies, and categories, in order to dissolve them and merge the results into something new.
Relating and integrating the various aspects of life in waterscapes and landscapes, as well as their transitional areas, creates new and unexpected narratives. Archaeological remains in waterscapes, (in or at lakes and sea, in peatlands, bogs etc.) must be seen in their relationship to and their symbiosis with water. The traditional territorial models, which saw dwellings or infrastructure sites as simply located by the water, limited the field of vision.
In order to understand waterscapes, the microarchaeological frog’s eye perspective, which examines the local aquatic environment, must be supplemented with a broader perspective, for water does not separate – it connects. Thus, archaeological sites must be viewed in relation to the water- and landscapes around them, in relation to each other, and as part of a wide and far-reaching network of similar relationships.
There is a wide variety of methods (e.g. from the field of landscape archaeology or network analysis) to investigate the relationships between terrestrial and aquatic areas and the transitional fields between them as well as the “amphibious” networks created by them. These networks are the result of a lively, diverse and constantly changing interplay between different actors (humans, animals, plants and other matters), factors, and forces. The focus of this session is on this interplay between water and land as well as its specific taphonomical, ecological, economical, climatic and cultural factors (which may result in pollution or overexploitation) regardless of restricting time or space frames.
In 2015 the skeletal remains of a late glacial bull mammoth, approximately 17,000 years old, were discovered in Risch-Rotkreuz (Canton Zug, Switzerland, location:
https://s.geo.admin.ch/7d5a3a861a), see
https://goo.gl/b2bX2D for the original publication. In the meantime bones and tusk have been analysed both for stable isotopes and aDNA. The results for the stable isotopes point to a cold area context in which the Rotkreuz mammoth occupied the typical niche of its species in the "mammoth steppe" ecosystem. aDNA results (see
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/nuccore/MH158736) show that the Rotkreuz mammoth belonged to clade I, as expected due to its age; and establish it as the next known "relative" to the mammoth from Kesslerloch cave (Canton Schaffhausen, Switzerland). In addition conservation of the mammoth remains has now been completed which allowed a documentation via computed tomography, in order to examine the structure of the tusk as well as a 3D documentation of all the finds (see
https://skfb.ly/6BRT6).
D. Drucker, A. Furtwängler, V. Schünemann, R. Huber, J. Reinhard, Durchleuchtet und analysiert. Ein Update zur Genetik, Isotopie und Radiografie des "letzten Zuger Mammuts". Tugium 34, 2018, 123-131.
The Roman villa rustica of Cham-Heiligkreuz (Canton Zug, Switzerland; see
https://goo.gl/9qtK7w for its location on a map) was partly excavated in the 1930ies. The exact position of the excavation trenches has been debated for a long time...
moreThe Roman villa rustica of Cham-Heiligkreuz (Canton Zug, Switzerland; see
https://goo.gl/9qtK7w for its location on a map) was partly excavated in the 1930ies. The exact position of the excavation trenches has been debated for a long time and was only reconstructed in 1993 using archival data. This placement has now been verified by a combination of geomagnetic survey and aerial infrared photography even though the location of the villa's pars urbana is still unknown. Furthermore, numerous snow marks seem to show a network of (mostly undated, presumably post medieval and/or modern) paths and tracks in the area.
J. Reinhard, Chr. Rinne, R. Huber, Spurensuche mit Infrarotkamera, Metalldetektor und Magnetometer. Zur römischen villa rustica von Cham-Lindencham, Heiligkreuz. Tugium 34, 2018, 117-122 (for an additional 3D model see
https://skfb.ly/6BRQP).
The approach to analyse Neolithic settlement structures only on a strict scale of ‘house – farmstead – village‘ is unrewarding in our opinion. Even individualisation, and therefore reconstruction, of separate houses in Neolithic wetland...
moreThe approach to analyse Neolithic settlement structures only on a strict scale of ‘house – farmstead – village‘ is unrewarding in our opinion. Even individualisation, and therefore reconstruction, of separate houses in Neolithic wetland sites is much more problematic than commonly assumed (e.g. distinction of architectural units, rate of dated vs. undated piles, scarce evidence for superstructures and their connection to the house layout). Many current reconstructions of houses and village layouts are mostly based on unproven presumptions. Taphonomic complexity in wetland layers is so difficult to understand that trivial connections between layers and architectural structures cannot be assumed. Concerning its basic hypothesis and the consequential economical and social implications, this paper focuses on discussing settlement patterns in the Canton of Zug (Switzerland) and highlighting two examples of current research in pile dwellings at Lake Zug (Cham-Eslen), Zug-Riedmatt. The high density of (potentially) contemporary sites in certain periods as well as the evidence of specialised ‒ and possibly only or predominantly seasonal ‒ lake dwellings speak in favour of complex patterns of settlement, exploitation and communication structured on a large scale as opposed to small, economically autarchic and self-contained village units. Hence we would like to contrast the traditional hierarchical model (‘house – farmstead – village‘), based on historic analogies, incorrectly perceived as obvious, with a relational network-model, which is close-knit especially in the bodies of water as lifelines (routes of transport and communication, important food resources). This approach opens a broad interpretive framework regarding the results of many disciplines like archaeology of economies, demography and settlement geography.
Key words
archaeology; lake dwelling; pile dwelling; wetland site; low-level food production; autarky; network model; bodies of water as
lifelines; seasonality
Aufgrund unserer Erfahrungen mit zirkumalpinen Ufersiedlungen stellen wir den Ansatz, Siedlungsstrukturen des Neolithikums auf der Skala ‘Haus – Hof – Dorf‘ untersuchen zu wollen, grundsätzlich in Frage. Nur schon die Ansprache und infolgedessen die Rekonstruktion einzelner Gebäude ist im Ufersiedlungsneolithikum problematischer als es ein erster Blick auf die Forschungslage suggerieren mag: Die Abgrenzung der architektonischen Einheiten zueinander, der Anteil datierter bzw. undatierter Pfähle, mangelhafte Informationen zur Gestaltung des Oberbaus bzw. dessen Bezug zum Grundriss – all diese Umstände erschweren die Lesbarkeit der Pfahlpläne. Viele der aktuellen Rekonstruktionen von Einzelhäusern sowie von gesamten Siedlungsplänen beruhen auf unbewiesenen Vorannahmen. Die taphonomischen Probleme in den Ufersiedlungen erweisen sich als derart komplex, dass ein Zusammenhang zwi-schen Schichteinheiten und architektonischen Strukturen nicht einfach und eindeutig hergestellt werden kann. Diese Skizze muss sich bezüglich der Grundthese und den wirtschaftlichen und gesellschaftlichen Konsequenzen auf die Diskussion der Fundverteilung im Kan-ton Zug (Schweiz) und hier auf zwei aktuelle Beispiele, nämlich die Ufersiedlungen Cham-Eslen und Zug-Riedmatt, beschränken. Die zum Teil hohe Dichte von (potentiell oder tatsächlich) gleichzeitigen und die Nachweise von spezialisierten (möglicherweise ausschliesslich oder schwergewichtig saisonal genutzten) Siedlungsplätzen an den Seeufern sprechen für komplex und grossräumig strukturierte Sied-lungs-, Nutzungs- und Kommunikationsmuster und nicht für kleinräumig territorial organisierte, ökonomisch autarke, in sich abgeschlosse-ne Dorfeinheiten. Deshalb möchten wir dem traditionell hierarchischen Modell (‘Haus – Hof – Dorf‘), das sich an uns naheliegenden histo-rischen Analogien orientiert, ein relationales Netzwerk-Modell gegenüberstellen, das sich im Bereich der Gewässer als Lebensadern, als Verkehrs- und Kommunikationswege und als Quelle wichtiger Nahrungsressourcen besonders dicht knüpft. Dieser Ansatz öffnet den Interpretationsrahmen in Bezug auf die Untersuchungsergebnisse zahlreicher Disziplinen wie Wirtschaftsarchäologie, Demographie oderSiedlungsgeographie.
Schlüsselwörter
– Archäologie; Seeufersiedlung; Pfahlbau; Feuchtbodenfundstelle; Low-Level Food Production; Autarkie; Netzwerkmodell; Gewässer als Lebensadern; Saisonalität
In July 2015, a tusk and several bone fragments of an adult mammoth bull have been unearthed on a construction site in Risch-Rotkreuz, Canton Zug, Central Switzerland. The perfectly preserved skeletal elements have been dated to the end...
moreIn July 2015, a tusk and several bone fragments of an adult mammoth bull have been unearthed on a construction site in Risch-Rotkreuz, Canton Zug, Central Switzerland. The perfectly preserved skeletal elements have been dated to the end of the last ice age at around 15'000 BC by AMS radiocarbon measurements, which is interesting also from the point of view of regional geology. The discovery of the mammoth remains, that are among the youngest ones currently known in Switzerland entailed international media coverage. See
https://skfb.ly/LsnA for a mammoth skeleton 3D model with bones preserved in Rotkreuz marked in red.
Im Juli 2015 wurden auf einer Baustelle in Risch-Rotkreuz, im zentralschweizerischen Kanton Zug, ein Stosszahn und mehrere Knochenfragmente eines adulten Mammutbullen ausgegraben. AMS-Radiokarbondatierungen stellen die hervorragend erhaltenen Skelettteile ans Ende der letzten Eiszeit um 15'000 BC, was auch aus regionalgeologischer Perspektive interessant ist. Die Entdeckung der Mammutreste, die zu den jüngsten momentan in der Schweiz bekannten gehören, fand internationales Medienecho. Auf
https://skfb.ly/TPAW ist das 3D-Modell eines Mammut-Skeletts verfügbar, auf dem die in Rotkreuz erhaltenen Knochen rot eingefärbt sind.
RefDoc Bienvenue - Welcome. Refdoc est un service / is powered by. ...
Zusammenfassung: Die Rettungsgrabungen auf der Rothuswiese in Zug (2001-2003) haben aussergewöhnlich gut erhaltene Funde und Befunde aus der Mittelbronzezeit geliefert. Zwei nebeneinanderliegende Gruben mit einer komplexen Schichtabfolge...
moreZusammenfassung: Die Rettungsgrabungen auf der Rothuswiese in Zug (2001-2003) haben aussergewöhnlich gut erhaltene Funde und Befunde aus der Mittelbronzezeit geliefert. Zwei nebeneinanderliegende Gruben mit einer komplexen Schichtabfolge und einer grossen Menge an Keramik und anderen Objekten wurden bereits untersucht. Die vorliegende Teilauswertung lässt bereits das grosse Potenzial der Fundstelle erahnen.
Fünf vollständige Gefässprofile und weitere grosse Gefässfragmente ermöglichen eine für mittelbronzezeitliche Siedlungen differenzierte Ansprache der Gefässformen. Zudem erlaubt die qualitätvolle Grabungsdokumentation eine detaillierte Befundanalyse, welche wiederum eine Deutung ermöglicht, die über das lnterpretationskonzept "Abfallgrube" hinausgeht.
Résumé: Les fouilles de sauvetage au lieu-dit Rothuswiese à Zug (2001- 2003) ont livré des restes et des structures extrêmement bien conservés du Bronze Moyen. Les deux fosses fouillées, situées côte à côte, contenaient une grande quantité de céramiques et d'autres objets répartis à travers une stratigraphie complexe. Les résultats partiels présentés ici permettent d'apprécier le fort potentiel de ce site.
Cinq profils céramiques complets et d'autres tessons de grande taille autorisent une approche renouvelée des formes céramiques en contexte d'habitat du Bronze moyen. En outre, la qualité exceptionnelle des relevés de terrain permet une analyse détaillée des structures, ce qui mène à une interprétation qui déborde largement du concept de „fosses-dépotoirs".
Riassunto: Gli scavi d'emergenza sulla Rothuswiese a Zugo (2001-2003) hanno portato alla luce ritrovamenti e reperti del Bronzo medio, sorprendentemente ben conservati. Finora sono state analizzate due fosse affiancate, caratterizzate da una sequenza stratigrafica complessa e grandi quantità di ceramica e altri reperti. L'analisi presente lascia intuire il grande potenziale del sito.
Cinque profili completi di ceramiche e altri grandi frammenti permettono una, per il Bronzo medio, precisa caratterizzazione delle forme ceramiche. Inoltre la documentazione minuziosa dello scavo consente un'analisi dettagliata dei ritrovamenti, Ia quale a sua volta rende possibile una lettura che va al di Ià del concetto di "fossa per rifiuti".
Summary: The rescue excavations that took place at Rothuswiese in Zug (2001-2003) brought to light exceptionally well preserved Middle Bronze Age finds and features. Two pits found next to each other with a complex sequence of layers and large amounts of pottery and other artefacts have already been studied. The partial analysis presented here hints at the considerable potential of this site.
Five complete vessel profiles and other large fragments of vessels have allowed us to identify the shapes of the vessels to an unusually high degree in Middle Bronze Age settlements. Moreover, the excellent excavation records have allowed us to carry out a detailed study of the archaeological features, which in turn enables us to arrive at an interpretation that transcends the "rubbish pit" concept.